Open letter Clare Short
Socialist Organiser1991 1991-10-10Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 11 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 11
LONDON FO @ ADERVASON ou've made yourself a new role in recent months. You have become a sort of unofficial TV spokeperson for the NEC on the purge of the Militant, explaining to cameras month after month why you support expulsions. And you were the only NEC member to attempt — in Tribun — a written justification of last year's ban on Socialist Organiser. No doubt the party managers reckon that your reputation as a bit of a rebel makes you more effective in the role of justifying purges.
You say that there is no option but to purge Militant supporters after they have stood against Labour in Walton and the Liverpool council elections, and declared their intention to stand against Labour in the future.
It is true that there is no way of stopping Militant's leaders breaking away from Labour if they want to. But this is the "good reason" for the purge, not the real reason. Left-wingers were being purged long before Walton. Left-wingers are being purged now who have no connection at all with Militant or the Walton affair -Socialist Organiser supporters, for example:
And the NEC has double standards. The rightwing MP Frank Field publicly refused to support the official Labour candidate in the constituency next door to his at the 1987 election; he has advocated "tactical voting" for Liberal and Alliance candidates; and he has threatened to resign his seat, force a by-election, and stand against Labour. Far from being expelled, he has had the NEC intervening heavily against his constituency party when it was dissatisfied with him.
It's one law for the right wing and another for If Militant's leaders are determined to break away from the Labour Party - or to put it another way, they have become so fed-up with the Kinnock leadership's harassment that they have given up - the job of any serious socialist in the Labour Party is to minimise the split. We should do all we can — and go easy on the strict letter of rules if necessary — to stop good left-wingers going with Lesley Mahmood and Peter Taaffe. The NEC has done the opposite.
It has used Walton to try to throw out or drive out as many good left-wingers as possible. You can see the results in Liverpool: two breakaway "Labour Parties" (the "Independent Labour Party" and Militant's "Real Labour"), and the official Labour Party reduced to a rightwing rump. No doubt the rump is easier for Walworth Road to control than a genuine, broad Maybe you will say that excluding factions like Militant (and Socialist Organiser) is necessary in order to create a civilised Labour Party where people like you can voice constructive dissent on issues like Ireland. I've heard that argument before - 20 years ago when 1 and some others (a couple of whom are involved in Socialist Organiser today were expelled from the SWP. SWP "loyal dissidents" said that they agreed with us orthodox Trotskyists" on many issues, but our approach was wrong - too factional, too rough. Exclude us, and there could be a civilised democracy.
Within four years almost all those "loyal dissidents" had been excluded in their turn, and the SWP had been transformed into the lifeless, regimented sect it is today.
It's going the same way in the Labour Party. Jo Richardson threw in her lot with Kinnock. Was the right wing grateful? Not at all. This year they have pushed her off the NEC in favour of Gerald Kaufman. Are the right wing grateful to you for your services? Not at all. The EETPU is now out to get you deselected.
The purge now underway — if it is not stopped - will leave the Labour Party not as a civilised democracy but as a lifeless, stampeddown, one-faction party. No wonder a few left wingers are looking to the SWP — be it a lifeless sect, it is at least a lifeless sect with some spark and militancy about it.
Some people on the NEC probably don't care. Ideas, debate, campaigning they can do without, as long as Hugh Hudson can turn out slick TV commercials and they get a chance of a job as a Minister. I hope you still think the Labour Party is about more than that.
----- pull-quotes -----
to THE POLI CA FRONT