Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

John Tocher

Socialist Organiser no. 500, 26 September 1991 · scan p. 15 · about 834 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 15 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 15

John Tocher, ABU for the Greater Manchester area and a lifelong socialist, died on September 17th at the age of 64. It was fitting, if tragic, that John should pass away just a couple of days before his retirement since he had spent his whole working life in the service of the trade unions.

John Tocher joined the Communist Party in the 1940s and was for many years a member of its National Executive and its Chair in 1970. He worked at BAe (then A V Roe) at Woodford becoming convenor of shop stewards in the early 1950s. He was subsequently AEU District Secretary in Stockport before succeeding All Jones as Divisional Organiser.

John was a member of a close group of able CP members and Labour lefts who dominated the AEU - and the industrial labour movement in the North West - in the immediate post-war decades. It included Eddie Frow, Hugh Scanion, Bob Wright, Bernard Panter and Stan Cole.

Party organisation was firmly based on the stewards' committees, dominated in engineering by members and sympathisers. Greater Manchester was probably the strongest CP fortress outside Scotland and South John Tocher first came to na tional prominence during the strike at the Roberts Arundel factory in the centre of Stockport - a marathon stoppage which lasted from late 1966 into 1968. An industrialist from North Carolina, Robert E Pomeranz attempted to smash the union declaring "I am the great white father of the workers". Tocher was imaginative and indefatigable inorganising a far-flung campaign of boycotting and picketing. One of the stories he often told in later years about the dispute involved Paul Casey. For 8 months, Casey crossed picket lines - to abuse and worse to work in the factory. By nigh he would rendezvous with Tocher in the back room of back street pubs providing vital information about management's strategy and the movement of goods and machinery. He was eventually rumbled by management who had taken to following Tocher" car.

Tocher was always an excellent but very patient organiser. In Hugh Scanlon's campaign against John Boyd for the AEU presidency in 1967-8, the left vote in Manchester was so high it provoked an internal inquiry into his activities. He threw himself wholeheartedly into the campaign against "In Place of Strife" and the 1971 Industrial Relations Act.

But his politics were limited by Stalinism, by the horizons o the CP and the politics of left alliances, by his loyalty to Scanlon and a certain limited caution, To take one example. in 1972, that annus mirabilis post-war militancy, the breakdown of national negotiations between the EEF and the CSEU prompted Scanion to urge plant bargaining for a shorter working week and wage increases. By April more than 7000 workers in Confed district 29 of which Tocher was the Secretary, had occupied their workplaces. Yet Tocher always held the campaign on a tight rein. And when, in May, Scanion caved in and despatched a circular urging the dropping of the campaign for shorter hours in favour of cash-only settlements, John Tocher reluetantly recommended that stewards accept this retreat. A golden opportunity was lost.

John Tocher left the CP in 1975, disillusioned with Stalinism and bureaucratism. The ensuing years witnessed a decisive weakening of the Broad Left and workplace organisation in engineering and the entrenchment of the hard right in the AEU leadership. Tocher expressed some bitterness at the way things went in the '80s and not a little disgust at the right's undermining of democracy in the AEU, culminating in attempts to merge his beloved union with the yellow EETPU. But he never stopped fighting the right wing. He stood agains Jordan for the presidency and despite bouts of illness, fought to keep the Broad Left going.

John Tocher was a bad enemy but a good friend as 1 found personally on several occasions when I received generous support against tuppence ha'penny right wing bureaucrats. In his last years, he became a strong critic of sec. tarianism. He believed passionately that the way forward for the left, was through the transformation of the movement we have now by means of patient work in both the Labour Party and the unions. He was an enthusiastic supporter of Labour Party Socialists in Manchester and one of his last public appearances was when he came from his sick-bed to speak at our meeting in August.

John Tocher was born in 1927, the bitter year after the defeat of the General Strike, the year of "Baldwin's revenge" the 1927 Trades Union Act. All that changed. The legislation was repealed. The working class came again. John Tocher's life spanned periods of defeat, vietory and defeat once again for our movement. The best memorial to him and certainly one he would want would be the rebuilding of a movement which can consign today's anti-union legislation to the wastepaper bin of history and go for ward to build socialism.

- John Mçllrey

----- pull-quotes -----

"He never stopped fighting the right wing:"

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 500

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →