Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

SWP sneers i Russian socialists

Socialist Organiser no. 501, 3 October 1991 · scan p. 12 · Martin Thomas · about 823 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 12 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 12

The best thing that happened in the USSR since the August coup is the launching of an appeal for a broad Labour Party to represent the interests of the working class against the bureaucrats and business people who now dominate politics there with their drive towards market capitalism.

The initiative has been taken by Boris Kagarlitsky's Socialist Party, and they have got the signatures of some leading Moscow trade unionists for their appeal, which we print on this page.

Whether this appeal will win broad enough support, and just how far the Socialist Party should or should not have made compromises in drafting the appeal in order to try to win support, it is impossible to say at this distance. The situation in the USSR now not easy for socialists. Drastic changes are underway, yet the working-class movement is extremely weak, even at a trade union level, and much of it is aligned behind Yeltsin and pro-capitalist ideas.

Socialists need to try to rebuild a movement starting from basic working-class self-defence in the coming turmoil, and that, clearly, is what the Moscow socialists are trying to do. "Socialist Worker's answer is always to organise a small 'militant minority instead of... a broad workers' party"

Yet, in last week's Socialist Worker they were roundly denounced by SW junior guru Alex Callinicos. Quoting a short excerpt from the appeal, he seized on one phrase — "a civilized form of market" - and sneered: "There's a good slogan for Neil Kinnock's (or indeed John Major's) election manifesto"

The sneer is stupid. The appeal calls for a civilized form of market" in the con text of transforming the USS's present state sector into a "social sector" under worker management and "democratic regulation of the economy". Hardly the same as Kinnock or Major!

"A civilized form of market" is a feeble and empty slogan for Britain. In the USSR where people's lives are dominated by very uncivilized markets — markets where you have to queue for hours, pay bribes or have influential friends in order to get anything — and where wildcat capitalism" is fast coming in, it is not so feeble or empty.

Or does Callinicos think that socialists in Moscow should propose abolishing all market mechanisms immediately? If so, how? How could even the best socialist government there collect the information necessary for total planning to replace all markets?

But Callinicos would probably be hostile to an appea for a Labour Party whateve the wording. Not only in Britain today, but in all countries in all circumstances - even in times of revolutionary turmoil, as in South Africa in the '80s and the USSR today -Socialist Worker's answer is always to organise a small "militant minority" instead of (rather than as well as) organising a broad workers' party.

Oddly, Callinicos criticises Kagarlitsky and the Socialist Party for "leaving the initiative to the liberals". That is precisely what Socialist Worker's policy does — in Britain where they abstain from the struggle inside the Labour Party and thus leave mass working class politics at election time, for example) to the "LiberalLabour" Kinnockites, or in the USSR, if the socialists. were to make no effort to organise a broader workers' movement.

Callinicos links his criticism of the Labour Party appeal with a criticism of Boris Kagarlitsky's analysis of the August coup. (That analysis first appeared in English in Socialist Organiser, but Callinicos, of course, refers only to another article by Kagarlitsky in the New Statesman).

Kagarlitsky argues that Yanayev, Kryuchkov, Pugo, and the other coup-makers were in fact manipulated by Yeltsin, and the real coup was Yeltsin's. Callinicos, I think, is right to disagree; whatever the complications, between 19 and 21 August, Yeltsin stood for the democratic freedoms that the Soviet people had gaine since 1985, and socialists should have been emphatically on his side. (In practice, it seems, despite Kagarlitsky's analysis, the Socialist Party - through its members in the Moscow City Council, for example - did take that side).

The most important deficiencies of the Labour Party appeal, in my view -whether they were avoidable or not, I don't know — are its lack of clear directions for taking a lead in the fight for democratic rights and for the dismantling of the old Stalinist state machine, and its failure to mention the national question. Callinicos says nothing on these points.

Last year Socialist Worker tried to make funding for Kagarlitsky's group the only form of practical solidarity from Britain for socialists in the Eastern bloc; they refused to cooperate with the "Support the Socialists" appeal, launched by the Campaign for Solidarity with Workers in the Eastern Bloc, which raised money not only for Kagarlitsky's group but also for socialists in Poland, East Germany and Czechoslovakia.

Now they have fallen out with Kagarlitsky, what will Socialist Worker do? Drop all solidarity activity, or reconsider their refusal to join a broader campaign?

----- pull-quotes -----

EYE=ON THEBLEFT

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 501

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →