Those who do not learn
Socialist Organiser1991 1991-09-19Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 10
Leopold Trepper was the head of the USSR's spy network in Nazi-occupied Europe. Months before the Nazi invasion of the USSR Trepper was sending details of Hitler's preparations to Stalin. They were ignored. On the eve of the invasion Trepper even supplied the precise number of divisions waiting to attack and their positions. All to no avail.
After the war Trepper was imprisoned by the KGB and only released during the Khrushchev thaw. In this extract from his book, The Great Game, Trepper honours the Trotskyists for their bitter, unyielding opposition to ing class could take power first. They believed they had a duty to maintain their bridgehead for workers' revolution in the most difficult and arduous circumstances.
The Bolsheviks were fallible human beings, acting in conditions of great difficulty. Mistakes they may have made in the maelstrom of civil war and economic collapse are proper subjects for socialist discussion and debate. As their critic and comrade Rosa Luxemburg wrote in 1918, the Bolsheviks would have been the last to imagine that everything they did in their conditions was a perfect model of socialist action for everywhere at all times. But what the Bolsheviks never were was the root of the Stalinist counter-revolution, which amongst its other crimes, murdered most of those who were still alive in the mid-1930s.
When things began to go wrong the Bolsheviks stood their ground. The workers' risings were defeated in the West. Invasions and civil war wrecked the soviets. The Bolshevik party itself divided. One section took a path on which it ended up leading the bureaucratic counterrevolution. The surviving central leaders fought the counterrevolution on a programme of working class self-defence and of renewing the soviets.
Those Bolsheviks (Trotskyists) went down to bloody defeat. Stalinism rose above the graves of Bolsheviks, just as it rose hideously Stalin. They were the only people who stood firm, people who could be proud of their past, unlike many newcomers to the cause of anti-Stalinism.
The glow of October was being extinguished in the shadows of underground chambers. The revolution had degenerated into a system of terror and horror; the ideals of socialism were ridiculed in the name of a fossilized dogma above the murdered socialist hopes of the Russian and international working class. By the late 1930s Stalin had slaughtered the leading activists not only from the Trotskyist, but also from the RightCommunist and even the Stalinist factions of the Bolshevik party of the 1920s. -Stalinism was not Bolshevism, any more than it was any kind of socialism. Trotsky, who was to die at the hands of Stalin's assassins, put it well and truly when he said that a river of working class and socialist blood separated Stalinism from Bolshevism. The workers in Eastern Europe and the USSR will learn the truth about that now that the possibility of open debate and honest information has been opened up.
Capitalism is vindicated by the disintegration of state socialism"
One of the most profound and heartfelt paeans of praise ever written about capitalism will be found in the Communist Manifesto, the founding document of the modern socialist movement. Capitalism gave a tremendous boost to human capacity to change and control our environment and thus created the objective possibility of humanity rising above its "pre-history" -out of the social jungle into a classless socialist society.
Scan page 11
from history are condemned to relive it history which the executioners still had the effrontery to call Marxism.
And yet we went along, sick at heart, but passive, caught up in machinery we had set in motion with our own hands. Mere cogs in the apparatus, terrorised to the point of madness, we became the instruments of our own subjugation. All those who did not rise up against the Stalinist machine are responsible, collectively responsible. I am no exception to this verdict.
But protest at Marxists criticise the waste and irrationality and savage inhumanity of capitalism, but at the same time see capitalism as the necessary forerunner of socialism.
Capitalism has not ceased to be irrational and inhuman, nor have market mechanisms ceased to be blind and wasteful just because of the Stalinist experiment in state socialism" • Wage slavery and exploitation have not ceased to be at the heart and root of capitalism. The possibility and even the inevitability remains of capitalism plunging once again into devastating slumps as in the '30s -and there are three million unemployed in Britain alone right now. Capitalism still presides over regular mass slaughters by hunger which are an indictment of any social system.
