Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

A man who valued political honesty

Socialist Organiser no. 501, 3 October 1991 · scan pp. 13–14 · about 1,117 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 13 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 13

Memoirs Liz Millward reviews Eric Heffer's memoirs, Never a Yes Man (Verso)

ric Heffer's memoirs written when he already •knew he was dying, are not an academic history of the labour movement during Eric's years in it. The book is something far better than that. It does what academic texts never do: it makes the events and the people Eric remembers live.

He looks at the things he describes through the eyes of working people, Eric's people, whom he lovingly portrays in all their individuality and remained loyal to all his life. He is no afraid - and this must be rare in Neil Kinnock's duck-egg blue Labour Party — of being associated with poverty and with the poor. Eric Heffer was proud of these connections.

He sets out his origins, his early working life and political activities as only a man who knows he has a great deal to be proud of can do.

Throughout his political life, Eric Heffer saw through all the lies of the capitalist propaganda machine: unlike the wimps of the current Labour leadership, he did not pander to those lies even when they seemed to have become all powerful and all conquering. He never lost his belief that the labour movement will one day tear down the capitalist city of lies and exploitation.

He never lost his belief that it is the duty of people who have seen through the lies to go on fighting capitalism - in good times and bad — until we bring it down. He agreed with the words of the Red Flag — words which should choke Neil Kinnock when, on ceremonial occasions, he sings them: *It suits today the weak base Whose minds and place To cringe before the rich man's frown And haul sacred emblem But with heads uncovered swear we all To bear it onwards 'til we fall.

That is unfashionably "emotional", of course. But so was Eric was not prepared to pretend that it is possible to work with capitalism, or that it is better to dump your principles than be seen to have a row in public. As a result he was a constant thorn in the side of the current Labour leadership, saying the party has become an SDP Mark Il, walking off the platform during Neil Kinnock's conference speech attacking the Liverpool councillors, and making his final speech in parliament against the Gulf War which Kinnock and company cravenly supported.

Nor did Eric fall for the myths that the Soviet Union and the Eastern Bloc states were some form of socialism. His perspective was always that of the working class, and as he says "Working people, over the centuries have had enough of being collectivised, organised, lisciplined….."

His vision of socialism was ssentially a vision of freedom: *It can only occur when genuine equality of opportunity exists, when the extremes of poverty and wealth are removed, when there is a genuine redistribution of wealth, when people work for each other, and when individual greed is not considered a virtue."

But this is not a utopian vision, or the Fabian ideal of an altruistic society controlled by benevolent but autocratic government.

Eric Heffer was a democrat, a genuine democrat amongst all the hypocrisy of the so-called democrats in both Labour and Tory parties. Eric's idea of democracy was of democracy from below - in the workplace, on the streets and throughout political parties.

That he points out that capitalism only loves democracy when it suits them and their profits is not unexpected. But he is also not afraid to say that democracy can be manipulated by "devious people". There are no prizes for guessing who he means: "He has got away with it because the party elected him in the belief that he was a left wing leader who would carry out socialist policies. What an illusion that turned out to be." _Neil Kinnock ought to read this book. It would show him an alternative approach to polities. Probably he will not read it: it can not be pleasant for him to be reminded of what he once aspired to be.

It was written by a man who did not bend to every pressure, who never cared about personal prestige, who valued political honesty above all and who lived by his principles.

The tragedy is that Eric Heffer is dead and the ghost of the socialist renegade, Neil Kinnock, is - for now - cock-of-thewalk in the Labour Party! 'normal' that a substantial proportion of the population in any society will do things that most others don't want to - or daren't admit to wanting to from time to time.

The biggest part of a socialist's job is exposing the absurdities in the 'common sense' which suits the needs of the powers that be. The biggest part of a socialist's job is exposing the absurdities in the 'common sense I mean the sort of ideas that kept the working class divided or distracted by questions which don't bear on the real power struggle in our society - that between the bosses and their wageslaves.

Jennifer Saunders' strapon penis is small beer compared to the arrant hypocrisy and stupidity of what passes for 'common sense' in the field of sexual relations.

Scan page 14

Controversy over 'Guardian' article mAN ANO GAY COALITION We need to see more of the positive aspects of the lesbian and gay Organiser 'Gay Abandon' Heles published Weekend Guardian' was really pissed off when I read Jim puts it, "baying'. We were making a cogent, angry proDenham's latest 'Press test. That protest was about a Gang' entitled. 'Hitlerian grossly distorted, one-sided, Guardian?' In it, he ap- defeatist view of gay men pears to rise to the defence which consigned them to a of the 'liberal' Guardian life of self-seeking, self-destructive individualism. It against criticisms made by said nothing about the inlesbians and gays about a credible altruism, sense of recent, homophobic ar- community and responsibility with which we have respondin ed to HIV for instance.

Secondly, the protest over the First, we were not, as he Guardian needs to be seen in the context of the failure of the paper to print articles on the positive aspects of the lesbian and gay experience, despite the fact that many excellent lesbian and gay journalists have offered them. Frankly, we do expect better treatment from a liberal' paper.

Thirdly, this comes in the ETTERS experience wake of a renewed upsurge of homophobia in the press following the recent conPARENTS GROUP EIREFATION 2E troversy over 'outing' and the bluff pulled off by FROCS.

Finally, yes we're quite tians! e of the jun!! homophr David Welch

----- pull-quotes -----

were Chri ANCHESTER

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 501

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →