Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

East and West: no difference

Socialist Organiser no. 499, 19 September 1991 · scan pp. 14–15 · about 486 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 14 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 14

respondence to comrade Clarence Chrysostom, but shortly before he went into hospital asked for it back to verify a few facts about which he wanted to write before returning it. At that point he died, and his literary executor, a supporter of Militant, refused to return it to us, containing as it did numerous embarrassing facts about political tendency.

It is no doubt now mouldering in the files of Hepscott Road, a sort of political/historical black hole into which large numbers of documents have vanished.

Whether you are an atheist or a believer, it is far better to carr on historical and political argument on the assumption that your opponent holds his views in good faith, in the absence of evidence to the contrary, otherwise the real content of the discussion becomes side-tracked. In the presence of the above facts, can I request that Laurens now abandon his campaign to smear the pioneer British Trotskyists with the accusation of religious obscurantism?

Al Richardson, have read your coverage of events in the Soviet Union with interest. But why always the insistence that if the USSR wasn't better than capitalism, it must have been worse [editorial, 5th September]?

This seems to me to lead to two serious political mistakes. One is that Western capitalist society has something desirable about it. The other is that when workers in the East look to the market, they are not entirely wrong to do so.

I am not arguing that the countries of Eastern Europe were anything but miserable places. Of course the experience of workers in say Leningrad and Birmingham is different. In the former, many basic services were heavily subsidised but there was no democracy and no choice. In the latter, there was more democracy and choice of a sort but increasingly less in the way of services.

In both cases, workers are now being hit hard by economic crisis. In both cases, the solution is to fight for real socialisni. Was there really any qualitative difference between the exploitation of the West and that of the East?

F O'Connor, 'Ted's idea of a good time is to go to a Labour Party meeting! I ask you - what kind of life is that for youth in the 1990s? Youth round here want to get a buzz out of life, but Ted just doesn't understand. I think he's lost his marbles, just like that other old geezer, Gerry what's-his-name.

*The councillors round here are all Labour and they're bloody useless. We used to have a National Education Centre in Militown but now it's shut down, along with a lot of other youth facilities.

*I stole a book from the local library before got burnt down. It was about American politics. When couldn't tell the difference between them Democrats and our Labour councillors. That's why me and my mates are into standing our own

Scan page 15

Socialist Organiser No. 499 pa

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 499

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →