Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Socialists march into the wilderness

Socialist Organiser no. 501, 3 October 1991 · scan pp. 10–12 · about 3,029 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 10

Peter Taaffe wrote a lucid criticism of the Healyite breakaway, and at a time of deep depression for the breakaway in Militant. Now he helps lead a similar industrial class struggle. AT THEIR UNOFFICIAL Morecambe conference held on February 27 and 28, and attended by 1,000 young people, the expelled Young Socialist National Committee (Majority) formed a breakaway youth movement.

With the acceptance of Keep Left as the official paper of the new movement. the organisers have clearly split from the Labour Party. The conference merely consumated a position which has actually existed for some months. The gathering was more a rally to launch the new movement.

A number of Landon branches such as Clapham and Wandsworth appeared as sponsors ot resolutions which they had never seen or discussed. Delegates were present from areas where the YS has been closed down (eg. Streathan and Birkenbead)

The story appears to mave been the same up and down the country. There was one resolution from a branch called Ashton (minority"

Scarcely a dissident Nonce was raised in debate as resolution after resolution was accepted with near unanimity. This alone should have warned David Ashby and his committee that this was a gathering of the "faithful" many of whom were unaware of the real issues at stake.

In the debate on foreign policy, a delegate drew whistling and applause when he said that there was an " instinctive hatred of America by the British working class". This display of crude nationalism wae corrected it is true. by the editor of Keep Left, but the very fact that such things could be said and find a response in the conference, is an indication of the flimsy basis on which the new movement rests.

Another subject of mild disagreement was the shabby role of Keep Left supporters during the Novemer apprentices' strike.

The delegate from Ashton stirred the conference when he said that "attacks by the National Committee on the apprentices' strike had split the movement". John former YS and rushed to the platform to denounce the Ashton delegate and the " conscious saboteurs " of the apprentices movement, MILITANT and the Young Communist League.

Despite this hysteria, Keep Left found it difficult to apologise for the actions of Ashby, Farley and company, who broke the elementary rule of support he backbone of the new should have aside the Labour Part Dave Ashby, in a schizo phrenic mood, declared a i press conference that the Labour Party is a " polic cal expression " of the working class and yer coe inued the headlong plung nto the political wildemnes For the past tweive years.

the criticism levelled by the Marxist left at the Labour leadership has mainly beer in the realms of ideas.

has now-become possible to show the rank and file of the party just what the ideas of Wilson & Co. mean in practice. A great job of educating the rank and file of the party by contrasting the past words and the present deeds of the Labour leaders should be undertaken by Young Socialists.

At the start of this vital period, Keep Left takes outside the Labour Party many comrades who can play an important role in the strug gles ahead.

The history of the British. labour movement is rich in examples of costly hysterical walk - outs and childish "left-turns " by sects with claims to divine leadership.

Marxists criticised the Independent Labour Party in 1933 for breaking from the Labour Party at the wrong time and on the wrong issue.

The ILP had at that time the support of 100,000 workers, yet the Keep Left tendency imagine that 1,000 (in reality a much smaller number) constitutes a viable alternative to the Labour PartyJust as dangerous is the heoretical cover which is given to this escapade.

amdly, that the unorgansed, unskilled adults and outh will not tump to the Buc the Labour Pary a not only the political enpression of the organised workers, but also of the unorganised and politically backward sections. At times be crisis they will tum fins the Labour Party fo alucions to their problem The new movement wil nelt away within a shor period, but the existence of walk-outs at every episodic event, both inside and outside the Labour Party. The Keep Left tendency are prisoners of these episodic events. They must have an unending secession of pragmatic issues to constantly activate their ranks.

The plight of the old-age pensioners and their scandalous treatment by the Labour government - an important but temporary issue - is built into the new movement's constitution.

Recent experiences should warn those comrades who support the new movement of the folly of their actions. The archConservative Daily Telecommented: "The breaking away of the extreme left, although temporarily embarrassing Transport House, may ultimately be the best thing that could happen to the By the Labour Party the Tory press means the Labour leaders.

After four years of expulsions, proscriptions and bureaucratic stifling, right wing are quite conent to provoke a section of YS into throwing in heir hand. This is what he attempt so form an ope outh movemen The enthusiasm of comrades who make up the anks of the new m and tum towards the rea aruggle inside the Laboo Party A refusal, so do thi and 1 join forces with outer tendencies in the strug ge a Socialise programme will doom them to isolation and gradual deoralisation the Labour Party. Nevertheless, that was the working-class movement in politics at that time. The situation could not be changed by will or fantasy. The Healyites understood that.

Two things changed the situation. After Labour's third General Election defeat, in 1959, the Labour youth movement - closed down in 1955 — was restarted. It grew quickly, providing an audience for the left. And the Campaign for Nuclear Disarmament grew to be a mass movement. A stream of newly radicalised youth came out of it into the Young Socialists.

he Healyites had maintained a small youth paper through the years when there was no national Labour youth movement. (Keep Left: the name came from a Labour pressure group of the '40s, a sort of parallel to the Tory Bruges Group now).

Local Labour Parties could have youth sections, and some did: Keep Left linked some of them together. Their influence grew rapidly in the new youth organisation. They made a deliberate turn away froma narrow discussion-group idea of the Young Socialists, and organised social events for working-class youth, drawing them slowly into politics. Some big Young Socialists groups were built like that.

The Labour Party responded as it was wont to. Keep Left was banned in July 1962. They defied the ban and continued to grow in the YS. Despite Labour Party leadership harassment, and the occasional expulsion, they gained the majority on the National Committee of the Young Socialists.

This was now the Wilson Labour Party, and it was plain by 1963 that the Tories were on their way out. Labour would be in power, being tested by events and judged by workers in the Labour Party and the trade unions. It was then that the Healy group - after 17 years — decided to break with the Labour Party!

Here we need to backtrack and look a little more closely at the Healy organisation. In the

Scan page 11

from the Labour Party quite wrong hopes and perspectives for the Labour Party left, and then not do a proper balance sheet to learn from their errors. In 1960-1 they developed grotesque hopes — self-evidently false to anyone not in the grip of wishful thinking — about the prospects of the nuclear disarmament issue transforming the labour movement - and then recoiled from the Labour left in bitter disappointment.

The lack of internal democracy meant that nobody could try to learn the lessons from such experiences or propose realistic assessments. The internal atmosphere was increasingly that of a religious organisation in which what should be rational and empirical questions of judgment and assessment, on which more than one view was possible from a common viewpoint and common aspirations and hopes, became infused with emotion and loyalties; and then with heresy and the fear of heresy. The leadership - orchestrated bludgeoning of any dissent, using those tools, made all internal life impossible. It also, increasingly, made rational life impossible. The raw youth were the leadership's cudgel against "fainthearts" and "donothings"

This was the group which, disgusted with the Labour Party's internal inertia after the unilateralist controversy, found itself growing and rapidly recruiting raw youth from campaigns against youth unemployment or police violence or from Young Socialist dances in places like the Wigan Labour Clubs. In terms of immediate growth, youth was the key.

And so they forgot about everything else, about the big questions of the necessary evolution of the labour movement and about questions of proportion. The Young Socialists was very tiny indeed compared to the broader labour movement and the Labour Party. But the Healyites began to act with their YS majority as if the YS could ignore the Labour Party and behave as an autonomous revolutionary youth group.

At some time in 1964 Healy decided to break the YS from the Labour Party. Individual expulsions were routine by now. The Healyites, looking for a break, began to court and provoke expulsions. They then used agitation against the expulsions both to line up broad support and to justify the break they had decided on. They would continue to claim that they were all expelled.

The split was consummated at Easter 1965 at a Healyite-convened Young Socialists conference. The rump, soon renamed the Labour Party Young Socialists, met in conference in the autumn. The Healyites, those of them who remembered what they used to think about such issues, said that they had not deserted the mass labour movement, or that they would be back: they passed resolutions at their 1965 conference saying that they would build the Young Socialists and then turn back to the Labour Party.

It was all nonsense. Events had their own momentum. The Healyite youth organised a few big and impressive marches, with lots of red flags and portraits of Trotsky and Lenin, but it was all marginal to the labour movement. They got more sectarian and crazier as time went on. But that is outside my subject.

ahe Labour Government of 1964-70 disgusted the left, and not only the left.

In the later 1960s there was a big exodus of the left from the Labour Party (the IS, forerunners of the SWP, drifted out in 1967).

Yet Labour remained the centre of working-class politics. When in 1974 a great industrial movement, in the first place the miners, led to the rejection at the polls of the Tory Government of Edward Heath, it was still the Labour Party that progressive anti-Tory workers turned to. Labour had not been discredited then, any more than it has now.

FORCE THESE MEN TO RESIGH Keep Young poul Keep let .. pape pinhergyn barynaving neone in political labour movement, they agitated amongst the ké nhe ale like Michael Foot - fight"!

Where was Militant in all this? Militant, too, was a fragment of the old RCP, of which Ted Grant had been one of the three or four central leaders. It dwindled to very little in the '50s, revived briefly in the late '50s when it had a monthly four-page tabloid paper (Socialist Fight), and then declined again, unable in 1960-1 even to maintain a monthly 12-page duplicated version of Socialist Fight.

But Militant, too, grew a little in the Young Socialists, publishing a joint paper with the future SWP until 1963. Then, as the Healy group moved towards its sectarian desertion of the Labour Party, individuals here and there joined Militant. One of them was the technically competent journalist Roger Protz. Militant made a new start, publishing Militant from October 1964 as a well-designed eight-pager.

The future IMG, a group based in Nottingham which published a weekly duplicated paper, The Week, had, like Militant, ties to the Pablo-Mandel "Fourth International" and they now fused with Militant. Things were going better for Militant than for many years. Then the Healyites intervened.

By provoking their own expulsions where they could, they intended to make it as difficult as possible for leftists who were hostile to the dominant Labour Party right wing to stay in the Labour Party. They denounced Trotskyists who refused to go with them out of the Labour Party as "traitors" , "scabs" Labour Party finks", and so on. Militant quite rightly refused to be bullied and browbeaten, and insisted on exercising "self-determination".

t least one Militant supporter did Amore. A Ceylonese Trotskyist, S.Mani, was the publicly listed business manager of Militant, and a member of Wandsworth Young Socialists.

When several Healyite youth were being expelled there, the police were called by the right wing. Mani acquiesced and either voted for the expulsions or abstained. (The details were disputed). This was grist to the Healyites' mill. They made a great fuss about the "Mani affair"

The recent ex-Healyites in Militant were upset about it too - for the reason that they were still sensitive to the moral pressure of the Healyites as well as for the good political reasons. Things were heated up by the work of an undercover Healyite agent within Militant, one Ted Knight.

The fifth issue of Militant had just gone to press, so Ted Grant and Peter Taaffe, the nominal editor, put a duplicated leaflet inside the paper defending Mani. Whatever Mani had done, they said, he was right: the issue was "hooliganism"

Whatever the right wing had done in Wandsworth, it had been provoked by the "hooliganism" of the Healyites!

There was hooliganism and unruliness, but to take this line was to assume the role of "left-wing political attorney" for right-wing action against the Healyite youth, putting a "political" gloss on it, forgetting that the right-wingers were expelling people long before the Healyites decided to go out with as much of a bang as possible.

It was an extraordinary performance. It split Militant. The Nottingham group walked out, and so did almost all the ex-Healyites, including Protz, editor of Militant. For a long time Militant was reduced to a very amateurish four pages on a not-quitemonthly schedule.

The parallels are obvious and striking. Like the Healyites, Militant has for long had very false ideas about the likely development of the Labour Party and the Labour Left.

Like the Healyites, it uses mystifying and nonsensical slogans like "Labour to Power on a Socialist Programme". Like the Healyites, Militant has recruited a lot of politically raw youth in a time of stagnation for the Labour Party. Like the Healyites, Militant is more and more irrational and unrealistic. The Walton by-election cannisi MILTANT FOR LA PRINTERS FIGHT 4-page Militant after the 1965 split: unfunny cartoon (to understand it you had first to read a beavy semicien of page.

didacy may have been right or wrong, as you like, but the debauch of lying Militant went in for around it is reminiscent of nothing so much as the Healyites; so is the gross unrealism of their assessment of the vote they got.

Like the Healyites then, Militant has the internal life of a highly emotional religious group where strong feeling attaches to what should be empirical and practical questions of judgment. The decision to stand in Walton was made without serious discussion; the organisation was bounced by a group at its centre into a radical change; even Ted Grant himself could not get a proper hearing when he opposed the new turn.

f Militant can organise young people for socialism - good! Organising young peo•ple is as desirable now as it was when the leaders of Militant justified calling the police on some of the youth the Healyites had organised.

Ultimately, unless such youth are taught to relate to the labour movement, they will be just sect-fodder outside the labour movement. That would not necessarily exclude a period of activity outside the Labour Party. Yet Militant is now trying to organise revolutionary youth as part of a stupid little splurge of electoralism: necessarily they minimise or lose sight of the central question of kicking the Tories out.

They necessarily act and speak and educate the youth as if the Labour Party - even before it is in office — is the main enemy. They go off to organise "new" youth at a time when the class struggle is at a 50-year nadir: the underlying thought, or halfthought, is inescapably that it is possible to start again afresh, outside the existing labour movement. That is the idea, for example, in a recent Militant article on Keir Hardie, angled to suggest that there is a parallel between that pioneer and Militant's electioneering now and a parallel between today's Labour Party, based on the trade unions, and the 19th century Liberal Party. This is a premature RIP for the labour movement!

It is the Healyite idea all over again. For it to be sensible, you would have to assume that the labour movement will go on declining, draining into the sands of history, without any revival. And even then the question would arise: why can we believe that a new labour movement can be built in such conditions? Mac The results already of Militant's adventure in Walton have been such as to discredit its strategic architects as politically competent people for the next hundred years!

In Walton they could not possibly have gained as much as they were almost certain to lose and are losing:

that, plus the lies and unrealistic boasting, is sufficient to establish that Militant's leaders do not know what they are doing now. At the root of their new turn is bitter disgust and loss of faith not only in the preposterously optimistic perspectives Militant had for the Labour Party, but in the political labour movement itself. Gerry Healy died in 1990 he is being reborn in 1991

Scan page 12

Socialist Organiser No. 501 page NTERNATIONAL

----- pull-quotes -----

LEFT MAKE THE LEFT MPs FIGHT! people have no time for Wilson's policies

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 501

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →