Those who do not
Socialist Organiser1991 1991-10-10Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 11 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 11
tightly-controlled right-wing voted for. stitution. The move was defeated wing tide of the '50s, centred on skellites controlled the Party in Hugh Gaitskell (above) ran a regime in the Labour Party 30 years ago, during the last long period of Tory rule.
about the "bourgeoisification" of he had made his peace with the working class and the end of Labour's establishment.
class politics.
An MP like Michael Foot, whose colour was never exactly flaming Trotskyist red, could be expelled from the Parliamentary Labour Party in 1961 for abstaining on take a step at a time. Maybe in the end we'll get chucked out anyway. In that case it'll be solved for us. It would be far better to be thrown out, if we are going to be thrown out, as an organised force of people working together for basic socialist ideas, than to go out as individuals one at a time with no perspectives.
But you know the history of the Marxist movement. You mentioned the SDF at the founding of the Labour Party. They had come along with their programme to a conference which was dominated by Liberal trade unionists. They made a motion that it be accepted and when, predictably, it was not accepted, they walked out. Isn't it true that Marxist tradition in this country has been a heavily sectarian tradition? The consequence is that we've left the mass movement to the right wing and the soft left. Isn't that the dominant trend? Isn't that one of the problems we have to face now - a resurgence of self-defeating sectarianism in response to Kinnock?
Yes. I think I've made that clear in all the books I've written. Had the SDF remained in the Labour Party it might have been a difTory defence estimates. Labour ownership from the Party conBy the early '60s the big left- but it was clear that the GaitAneurin Bevan, had ebbed away. all essentials.
However, tensions were bubbling below the surface. From 195 When Labour lost the 1959 (above) the Aldermaston marches General Election, the Gaitskellites focussed a growing campaign immediately launched a drive to against nuclear weapons. do what the German Social The left won a victory at ScarDemocratic Party had done that borough in 1960 when the giant. same year at Bad Godesberg and block vote of the TGWU, led by drop all commitment to public Frank Cousins, carried a decision ferent party.
Isn't that sectarian tradition also to be found in the Communist Party in the '20s when they didn't want to stay in the Labour Party? Formally they wanted to stay, but in practice they didn't.
It was very different circumstances. The Soviet Union was coming into existence, the Communist International.
But the Labour Party was a mass movement which varied very much ideologically. There was pretty free political competition within it. You had Christian Socialists, Marxists, and Fabians - and the serious revolutionaries outside, largely because they excluded themselves.
Because it was a wrong tactic then, it may not be the wrong tactic always.
No, but there is this powerful sectarian tradition.
Yes. It is quite clear that the ILP made a mess of it in 1932 in coming out. But then the ILP had a lot of strange people in it.
tendency.
committing Labour to the unilateral abandonment of tain's nuclear bomb.
The Right fought back and won a clinching victory for a pro-nuclear Labour Party at the subst quent conference, in Blackpool in 1961.
But in 1963 Gaitskell died -and the Tories began to look like losers. Labour won the 1964 General Election, and the labour movement entered a period of fierce struggles.
thread through to today. For instance, you mentioned the great struggle in the Labour Party in the '80s. Lots of sectarians chose to stay outside when they could have been immensely valuable inside. The SWP is the clearest example.
I suffered with that in the '50s. I was involved in setting up the Socialist Workers' Federation which was to try to attract people from both the Communist Party and the I'm not being pharasaical. We've made sectarian mistakes as well, in the late '60s, with criminally stupid attitudes in relation to the Labour Party during the attempt to bring in anti-union laws in 1969 and after. But we do have to establish that there is in this country a tradition, a persistent tendency to sectarianism. Of course, you are right, the world is changing. We may all be expelled. We may have no choice.
I don't think we should be advocating that people leave the Labour Party. We shouldn't be calling for a new party. We should concentrate on building up a good genuinely left wing movement within the Labour Party.
Scan page 12
Socialist Organiser No. 502 page 12
----- pull-quotes -----
learn from history are condemnea to relive it relive