Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Socialists should not leave the

Socialist Organiser no. 502, 10 October 1991 · scan pp. 10–11 · about 1,759 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 10

Those who stood Lesley Mahmood against Labour in the Walton by-election last July claimed that they were the "true heirs" of Eric Heffer. Heffer's thinking on socialists and the Labour Party is established in this discussion he had with John Bloxam and John O'Mahony last year.

We've reached the stage where we have to reassess not just our / labour movement here, but throughout the whole of the capitalist world.

It's not happening just in Britain. We aren't even the first. It began immediately after the war in West Germany, then France, Belgium, Italy and — after the Franco dictatorship - in Spain, the Spanish Socialist PartySo what do we do? Some believe the answer is to fight within the Labour Party and if we do, then in a few years' time the party will swing back our way. I don't really know, but I think there will be change in the Labour Party, and I think there will be a move back to more left-wing concepts.

We have to begin to renew not only the party but the movement as a whole. I think it has to be done almost from scratch. We've got to go out again and begin with a lot of things. We've got to start socialist educational groups throughout the entire country.

I think we've got to have socialist education on a big scale, such as we've not had for a long, long time. We have to produce more and more pamphlets - discussion pamphlets which don't deal just with the immediate issues, though obviously they have to be related to immediate issues, but which have an underlying socialist message.

This is what has got to be done. We've got. to work in the Labour Party, but we've got to Eric Heffer at the Labour Party conference rostrum work outside the Labour Party as well. ! think there is a movement out there. I don't particularly like every aspect of it, but I think we have to be in it.

I'm thinking of the Socialist Movement. Some of it is just pure straightforward academic elitism, but nevertheless, I think it does attract people. We've got to get involved in it, and discuss with them. Possibly something will emerge out of that. Possibly.

We've got to have a look at what we've been arguing for over the years. We've got to learn the lessons of the Soviet Union and Eastern Europe. We must argue very strongly for the democratic control of industry by the working people themselves. But - and I think this is fundamental - there has got to be a much greater effort towards a basic socialist educational message if we are ever going to be able to rebuild a powerful mass socialist movement.

You seem to believe that there was a Golden Age" when the party was bigger, more socialist, with more workers in parliament. Now you seem to say that the roots are being cut away.

No, I've never thought there was a golden age of Labour Party socialism. The Labour Party was created not as a socialist organisation, but as a broad working-class organisation. At the first conference, in 1900, the Social Democratic Federation moved that the party should be socialist. That was defeated. It was decided that Labour should be a party for working class representation in the House of Commons. That was carried because it was the trade unions that created the Labour Party.

Yet, when you read the speeches and listen to the arguments, there's a very powerful socialist influence in the Labour Party. In 1918 the party got a more or less socialist constitution. It was always a reformist socialist party; but it did have socialist perspectives, and not just the idea of bureaucratically nationalising everything through the state. It talked of social and public ownership in varied forms.

The idea of a vast bureaucratic state-run society came from Fabians like Beatrice Webb and Sydney Webb. It was no accident that when the Webbs went to Russia in the '30s they came back and wrote a book praising Soviet society as "a new civilisation"

When I was young I couldn't understand how those Fabian reformists and intellectuals could so praise the Soviet Union. Later I realised that Stalinism appealed to them because they too knew what was good for the workers, whether the workers wanted it or not.

So, no golden age. But I think better age.

But what happened was not that the Labour Party became socialist in 1918 with the adoption of Clause Four and the reorganisation of the party. Even right-wingers declared for "socialism", but only to head off a far more left-wing drive, stimulated by the war and the Russian Revolution and seen in such things as the very representative Leeds Convention of July 1917 which called for Soviets in Britain. That is largely true, but the party itself was. also affected. Even the Fabian Society, with its "New Fabians" like GDH Cole, was preaching workers' control. All right, it was reformist. But there was a real difference, and it did affect the party.

You could see it in the party members when I first became involved. OK, yes, they thought everything was done through parliament, but you only had to be in their company for ten minutes to realise that they were real socialists. Their whole attitude was different.

I recently saw an article in a magazine about Jackie and Billy Charlton, which illustrates my point. Jackie Charlton said: *When I was young I could argue strongly for the Labour Party and Labour politics. Now I don't know what they believe in. And I can't argue that any more."

Charlton would have been brought up in the North East, an area where they are very loyal to the Labour Party. Whatever the leadership said, they did. But on the North East coast you found the mass of workers loyal not just to the party but to concepts which were basically socialist, to working class solidarity. That, I think, is the difference.

Why did that loyalty dissipate? Why did so little come of it? Why did the right wing always get away with faking. There's always been a "faking culture", hasn't there? You said yourself that people come into the House of Commons reflecting their party, and then when the pressure is off they don't carry on with the same opinions. That is a faking culture. Why did all that generally socialist working-class consciousness lead to what it has led to?

In the last 20 or 30 years there's no longer been the educational effort that there used to be. Speakers used to come regularly and talk about the labour movement and the unions, and about socialist ideas. It was accepted as part of the life of the union. That's died The National Council of Labour Colleges was absorbed into the TUC and killed stone various programmes, and issue pamphlets on wage labour and capital, on how you seized power, and so on. They educated a layer of workers. I'm in favour of all the socialist papers, because they help to keep the flame alive. But there is so much confusion! With so many competing socialist groups, people don't know where to go.

There's been no education. But it's not only that. Circumstances have changed. With the growth of the welfare state, a lot of the pressure on workers to build a new society was eliminated — not entirely, and it needn't have been at all if there had been a movement capable of giving a continuous working class education.

I think those are some of them, but I don't claim to know all the reasons why the movement dissipated.

So you'd say that with the attacks on the workers' living standards, the conditions are now being recreated for a working class resurgence and opportunities for mass socialist activity?

Yes, I think so.

What do you say to those who conclude that because of the right wing's victories, socialists should leave the Labour Party?

This is not the time. I'm not saying that at some time in the future there won't be a new socialist party. But this is not the moment. We have to organise the left for socialism, but within the Labour Party.

That doesn't stop us collaborating. with people in the Socialist Movement and others who are not in the Labour Party. It's rather like what happened after 1931 when the Socialist League was created, and Socialist League worked with the Independent Labour Party throughout the period from 1932.

Isn't there a competition for resources. For example, the SWP say "leave the Labour Party".

Well, you're always going to get that. I don't think there's any answer. If you created a new party, you'd have all sorts of small organisations becoming part of it in order to win people from the party to their organisation. It has ever been thus.

leave the Labour Party.

should concentrate movement within the Of course we are socialists, and we have fought for socialism in the Labour Party. But isn't it true that the reason for being in the Labour Party has never been because of its doubtful "socialism", but fundamentally because it is the mass party of the class linked to the unions? Isn't that the fundamental thing? No matter how far it has moved formally from socialism now, it remains the mass party of the class because of its trade union roots. Serious socialists should never voluntarily abandon the mass party of the class to the right wing. Isn't that the essential argument?

If they marginalise the unions in the party, then it's no longer the mass party of the working class.

And you think that's what is happening? It's beginning to happen. It's not just the conference block vote. Some of the trade union leaders are quite happy to see the trade unions set aside, without any real influence. If they get away with that - and they're moving in that direction - then it is no longer the mass movement of the working So why should we stay in the Labour Party? Because there's an awful lot of people like us in the Labour Party who've got to be organised to work together. I don't think you can run before you can crawl. We have to

Scan page 11

MARCH FROM lisel

----- pull-quotes -----

« don't think we should be advocating that people

We shouldn't be calling for a new party. We

building up a good, genuinely left wing

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 502

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →