Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

What is Stalinism

Socialist Organiser no. 502, 10 October 1991 · scan pp. 14–15 · about 1,278 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 14 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 14

hemcnilapsenai Simihikms s@nhais moriewep an l appnca This was tiez (rem nikd. Kremlinne lite: :a tncomerai iorw00wyearв:xaleo se wergio te workensi stage!'?

Bin shexSonica ndnionnnas

-pesedlshesp mins iono nu soctäilie frowl ignt end liA Te pywan achmaliy enisting" Tndbei., naybe,: detpamed, bureauara tiserd жапигре embodiment olsoiism.

Tis nowa irenecimol Dy une xankerseotithenSRwand astern Europenwnia li MamMIOLSa neUred Wasi che eystem w'ow! The last 40 years number of facts are unmisA takeable from the evidence of the last 40 years, central to clear assessment of the struggles in the Eastern Bloc, yet obscured by or difficult to reconcile with the "deformed and degenerated workers' states" codification.

1. The position of the working class in the command economies is generally worse than in the market economies. Low rents and food prices, and fairly full employment, do make the poorest in the Eastern Bloc better off than in the West. Yet average working-class living standards are lower, even at the same level of general indüstrial development.

Work conditions, despite the sluggish pace of work in many Eastern Bloc factories much of the time, are worse. And - centrally -the ruling bureaucracies repress all independent organisation by the working class. LISOCaAISOI= -Me6N 10 A VGI:, WE most ilirotsk ykstoargmed while calling diora lennew obationaru o vartimrora oMihe Sociolic/mi Urgarer mir anguedi phauni • wası mona wrle we reprint an excerpt from the statemem inwe rublishonEo 19801, arher we ipalle rapydiawcrim he «dagoneream worlers astote Tornun ay-Wie weltomeronheremontmbuimans di tirer ne wed balemnp wn opessary on wihe neturenof Slanfsm.

South Korea is a society based on ruthless exploitation and brutal repression: yet is has allowed some openings for trade unions to develop against the odds. North Korea has allowed no such openings. The contrast between the two Koreas reflects the general picture.

And this is not an extraordinary situation of acute short-term crisis - as the position in the USSR in the '30s could perhaps be viewed at the time. It is a stable pattern over 40, 50 or 60 years.

The command economies have built up large and powerful working classes, working classes which have shown tremendous socialist potential. In that sense they have created preconditions for socialism. But in their repression of the working class socialism than many market are further away from economies.

2. The development of the productive forces may be progressive even if the immediate results for the workers are bad. Many post-1951 Trotskyists have let the goal of working-class self-liberation be obscured by the goal of national economic development, because that national economic development is where the "workers' states" are supposed to display their superiority over market capitalism. Some command economies have indeed developed industry fast.

But so — since 1945 - have many market economies. The command economies can certainly show no general, clear superiority over the market economies in developing the forces of production. Indeed, relative stagnation in the USSR and Eastern Europe is now the starting point for Gorbachev's reforms./ The command economies are not a stage beyond capitalism in developing the productive forces. Rather, they have emerged from underdeveloped capitalist societies with a big load of pre-capitalist or colonialist dross, and done broadly the same work as capitalist development.

A cooperative commonwealth — a nationalised economy planned under workers' democracy — will produce more efficiently and distribute more equally than any market economy ever can. We have no reason to doubt that.

But the sort of nationalised economy that exists in the Eastern Bloc has no superiority in the conditions it creates for the workers, nor superiority in long-term development of the productive forces.

3. Outside the USSR, the ruling bureaucracies are not usurpers of the nationalised economies: they created them. They did not create them because mass pressure forced them to do so against their will. They created them according to their own wishes and designs.

The bureaucracies are not acutely unstable. For 40 to 50 years they have been stably self-reproducing organisms. If we do not call them "ruling classes", it can only be on a technicality.

Although sometimes when in power the bureaucracies seek to recruit individuals from the working class, the core of these bureaucracies is certainly not a segment or a product of the working class. They come from the middle class. Perhaps nowhere is this seen more plainly than in Afghanistan, where a very large part of the middle class and the military and technical intelligentsia tried, in the 1978 coup and after, to transform themselves into a bureaucracy on the USSR model.

Trotsky spoke of the Kremlin bureaucracy as balancing between its social and economic base and the pressure of capitalist imperialism. Such a view is no longer tenable.

The USSR is the second world power. In Vietnam, China and elsewhere the bureaucratised revolutionary forces were able to defeat the old order and beat down the working class simultaneously. Even while they were revolutionary against the old order, they were simultaneously counterrevolutionary against the working -4. The USSR does not correspond exactly to Lenin's picture of imperialism in his 1916 pamphlet. But then neither does any other country today. Today we commonly use the word "imperialism" in a wider sense than did Lenin, for whom "imperialism" started only around 1898-1902. In that broader sense of the word "imperialism" the US, Britain etc. are imperialist - and so is the USSR.

Nearly 50 years ago Trotsky wrote: "The driving force behind the Moscow bureaucracy is indubitably the tendency to expand its power, its prestige, its revenues. This is the element of 'imperialism' in the widest sense of the word which was a property in the past of all monarchies, oligarchies, ruling casses, medieval estates and Today the USSR has in Eastern Europe an empire with over 100 million subjects. You can deny that the USSR is imperialist only by saying that imperialism is only the form of monopoly-capitalistimperialism described by Lenin, and nothing else. And that would be to deny the existence of the Athenian and Roman, the Spanish and Ottoman empires, or indeed of the British Empire for all but 70 or so of its 300-year life.

The conflict between the US and the USSR is chiefly about competition for spheres of influence and control, rather than a dispute of market economy versus nationalised economy.

It is time to reassess. It is time to examine the idea that the Eastern Bloc states are exploiting economies essentially parallel, as regards the development of the forces of production, to market capitalism. We are for: • Disbandment of the police and armed forces, and their renlacement by a people's militia. • Breaking up the bureaucratic hierarchy of administration, and replacing it with a democratic regime of councils of elected and recallable workers' delegates, with freedom to form many political parties. • Workers' control in industry. Free trade unions. • Abolition of bureaucratic privileges; reorganisation of the economy according to a democratically-decided plan. • Abolition of the bureaucracy's monopoly over information; freedom for working-class newspapers, meetings, radio and TV stations, etc.

We are for nationalisation of the major means of production. But what exists now in the Eastern Bloc is no form of socialism. Nationalisation is a means to an end -working class liberation from economic exploitation of those who control the means of production. That is not achieved when the nationalised economy and the monopolising state are in effect the property of a ruling elite whose upper layers lord it over society as the aristocrats and capitalists do elsewhere.

We advocate the replacement of the system of nationalised economy under a state-monopoly bureaucracy with a socialised economy under the democratic control of the working class.

Scan page 15

NDUSTRI

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 502

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →