Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

When the Healyites split

Socialist Organiser no. 501, 3 October 1991 · scan p. 10 · Sean Matgamna · about 950 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 10

Organising events like this dance at a Wigan Labour Club, the Healyites recruited 'Independent' Yo mahose who do history are relive it"

Yes - and sometimes people learn from history but go on nevertheless to relive it because time passes and they forget what they learned.

Of course, no two situations are exactly parallel, but Militant's departure from the Labour Party now is remarkably like events in_the mid-'60s when the group that evolved into Healy's crazy WRP broke away from the Labour Party. After 17 years' work there, the Healyites left the Labour Party in 1964, on the eve of Labour forming its first government in 13 years. The similarity between those events and what is happening now is so close and so comprehensive that we could be living through one of those periodic Hollywood remakes of old movies, using the same shooting script, usually crudified. Except that Hollywood remakes old suecesses. This is a re-run of one of the most destructive episodes in the history of the revolutionary left in Britain.

Militant had a prominent role in the earlier version of the events we are now living through. Its role then was that of outspoken and embittered opponent of the Healyite who do not not learn from condemned to breakaway. So it played the role then that SO is playing now? Not quite. SO, unlike Militant in 1964-5, will not under any circumstances join with the right wing in expelling other leftists from the Labour Party, nor will we support the right wing in calling in the police to eject young supporters of the breakaway group.

Militant did those things when the Healyites were making their messy break with the Labour Party. Militant itself split over the issue: the definitive split between Militant and the IMG a tendency represented today by three factions, Socialist Outlook, Socialist Action, and the Communist League) occurred because of Militant's enthusiastic activities in 1964-5 to preserve the Labour Party against "sectarian disruption" and "hooliganism"

The Healyites were a sizeable group, Their initial nucleus had joined the Labour Party in 1947 and had helped organise the Labour Party left. They won some hundreds of people from the Communist Party in the late '50s. They made bigger gains than any Trotskyist group had anywhere in the world for the previous decade.

They were in the Labour Party, recognising it as the mass working-class party and recognising that socialists either related to that movement or marginalised themselves where mass working-class politics was concerned. They did important work in industry and in the trade unions, too. β€”In February 1959 they had set up a public organisation, the Socialist Labour League, which claimed to be an integral part of the Labour Party. The National Executive Comundreds of young people - and then led them into the political desert...

mittee banned the organisation and its weekly paper, The Newsletter, within two weeks.

By 1960 the Healyites' big spurt of growth was over. They organised activity to "Defend Clause Four" from Gaitskell's attempt to jettison it; they organised against the right wing on unilateralism and expressed a proper disgust at the spinelessness of the Foot-led Tribune left.

Then as now, there was not a lot of life in :40s, during and after the war, the Trotskyists were organised in a small party (called the Revolutionary Communist Party from 1944 to 49) which, at its biggest, reached maybe 500 members. The organisation grew during the war when the Labour Party was in a coalition government with the Tories and the then very important Communist Party was organising the breaking of strikes to help the war effort of Stalin's ally Britain.

The RCP developed the illusion that it could continue to grow in a straight line. The tremendous revival of Labour in 1944-5, leading to the 1945 victory, when workers turned to the Labour Party as the only governmental alternative to the Tories, took most of the organisation by surprise. The RCP began to fall apart, and slowly disintegrated. Its remnant, the future Militant and the future SWP, collapsed into the Labour Party in 1949-50 because they could not think of anything better to do.

By contrast, Gerry Healy had been part of a minority faction since 1944, arguing that the Trotskyists should work within the Labour Party, that is, within the mainstream of working-class political activity. The Healyites had often false ideas of what was likely to happen in the Labour Party in the period ahead, but their central idea made sense. They separated from the rest of the RCP in 1947 and began work in the Labour Party.

The organisation that evolved was, however, a peculiar one. It never lost the character of a factional group, so that the organisation was always rather undemocratic. This got worse as time went on. By the early '60s it was an extremely autocratic grouping, though still a long way from the vicious religious cult it became in the "70s. T youth in the early yo youteduca nd he influx of raw, politically uneducated experience of the earlier discussions on the Labour Party and linked questions, probably speeded up the process of turning the Healy group into a cult.

Healy and his friends used the youth, playing on them and demagogically exploiting their aspirations and wishes against the older cadres of the group. In the process they raised the machine above the organisation and Healy above the machine as supreme Caesar. There were always big elements of that in the Healy group, but it now became all-shaping.

Lack of honest accounting was always a feature of the Healyites. They would develop

----- pull-quotes -----

Those do learn from history are condemned to relive it

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 501

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →