Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Modern gladiators O was severely beaten abone

Socialist Organiser no. 500, 26 September 1991 · scan p. 13 · Steven Holt · about 648 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 13 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 13

devices à la James Bond, and, its central flaw I suppose, thin and corny characterisation.

Having said that, 1 also suppose, that this is reasonable in the case of the portrayal of the baddies — drug manufacturers and dealers who are, in real life, every bit as vile as they are painted.

Where the problem lies is in the characterisation of the people who take on the crack-barons — cops. Maverick cops granted, but cops nonetheless, whereas in real life cops don't usually give a damn, or else they are unable to deal with social problems at root.

These cops succeed to a degree in their aim, but the director knows that there are massively more poMichael Watson In Saturday a young man the head and is now in hospital in intensive care.

It is feared that he will suffer severe and permanent brain damage, or may even die. The man who knocked him down was cheered by hundreds of thousands of onlookers and the fight between these two men was broadcast live on television.

The police are not terrifyingly brought out in episode.

On the boat to Ireland, the young man goes in his wheelchair to the lavatory, hauls himself up to the urinal, gripping the pipes above it. The movement of the ship rolls the chair away from under him, across the room.

He is stranded, hanging onto the pipes, unable to do anything else. His strength wanes and he sinks down and crawls helplessly on the vomit-covered floor, unable to catch the chair rolling gently back and forth with the movements of the ship.

"Journey to Knock" was one of the most moving — and original -things I have seen on TY: 1.: this man took place within a socially accepted convention, the "sport" of boxing.

Boxing is, like football and cricket, a competitive activity with unavoidably violent aspects. Unlike such sports as football and cricket, the whole aim of the competitors in boxing is to incapacitate their opponent physically by knocking them out. This carries a heavy risk of inflicting brain damage and anyone entering boxing as a career will suffer some degree of brain damage at some time.

The British Medical Association has for many years urged that boxing should be banned as unsafe.

But, the supporters of boxing argue, boxers have freely chosen boxing as their career. To this we can ask, "How many young men would choose boxing other than to avoid unemployment or degrading no-hope jobs?"

Is it a coincidence that so many British and American boxers are black?

And what of a society where so many working class people want to watch people hurting each other, where others rake off huge profits from this process, and where some, black and white, men have to resort this kind of thing as a "social ladder"?

I don't know whether banning boxing is an appropriate response, since those who box have chosen to do so, within the limits of choice imposed by present day capitalist society. Boxing i certainly a symptom of capitalism, anc perhaps the best response for socialists is to continue efforts to bring about [undamental changes: triends, the quack therapies and "cures" seized on by desperate people, the grim round of hospital visits and memorial services.

By the end, Willie has become a buddy, helping out AIDS victims without family OI friends. lover, Alan, a lawyer, is also busy helping gays thrown out of housing or denied jobs because of their ilIness.

By the end, all the characters have learned not to blame themselves for AIDS - it's just a virus, says one of the female characters matter-of-factly - and have begun to try to build something together, to help themselves and other people until a cure is found. That's a positive message to take away from any film. For a film in 1991, it's almost a miracle.

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 500

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →