Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

[Students against the Tories of workers in a…]

Socialist Organiser no. 502, 10 October 1991 · scan p. 4 · about 738 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 4 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 4

Students against the Tories of workers in a particular industry. Oil the other hand we are against making a powerful rank and file movement bow down to entrenched bureaucrats. We are against sectarian breakaways, and we are also against making a fetish of The clearest example of a progressive breakaway was in the USA in the 1930s. The American Federation of Labou was a business-type trade union movement, very conser- abour thinks education is an issue that can help win the General Election for them, but will Labour deliver? vative, concerned with craft unionism, very racist and very In the 1930s there was a great wave of militancy, with sit-down strikes. The workers wanted to organise. Sections of the AFL - in the first place the miners' union - Education in crisis began to reflect the drive of the workers. They wanted to organise industrial unions. Eventually the miners' leader John L Lewis walked up to a prominent representative of the craft unionists at an AFL congress and hit him on the jaw. It was a signal for a break from the AFL.

It was a constructive break. It allowed the workers to create the Congress of Industrial Organisations, the CIO, which became the most powerful section of the US labour Stalinist tactics in the 1930s give an example of the opposite. In 1928 Stalin declared that the so-called Third Period of capitalism had started. The system was collapsing everywhere, and revolution was round the corner. The main enemies were not fascists or capitalists or monarThe Stalinists tried to organise their own "red" trade unions. In countries like Germany and Britain it was disastrous. In Britain the CP created a small miners' breakaway in Fife and a clothing workers' union in East London and Leeds. That was the extent of their ability to create independent unions, but their orientation was utterly destructive for the rank and file movements in the mass trade unions. It very quickly gave way a few years, around the mid-'30s, to the CP forgetting all about fighting the bureaucrats and instead burrowing within the bureaucracy.

Another important case history is the British docks in the '50s. The TGWU had a closed shop, and it was effectively a half-share employer of the workers it was supposed to be representing. Highly bureaucratised and very right wing, it took on the joh of policing the dockers. There In 1954-5, some 16,000 dockers — beginning in Hull, then Liverpool, then Manchester - broke out of the TGWU. They attempted to join a small dockers' union which already existed in London, the NASD or "blue union". They struck for six weeks to win recognition for The strike was defeated. The "blue union" then tried to expel the dockers who had joined it in the Northern ports. The dockers tried to stay in by taking the union to court. The "blue union" was then expelled by the TUC, in 1958.

Was the breakaway right or wrong? It led to a split among the dockers and even to a certain amount of nonunionism, though not enough to undermine militancy. The breakaway movement was defeated. After such a defeat it is easy to say that the workers should not have fought. But you never have a guarantee of victory. The dockers could not have known in advance that they would be defeated.

In any case it was not a full-scale defeat. It liberated the militants and it helped to change the TGWU, which by the late '50s was beginning to loosen up and move to the left.

As Rosa Luxemburg put it, the union does not create militancy, militancy creates the union. The union exists for the working class or it exists for nothing at all. We go by the interests of the working class, not by the interests of 1954 the dockers were right to break from Deakin (left). Are the oil —workers right to break from Jimmy Airlie today?

Isewhere in this INSIDE a paper we carry reports on the new THEEUNIONIS "breakaway union" being formed by workers i the offshore oil and gas industry. What does history have to teach us about such breakaways?

In the Transitional Programme of 1938, Leon Trotsky argued that we should be against breakaway unions John O'Mahony of a sectarian type that pull away from the broad mass unity.

sexist. movement.

CHIR TOGETHEK L DO WEWONT THAI

----- pull-quotes -----

LAY D MCHTING

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 502

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →