A price worth paying?
Socialist Organiser1991 1991-09-26Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 10
The Tories have chosen their main an election - the link between Labour and the unions.
"Who runs Labour?" their posters bellow, and just in case the answer isn't clear, some of Britain's leading trade unionists peer out from the huge letters of the word "Labour" The comedian Stephen Fry made the telling point this week that the unions had taken such a battering in the last 12 years that the public didn't recognise most of the pictures.
The challenge, nevertheless, is one which Labour should confront head-on. The differences between the two parties' funding says a lot about the roots of each of them.
From the start, the Tories have been funded by big business which, like the 19th century breweries, openly bought influence and protected their interests. The use of huge sums of money is a decisive means by which people who are in a tiny minority can always have their way even in a "democracy"
Trade union funding of the Labour Party, on the other hand, makes Britain more, not less, democratic. Without it there would be no working class party of opposition, there would be no way for the majority of people to sustain a consistent political voice. If the argument appears a shade partisan, look at the US. There the most political unions fund particular Democrats, most stay out of politics and there is no working class party which can seriously compete with the big capitalist parties.
The result is the complete alienation of the majority of people from any sort of politics, and protest through ethnic identity, street crime and drugs.
Implicit in the Tory campaign just now is the demand that Labour break the union link and survive like the others on individual and company donations. Now there is just an outside chance that the party of Kinnock, Smith, et al could cobble together a few guilty liberal industrialists - the Anita Roddicks of this world. The certainty is, however, that there would be no such part that could represent the workers as an organised class, no party for the poorest, no party which even genuflected in the direction of a challenge to the profit system — because no such party could gain adequate funding from people who thrive on that system.
Working class people have no possibility competing with the resources and power The Tory faithful big capitalists except through their collective strength. The drive behind the Tory poster campaign is that there should be no Labour Party — that we have no right to collectively fund our own party.
At the same time, private wealth is to absolute unfettered power to buy politic fluence. In 1989 big business reported ‹ tions totalling £3.5 million to the Tory! have al inlonaParty - but this is only the tip of the iceberg, for neither companies nor party are required to publish such donations.
Individual donations, such as the t2 million given by Greek shipping billionaire John Latsis are much harder to trace. The links between unions and the Labour Party are open, the figures are published annually, and under law no political fund can exist without the approval of a substantial majority of union members in a secret ballot.
Contrast that with big business funding of the Tories. Most of it is secret, its effect is not seen openly at a conference where business leaders can be held to account because the Tory conference doesn't make any decisions. Above all, there is no requirement in law for companies to obtain the approval of shareholders before they make donations. "One law for the rich..." as the old saying goes.
Partisan as it may seem, one of these links is straightforward corruption, the other is one of the few bits of social democracy left in the parliamentary system.
And what do the likes of John Latsis get in return for their donations? In an understated way that was made clear by the head of Taylor Woodrow, Peter Drew, last week. His Tavlor Wondrow. Peter Drew. last company, one of the largest contributors to the Tory Party, had reduced their contribution in 1990, unhappy with certain policies, but he promised a much greater donation in 1991 because "we are pleased that our views on the economy are being taken on board and that Mr Major is performing well"
These companies are looking for policies that guarantee their profits, offer them low taxes, cheaper labour costs, restrictive anti-union laws. It is a package which, in the 1980s, became known as supply-side economics, and the Tories have made every effort to deliver it to their friends in the last 12 years.
midst all this, every worker should A calculate the compulsory contributions they have had to make to this Tory jamboree, for the profits and wealth of these companies have to be paid for by someone.
In the 1980s they were paid for by the unemployed, who became mere "excess capacity"; by those who worked in, or used, public services which have been cut to the bone or sold off to the private sector friends of the government; by the homeless victims of the run-down in the building programme and the sale of council houses. They are still being paid for by the huge numbers of low paid and the hopeless generations of young people looking for kicks on jobless council estates.
Norman Lamont, the Chancellor, recently said more about the Tories' attitude to our class than any socialist newspaper. "Continuing unemployment" , he said, "is a price worth paying for a revival in trade, growth and profitability". The social cost of Tory policies is, of course, of no consequence to those who will never have to pay it.
Meanwhile, for John Latsis, £2 million is "a price worth paying" for a government willing to go to such lengths and stick to such a brutal programme to revive the profitability of capitalism.
There was a time when most socialists, and even the Labour Party, would at least talk about expropriating these parasitic vultures, taking over their vast wealth and control of resources, not only to fund the NHS and education, but to run production rationally and democratically, to make it for the first time serve human need rather than the wealth and power of a tiny minority.
Since then Labour leaders, and many beyond that, have become finally convinced that this would too severely restrict the rights of some individuals to accummulate wealth, gain private ownership of industry, and control production in their own individual way.
Me? I think that is a price worth paying!
tion, ie. seizure and violence.
The government considers it the greatest of crimes against humanity to continue this war over the issue of how to divide among the strong and rich nations the weak nationalities they have conquered, and solemnly announces its determination immediately to sign terms of peace to stop this war on the terms indicated, which are equally just for all nationalities without exception...
The government proposes an immediate armistice to the governments and peoples of all the belligerent countries, While addressing this proposal for peace to the governments and peoples of all the belligerent coun tries, the Provisional Workers' and Peasants' Government of Russia appeals in particular also to the class-conscious workers of the three most advanced nations of mankind and the largest states participating in the present war, namely, Great Britain, France and Germany;
----- pull-quotes -----
ArEpolimcaL_ FRONT
"Every worker should calculate compulsory contribution have had to this Tory jan