French socialists call for new debate on Stalinism
Socialist Organiser1991 1991-09-26Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 14 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 14
The French socialist - weekly Rouse, in its issue 12th September, has called for a new debate on the analysis of the old order in the USSR, acknowledging that the "degenerated workers' state" theory needs to be reconsidered.
The call marks a watershed in the history of the Trotskyist movement. The LCR, the group which publishes Rouge, has a wide influence internationally, linked to such writers as Ernest Mandel and groups such as Socialist Outlook and Socialist Action in Britain.
For over 40 years, that current of opinion has held to the view that Trotsky's assessment of the USSR *degenerated workers' state" could validly be G DURA TOSMSBYJUM extended into the post-World War II world and extrapolated to describe the East European states, China, Vietnam etc. as "deformed workers' states", • It has based its whole perspective of "the world revolution" on that view.
Most other Trotskyists shared the basic view, giving it their own YalEOS various shared it until the Organiser shared mid-80s. After fresh discussions, we concluded that the Stalinist states were systems of class exploitation parallel to capitalism, rather than being an advance on capitalism. We formally abandoned the "workers' states" position at our conference in 1988.
The rush towards capitalism in the USSR and Eastern Europe must be utterly demoralising for any socialist who reckoned that those societies embodied their ideals, even imperfectly.
For over 60 years now Trotskyists have combatted the lie that the Stalinist system was socialist, and advocated a new workers' revolution against the bureaucrats in the USSR. Nevertheless, most Trotskyists have reckoned that the USSR was still "Fighting racism", Leeds SO meeting. 7.30, Coburg Pub "Why we are socialists", Canterbury Tech SO meeting. 1.00. Speaker: Mark Osborn Saturday 28 September "Stop the purges!" meeting at Labour Party conference. 7.30, Middle St Primary School, Brighton Called by Friends of Brighton Sunday 29 September "Our history", North London S meeting. 7.30, Red Rose Club, Seven Sisters Road. Speaker: Cathy Nugent "Unshackle the unions" fringe meeting called by LPS and SMTUC. 7.30, Royal Albion Hotel, Old Stein, Brighton. Speakers include Dennis Skinner, Peter Heathfield Leafletting of Chinatown in suppo of political prisoners. 12.00-2.00, London. Organised by CSC Monday 30 September "The Sarah Thornton case", SE London SO meeting. 7.30, Two Eagles Pub, Elephant and Castle Speaker: Liz Dickenson "degenerated workers' state" and that general view has been influential on the left way outside the ranks of the Trotskyist groups.
It is a view routed and ruined by the events of the last two years. Large sections of the left need to re-examine both their views on the Stalinist states, and the assumptions on which those views were based.
This is how Rouge puts it. -contronted each other in or fifty years now, confronted each other in the workers' movement on the analysis of these [Stalinist] states.
In the light of the current overturns, it is possible to take up the debates on all these questions anew. For our part, we are willing to take part in this discussion and confront our own theory with the lessons of history.
We used to believe that from a sharp crisis of these regimes would arise forces - significant, at least, if not commanding a majority - capable of opposing the road of a self-managed socialist democracy to that of capitalist restoration. In fact such currents are marginal today.
We used to think that in spite of the confiscation of power by a parasitic bureaucracy. the existence of non-capitalist social relations arising from the revolution [of 1917] represented gains in the eyes of the workers, who would mobilise to defend them.
In fact, it appears not so at all. Primarily, the workers see in their miserable living standards the expression of a productivity gap which has widened again between the rich Western countries and the Eastern bloc.
That does not exclude vigorous movements tomorrow of resistance to the consequences of privatisations, but as of now the facts are sufficient to render necessary critical re-examination of the analyses and of their consequences for practical activity.
We are willing to take part in this re-examination and this debate, which will be illuminated by joint action with all those who, -facing the enormous challenges that we do, will remain faithful to the defence of the exploited and oppressed.
Tuesday 1 October Anniversary of Chinese revolution China Solidarity Campaign picket Chinese Embassy, Portland Place, London, 7.00pm Wednesday 2 October "Campaigning for Left Policies in the General Election", ; LPS 1 inge meeting, Labour Party Co ference. 7.30, Royal Albion Hotel, Old Stein. Speakers include Tony Benn and Jeremy Corbyn Picket for Dessie Ellis. 9.30-11.30am, Old Bailey, EC4 Thursday 3 October "Is socialism dead?", Brighton SO meeting. 7.30, Eastern Pub Speaker Cate Murphy "After Stalinism - standing up real socialism", *, Sheffield SO meeting. 7.30, SCCAU, West Street Saturday 5 October March for the Tottenham 3 Assemble 12.00, Civic Cent Wood Green, London N22. 2.00, Finsbury Park Monday 7 October "Stand up for real socialism" Socialist Organiser London Fo 7.30, Lucas Arms, Gray's Inn Road, Kings Cross
----- pull-quotes -----
EYESION THE EVE
WHAT'S ON Thursday 26 September