Can Itake this that tr have been
Socialist Organiser1991 1991-09-26Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 7 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 7
TGWU Region 6 After the TUC conference Party conference, the debate on the future of employment legislation must continue.
At present, it is a very confused debate in which the voice of the rank and file has been inadequately heard. So let me try to outline wat lies at stake between the two main positions - for Labour's new framework of law, and in contrast to that the total repeal of all the Tory anti-union laws.
The limitations of Kinnock's proposals The first position unconditionally endorses Labour's proposals. What is being endorsed? Labour propose that restrictions on so-called "secondary" action will continue. So will sequestration and the clauses making unions legally liable for the acts of their officers.
Labour propose keeping the right of members to take their unions to court if detailed legal requirements on ballots over union elections and industrial action are not met. The courts, predictably, would have a field day - at our expense.
I repeat, what is being endorsed? Those who support Labour's new framework are arguing that if a group of car workers or bus workers or textile workers go on strike to support each other or, say, NHS workers, then they should be brought before the courts. That is what they are saying.
If, in such circumstances, a union failed to get its members back to work to the judges satisfaction, they would be in contempt of court. The fine for that is unlimited. So, if we did not pay, then our assets could be sequestrated up to an unlimited amount. Solidarity will still be outlawed Labour will keep sequestration, and those who support its proposals are supporting sequestration. And in doing so they are supporting the Taff Vale judgement, condemned for almost a century by our movement, revived by Norman Tebbit in 1982, and accepted by Labour in 1988.
What was good enough for Ramsay McDonald, Clem Attlee, Harold Wilson and Jim Callaghan - that is, opposition to Taff Vale — is not good enough for Neil Kinnock or Norman Willis.
The way Labour's proposals are drafted leaves interpretation open to the judges. Please remember how we have, with justification, condemned them in the past. Labour's new framework is a recipe for weaker unions and the maintenance of the Thatcher-inspired attacks on trade unionists.
A fresh start unions in contrast, is saying "break with The demand for "total repeal" Thatcherism and its attacks on the unions — don't adapt to it - make a fresh start."
Having weighed all the possibilities, I remain convinced that a fresh start means the total repeal of all the anti-union laws and their replacement by a Charter of Positive Rights. This would add to the individual rights proposed in Labour policy documents; clear cut rights to organise, bargain and take industrial action.
Such a charter would protect secondary action and peaceful picketing if carried out after a democratic vote. It would begin to give trade union members, as working people, the kind of rights that Justice demands should be theirs. In itself it would be insufficient, and so would the Labour Court, consisting of judges and industrial relations "experts" that Labour is proposing. Reforming the law and the judiciary A Charter of Positive Rights for trade unions and trade unionists must go hand in hand with reform of those who would "interpret" it - the judges.
In the higher courts judges should be appointed only after parliamentary scrutiny. They should be nominated from the 132210 lower courts whose personnel should be subject to election as part of a revived local government process. Positive discrimination should judges from the ethnic minorities. provide for more women and Only if we change the administration of the law, as well as the torm and content, will we secure a lasting and just settlement for trade unions and, more importantly, their members.
Is that asking for the earth? Is that revolutionary? It certainly appears to have some in our movement shaking in their Gucci loafers. I maintain that total repeal of all anti-trade union legislation and a legitimisation of the rights of trade unions and trade unionists is far better than the fudge and flannel espoused by some.
We should be confident and articulate in our demands. Doing so confirms our faith in our movement, its history and, most importantly, its future.
Slightly abridged from Trade Union News
----- pull-quotes -----
A come hatever is a bour come of this year's Labour