Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

It's the thought that counts

Socialist Organiser no. 502, 10 October 1991 · scan p. 15 · about 679 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 15 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 15

The Time and Space of Uncle Albert* is about the adventures of a girl, Gedanken, and her Uncle Albert.

These adventures take place in the head of Uncle Albert or, rather, in the almost tangible thought bubble that hovers above his head as he sits in his favourite armchair.

What starts off these adventures is Gedanken's search for a subject for her school science project. Dinosaurs and volcanoes have already been taken and electricity in the home seems rather boring so Gedanken appeals to her uncle for suggestions, The topic of light and its incredible speed crops up in conversation (as it would) and suddenly Albert has an idea. Gedanken can find out how light behaves for her project. For this she will need a space craft powerful enough to catch up a light beam. Is uncle joking? No!

He will think one up in his thought bubble and Gedanken can climb aboard and pilot it. All goes well and Gedanken finds herself "first captain" "the largest spacecraft that has never been built" , courtesy of Uncle Albert's powerful imagination.

A light beam goes past and Gedanken instructs the computer to accelerate to the same speed ie. the speed of light. The computer does the relevant calculations and the ship accelerates but it seems to Gedanken that the light beam is still travelling away at the same rate.

Why hasn't the ship got up to the speed of the light beam? She checks the speedometer. The spacecraft is travelling at 9/10ths of the speed of light relative to the Earth. Surely the light should have a speed relative to the craft of only 1/10th of the speed of light.

The computer puts the ship's engines on full power. After what seems an age, the light beam is still receding at the same speed relative to the craft though the speedometer is reading 0.999 of the speed of light relative to the Earth.

When Gedanken returns to Earth (ie. when Uncle stops thinking), she tells him of her strange and rather frustrating findings. To her surprise, Uncle Albert was expecting something of the sort. He explains to her that light is very special in that its movement is integral to what it is. There is no such thing as light standing still. An observer who was travelling at the speed of light would see light standing still and therefore no observer can travel at the speed of light.

But the imaginary space craft had enough power to accelerate itself to the speed of light so why didn't it reach that speed? The answer according to Uncle Albert was that, as it went faster, it became more massive, taking more force to accelerate it. It could never reach the speed of light because that would mean it had infinite mass and required an infinite force.

Readers may find this starting to sound familiar and in fact this book is an extremely clever, because SO simple, elucidation of (Uncle) Albert Einstein's theory of relativity. Other peculiar but true predictions of Einstein's theory covered in Gedanken's later voyages in Uncle Albert's thought bubble include the slowing of time and the shortening of lengths at high speeds, the relativity of motion (when someone is cycling along a road, are they moving or is it the rest of the universe? There is no absolute way of telling) and the relativity of time (events simultaneous for one observer may not be so for another).

Though written for children, this book has much to teach any reader about the bizarre nature of reality. Incidentally, "gedanken" is the German for "thought" Einstein's typical means of investigation being the "thought (gedanken) experiment"

Incidentally, Gedanken only gets a B for her project. Rather cheekily, she sets a test on it for her teacher which readers are invited to try.

I'm now looking forward to reading Black Holes and Uncle Albert.

* By Russell Stannard, Professor of Physics at the Open University. Faber & Faber, 2.99. Suitable for readers of 10 years and upwards.

----- pull-quotes -----

LES HEARN'S COLUMN

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 502

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →