Vote yes to CPSA/NUCPS Why the NEC are wrong to oppose merger
Socialist Organiser1991 1991-09-19Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 15 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 15
An activist in the PSA demolishes some of the arguments that the CPSA leadership are using to oppose merger with NUCPS The NEC: The interests of CPSA members in the workplace, including our EO members are [not] the same as managerial grades HEO and above.
We say: The majority of NUCPS members are either EOs or basic Support and Specialist grades, with whom the NEC rightly does not see any problems. Our struggles would be immeasurably strengthened by CPSA/Support Grade/EO unity. Such unity will be far easier to achieve in one union, with one set of policies, and all members exposed to the same arguments. Do not reject merger with these grades because of other Executive grades.
Merger would also stem the dreadful loss of good and experienced members that CPSA suffers after every AO-EO promotion. EOs - including those in CPSA - do not have different interests to HEOs, that is why the majority of EOs are committed members of the NUCPS.
There is no fundamental difference in function between EOs and HEOs which places the latter in a more antagonistic relationship to other CPSA members.
There are a whole range of vital issues on which CPSA and NUCPS members have similar interests and policies: national pay bargaining, equal opportunities, proper statting levels, privatisation, pensions and severance terms, conditions in agencies, decent accommodation.
If the NEC were being honest, they would transfer all LCD HEOs/SEOs/PRINS to NUCPS. In fact, they are hostile to any such suggestion.
The NEC: We don't need a merger to achieve unity. We already work with all unions, including NUCPS, in the Council of Civil Service Unions, to present a united front to the employer.
We say: In truth the CPSA WHAT'S ON Thursday 19 September "Is Socialism possible?" , SW London SU meeting. 7.30, Lambeth Town Hall. Speaker Jill Mountford "After Stalinism can there be socialism?", , Nottingham SO meeting. 8.00, ICC, Mansfield Road "Why you need socialism", Brighton SO meeting. 5.00, Base ment, Polytechnic. Speaker Mark Sandell Friday 20 September "Stand up for real socialism". 1.00, Richmond College. Sponsored by Left Unity. Speaker Mark Sandell Saturday 21 September Campaign Against the Witch Hunt, National Working Conference. 1.00-5.00, Manchester Town Speakers include Terry Fields, Socialist Campaign Group MP Monday 23 September Into the dustbin of history -Stalinism and the USSR", SO London Forum. 7.30, Lucas Arms, Gray's Inn Road. Speak from Su anu wun rutzer works more closely with the NUCPS than with any other civil service union. It is in our common interest to do so - the same common interest which should unite us in one union.
But our present unity with the NUCPS is too weak, enabling senior management and union leaders time and again to divide us. The 1987 pay dispute resulted in a dreadful and demoralising split between the unions. Recent years have seen major disputes in DSS and PSA in which the two unions have at different times struck without the other but for the same objectives. Two unions means two decision making processes and two bureaucracies - a recipe for divide and rule tactics. We do need a merger for unity.
The NEC: We don't want managerial grades dominating our union.
We say: The proposed merger constitution provides stronger safeguards for the representation of basic CPSA grades than CPSA's own LCD and DE section constitutions! This protection should undoubtedly be strengthened within the merged union.
The NEC: you will have less say in the [merged] union, less control...and fewer rights.
We say: Annual conference in the merged union will continue to be the sovereign body, setting policy and determining the union's constitution.
The real argument is over whether the entire membership of the merged union should be able to elect the entire NEC. The draft constitution provides for election of the NEC by three constituencies (Administrative, Executive and Support/Specialist grades). Mechanisms to ensure CPSA grades' representation in a merged union are essential if we are to avoid Executive grades dominating the NEC. Whether the mechanisms be reserved seats, but with all the members able to vote for all candidates or constituencies, is a matter for debate and experience rather than opposition to merger.
The NEC: the merger terms are not the best ones possible.
We say: the NEC should indeed have negotiated better terms but they are a sufficient basis for merger.
CPSA/NUCPS merger
create real unity, improve our organisation, and strengthen our industrial muscle.
Vote for the merger!
Tuesday 24 September "Is socialism dead?", Northampton SO meeting. 5.00, Nene College. Speaker Paul McGarry "Justice for Dessie Ellis", 7.30, Conway Hall, Red Lion Square, Holborn, London. Speakers Paddy Joe Hill (Birmingham Six), Ken Livingstone MP Thursday 26 September "Fighting racism", Leeds SO meeting. 7.30, Coburg Pub Saturday 28 September "Stop the purges!" meeting at Labour Party conference, 7.30, Middle St Primary School, Brighton. Called by Friends of Brighton Labour Party.
Sunday 29 September "Our history", North London SO meeting. 7.30, Red Rose Club, Seven Sisters Road. Speaker Cath Nugent "Unshackle the Unions", fringe meeting called by LPS and SMTUC. 7.30, Royal Albion Hotel, Old Stein, Brighton. Speakers include Dennis Skinner, Peter Heathfield