Bad faith
Socialist Organiser1991 1991-09-19Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 14 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 14
+ the risk of extending Iready bidding for the Neil Kinnock Prize for Political Flatulence, I feel I must reply to Laurens Otter's repeated attempts to represent the Balham Group as Vestment and Incense freaks instead of revolutionary internationalists - to the great delight, no doubt, of all the opponents of the Trotskyist movement.
The argument hinges on two propositions: first, that Reg Groves never abandoned his religious convictions during the time he was a Communist and a Trotskyist, and second, that this was the political persona of the Balham Group, in spite of the overwhelming majority of its members, who were never religious.
The first point can be disproved by innumerable examples of Reg's writing during that period, from which I shall select only one:
*The ruling class began to see the importance of the working class "receiving in school or in places of worship that religious instruction that is necessary for knitting together the inhabitants and classes of a great country" and to this end, to the task of winning the workers away from revolutionary ideas... some secured a "softening" of the most glaring examples of the class character of church life and doctrine; others tackled education and issued instructive periodicals; others tinged their Christianity with Socialism in order to secure the confidence of the workers." (*The Dotage of the Hammonds", in Labour Monthly, November 1930, p700).
All the evidence is, in fact, that although Purkis returned to his religious views when he broke with the group in 1934, this did not take place in Groves' case until the Second World War, when he became involved with various pacifist bodies.
The second proposition is even more easily refuted. When Reg died in May 1988, his oldest surviving friend, Harry Wicks, attended the funeral and was shocked to find that it was a wholly religious one. He wrote: *1 have no quarrel with comrades or their families embracing the Church in the evening of their life, but to conceal it fron one's personal comrades so thoroughly in my view was unforgiveable on Reg's part. Both Roma Dewar, Hugo's sister, and Rita were amazed, to put it mildly - so much so that Roma declared to me that she had never heard of the Catholic Crusade and Reg's connection with it." (Letter to Ted Crawford, 2nd June, 1988).
One final point. I have always found it fascinating how people who make such a parade of their own faith are so quick to ascribe bad faith to others. I do not know to which members of the board of Revolutionary History Laurens refers when he speaks of those with "a more definite regard for historical accuracy than Al Richardson" — we all feel that we are committed to it.
But on the question of his correspondence with Sam Bornstein, I must inform him that although Sam did show me at least one of the letters before he died, none of his political correspondence in fact remains with us, contrary to his wishes.
Six months before he died he handed on his political cor-