In the United States, the richest capitalist country in the world, thousands of people sleep on the streets, or get a living only through the drug trade. In the private-profit counterpart of Eastern Europe -Latin America - unemployment runs at 40% in the big cities, workers' living standards have sometimes been halved since the debt crisis broke in 1982, cocaine gangsters rule huge areas, and malnutrition and even starvation are widespread. Capitalism is no alternative at all!
Stalinism was not an attempt to go beyond advanced capitalism on the basis of the achievements of adtime? Who rose up to voice his outrage?
The Trotskyists can lay claim to this honor. Following the example of their leader, who was rewarded for his obstinacy with the end of an ice-axe, they fought Stalinism to the death, and they were the only ones who did. By the time of the great purges, they could only shout their rebellion in the freezing wastelands where they had been dragged in order to be exterminated. In the camps, their conduct was admirable. But their vanced capitalism which has proved by its failure the hopelessness of all such attempts. It was an experience on the fringes of world capitalism, arising out of the defeat of a working class revolution, and stifling under its own contradictory bureaucratic regime.
Stalinism was part of the prehistory humankind must grow beyond. So is capitalism!
Socialism is discredited because only a free market economy can give a secure basis for demcoracy. Witho it you get state control, an state control inevitably stifles democracy Marxists do not want any sort of bureaucratic state, neither that of a country like Britain, where the bureaucratic state works in tandem with the bourgeoisie, nor that of the Stalinist systems where the bureaucracy was the sole master of society's wealth.
We advocate a semi-state" without a standing army, without an entrenched bureaucracy. The Bolsheviks wanted that, too. They could not create it because of the backwardness of the isolated USSR, but it would be entirely possible in a country like Britain, voices were lost in the tundra.
Today, the Trotskyists have a right to accuse those who once howled along with the wolves. Let them not forget, however, that they had the enormous advantage over us of having a coherent political system capable of replacing Stalinism. They had something to cling to in the midst of their profound distress at seeing the revolution betrayed. They did not "confess, for they knew that their confession would serve neither the party nor socialism.
especially with modern technology.
The idea that only the market system of the West can be the basis for democracy is the idea that only wage slavery for the masses together with the phenomenal concentration of wealth - and therefore power - at the top of society can be the basis of democracy! It is a prize example of the crazy logic satirised by George Orwell according to which war is peace and lies are truth.
Even such democracy as we have in the West owes its existence to decades and centuries of struggle by the working class. Democracy in capitalism is limited, imperfect, and normally not very stable.
Mass self-rule by the producers, dominated neither by a bureaucratic state monopoly nor by the economic rule of the multimillionaires and their officials, is a better form of democracy. It is socialist democracy.
The reason for the economic impasse of the Eastern Bloc is that centralised planning capitalism is the only possible system This argument too rests the that Stalinism - the Stal co mand economy - was - was socialism. alis The attempt to have the state control everything served the Stalinists. not the working class. Marxists never believed that the working class could take power and simply abolish the market: in 1921 Lenin set the goal of Soviet government as that of occupying "the commanding heights of the economy"
socialism, once the workers have taken power and abolished wage slavery by taking the major means of production from the capitalist class, would - probably for generations ahead - operate through a combination of planning and market mechanisms - within the broad framework of a flexible plan.
There is a vast difference between an economy where the basic strategic decisions are made by democratic planning - which 1s certainly possible — and one where they are made by the crazy gyrations of the Stock Exchange.
How quickly a workers' planned economy will be able to make its planning more comprehensive, and move towards replacing the market altogether, must be an open question. We do not know now how quickly computer technology will progress.
The Communist Parties ditched Marxism and Communism, and they should know what they're talking The Stalinists rulers in the USSR have created an ideology through which their interests and their immediate political concerns were expressed in stereotyped language derived from Marxism. Marxist analysis has been no part of that ideological process.
Communist Parties like the British CP danced like performing bears to that official "Marxism" In the high Stalinist period, Moscow could say on Monday that Britain and France were democratic powers justly opposing ravenous German fascism, on Tuesday that British and French war-mongering imperialism were ganging up on peaceloving Germany, and on Wednesday that it was Anglo-French democracy against German fascism again — and the CPs would jump accordingly. (They did that between September 1939 and June 1941)CPs justified Stalin's terror and for decades lied systematically about the reality of the USSR. When told to, they collaborated with Nazis against socialists in German in 1931-33; coordinated Nazilike campaigning against "Jewish Trotskyists" in Mexico in 1939-41, when Hitler and Stalin were friends; organised bloody counterrevolution against the workers in Republican Spain in 1936-7; and so on. The list is almost endless.
Later, the CPs softened up, accommodated more to the societies they lived in, and for a couple of decades past they have occasionally criticised aspects of Stalinist rule. In practical politics, the West's biggest Communist Party, the Italian CP, has long been to the right of the British Labour Party.
These political whores and charlatans can speak neither for socialism nor for Marxism. The best service they can render to socialists and Marxists is to distance themselves from us, the more formally and explicitly the better. The air around us will eventually be a lot cleaner for their departure.
When the Italian ex-Communist Party decides to change its name, what is collapsing is not Bolshevism or Communism but the grotesque counterfeit of Marxism and socialism shaped and moulded by Psni:
Stalin, and in part sustained Stalin's wealth and power.
The collapse of Communisı vindicates the reformist "social democratic" model socialism Social democracy defined itself historically not against Stalinism but against Bolshevism. And the social democrats were wrong at every point against Bolshevism.
They either supported their own bourgeoisie, even against the revolutionary communist workers, or temporised and hesitated and thus helped the bourgeoisie to win.
It was the social democrats who rescued German capitalism in 1918, and thereby isolated the Russian Revolution. By betraying socialism or dithering in countries like German and Italy, the social democrats played the role of historic stepfather to Stalinism.
The Bolsheviks did not lead the workers to power believing socialism could be rooted in Russia; they led the Russian workers on ahead believing the European workers would follow. The socialist leaders in the West left them in the lurch, amidst the Russian backwardness, where Stalinism was eventually to grow up.
Whatever about this or that error made by the early Communist International, the international Bolshevik current was entirely right against reformișt social demonsa cy.
The reformists' criticisms Stalinism have often, of course, been correct. They have been right on the same questions bourgeois democrats have been right on The disintegration of Stalinism cannot lead logically to the conclus10n that reformist social-democracy is the answer — unless we also accept that Stalinism was socialism, and that its collapse therefore shows us that capitalism is the best we can ever hope for.
Reformist social-democracy is not a different strategy for achieving socialism. Socialism is the replacement of wage-slavery and the capitalist system built on it by a different mainspring - free cooperative self-administering labour. What has that got to do with the achievements of social democratic reform?
The fight for welfare-state reforms, and the defence of existing welfare state provision, is indeed necessary for socialists. But socialists cannot stop there. And very often today the reformists do not even defend the welfare state. The fight to defend welfare state provision is often a fight against reformists in power - as it was in Britain during the last three years of the 1974-79 Labour government. The socialism of the reformist social democrats is like the smile on Lewis Carroll's Cheshire Cat.
Since the 1920s, social-democratic parties have abandoned even a verbal commitment to fighting for a socialist system defined as something radically different from capitalism. They aspire at most to modifying capitalism, with a few welfare measures. In the 1980s, social-democratic leaders in France, Spain, Australia, New Zealand and Italy have become no better than pale-pink Thatcherites.
The only model socialism restored to its proper shape and colour by the disintegration of Stalinism and the open disavowal of socialism by the Stalinists is the only model of socialism that ever deserved the name - the fight to organise the working class as a clear conscious force, a class for itself, to break bourgeois state power and abolish wage slavery, and establish a comprehensive, democratic self-rule throughout society.
Scan page 12
in disarray Afghanistan - about five million people! - were driven over the border as refugees.
And you supported Russian imperialism's bloody war! Your preposterous dogmas led you to define it as the expansion of the "world socialist revolution' You wound up accepting, advocating, detending and gloritying the inevitability of Stalinism in most of the less developed countries as a progressive stage in the movement of the world toward socialism. As late as 1978 — yes 1978! — Ted Grant looked forward to a Stalinist officers' coup in Portugal! (See the article in the Summer 1978 edition of your magazıne.)
You don't want to accept that this was the implication of what you said and wrote? I don't blame you, Dave! But you will find that it is the unavoidable conclusion from what your organisation wrote. I analysed all this in a pamphlet some years ago, and there you will find all the relevant quotations from your organisation's articles and pamphlets.
But it was worse than that. The Mandelites and those who have had - again and again — ridiculous illusions in Tito and Mao or Castro usually need to tell themselves lies about it. They needed pretences and fantasies about what went on in these Stalinist states. You told yourselves a large part of the truth about them. You knew and I said that they were totalitarian societies where the working class was ruthlessly oppressed. And still you supported them, still you crowed in triumph for every advance by Stalinism (in Afghanistan, for example).
The "autonomous movement of the productive forces" was at work in the world, you said, like Adam Smith's hidden hand, inevitably creating Stalinist states which had n 1985, 17 Americans were killed by terrorists, out of some 28 million who travelled abroad. The response was a massive drop in US tourism — the 1 in 1.6 million chance of being killed scared millions into staying at home where they ran a risk of 1 in 5,500 of dying in a car accident, 1 in 20,000 of drowning or 1 in 68,000 of choking to death. Clearly they would have been safer abroad!
For John Allen Paulos, in his book Innumeracy*, this is one example of the mathematical equivalent of illiteracy, the inability to comprehend, compare and interpret numbers.
Understanding of probabilities is a particular area of weakness. Paulos shows how to calculate numbers of choices and probabilities in an attempt to help the reader overcome this. For example, a restaurant menu might offer a choice of four starters, seven main courses and three desserts. The total number of possible three-course meals is 4 × 7 × 3 = 84. This illustrates the multiplication principle: the number of choices or possibilities at each stage are multiplies together.
This can lead to some astronomical numbers. Consider the number of possible 7-figure telephone numbers. There are ten possibilities for each figure leading to 1010101010x 10 × 10 which gives 10 million possible numbers. Even if 0 and 1 are excluded for the first place, there are still 8 million.
Or how many ways can eight world leaders line up for a group photograph at a summit meeting? The choices decline as the leaders line up — 8 for the first place, 7 for the second and so on. So the number is 8 x 7 x 6 x 5 x 4 x 3 × 2 × 1 = 40,320.
In how many arrangements will Bush and Major be together? The answer is 2 an immensely progressive role to play — like the bourgeoisie in the time of Marx, developing the means of production - in most of the world.
And now? The *autonomous movement of the productive forces" - once the Stalinist political centres of command and terror have broken down - prove to be capitalist in direction!
You have been forcefully reminded of the basic Marxist truth that the working class can only take power consciously, and not through any "autonomous movement of the productive forces"
Your picture of a world in which capitalism is dying and a form of workers' power exists in large parts of the globe is shown to have been delirium, fantasy, political fool's gold.
What is left of Militant's "world outlook" now? What can be left of the political authority of leaders who have peddled such self-evident gibberish - reactionary gibberish! - for nearly half a century? Ted Grant's political authority is in crisis — to use the term Lyn Woods used when he talked to the Guardian reporter — not only, and not fundamentally, where the Labour Party is concerned. But what about the authority of people such as Taafe and Walsh who have run the organisation for a quarter of a century?
Now, your "world outlook" -spun out of ridiculous pseudoTrotskyist prettifying glosses on Stalinism - was never either coherent or intellectually worthy of respect. At one and the same time a Militant supporter could sing the praises of expanding - Stalinist -"world revolution" euphorically cite the "successes" of nationalised property as socialist successes and denounce Stalinist totalitarianism!
You called your theory "workers' statism" , but the terms of your actual theory were the opposite of the theory Trotsky had X 7X6 X 5 × 4 × 3x2×1= 10,080. Suppose the leaders line up at random. What is the probability that Bush and Major will be together? The answer is ¼ or 25% (10,080 divided by 40,320), illustrating that seemingly improbable events can have quite a nigh probability.
On the other hand, even quite improbable events will happen from time to time. Consider the chance of getting poker hands with four aces. The number of 5-card hands is 52 × 51 × 50 × 49 x 48. Since the order of the cards is unimportant, this number must be divided by 5 × 4 x 3 x 2 x 1, giving a total of 2,598,960. Of these, 48 will be 4-ace hands, since the fifth card can be one of the remaining 48.
The probability of 4 aces is therefore 48 divided by 2,598,960 or about 1 in 50,000. While it would be unwise I to Militant believed mystically apart irrational social class. What will "the plann the decrep ns created say now? propounded for the USSR in 1940 using the same name tag. You described Stalinist societies in which the nationalised economies were not in antagonism with the bureaucracy but were its own form of property, created by itsell, for a long transitional stage of history. In fact you described Stalinist societies - with the exception, perhaps, of the USSR, where, you said, conditions were now objectively ripe for a working class "political revolution" - in which the bureaucracy had a necessary and progressive function in the economy and was not at all the "cancerous growth" Stalin's bureaucracy was for LD Trotsky's "degenerated workers' state" theory in 1940.
Under the workers' state name tag you actually described a new form of class society in which the bureaucracy had the role of a progressive ruling class. You described the sort of society Shachtman described (and I believe accurately described) except that you believed it was progressive. The "workers' state" name tag was merely your way or saying it was "postcapitalist" and progressive.
In fact, for Stalinism, you had exactly the politics of Bruno Rizzi bank on getting such a hand, there must be several of these dealt every year in the many thousands of poker games that go on.
Lack of appreciation of the latter sort of fact leads innumerate people to mistake coincidence for what it is — the operation of probability. So is there any significance in the fact that President Lincoln's Secretary was called Kennedy and President Kennedy's Secretary was called Lincoln? No, says Paulos.
How about discovering that two people in a room share the same birthday? Should not this have a very small probability — say 1 in 365 squared, or about 1 in 100,000? Paulos shows that you only need 23 people for a 50% chance of two with the same birthday. How can this be?
The number of possible combinations of birthdays for this group is 365 times itself 23 times, a colossal number. The number of combinations with no birthday in common is 365 x 364 x 363... × 343, a not quite so colossal number. The latter divided by the former is just under ½ or 50% and is the probability that no two in the group share a birthday. Therefore, there is an above 50% chance that two will share a birthday.
Other seemingly improbable events can occur too, and fool the innumerate. Suppose a firm of stock market advisers gave you six consecutive correct tips about the movement of market prices. They then ask for E1,800 before sending you their next valuable piece of advice. Would you give it to them?
The trick works like this (and is illegal, I think). The firm sends 32,000 fancy letters to investors, 16,000 "predicting" a rise, and 16,000 a fall, in the coming week. Next week, they send 16,000 letters to the investors who got the "correct" information, 8,000 "predicting" a rise and 8,000 a fall.
After 6 predictions, 500 investors will have received 6 correct pieces of information. If they all send back £1,000, that's £500,000, a profit of quite a size for the outlay of about 64,000 letters.
Paulos has a lot to say about the amy ies a Stalin against whom Trotsky polemicises in In Defence of Marxism. Rizzi considered both fascism and Stalinism to be "bureaucratic collectivist" societies, and that they were progressive, moving towards socialism.
In a way, that fact alone sums up Militant's political and theoretical level: having a theory which in its historical evaluations, political conclusions and terms of reference was almost identical to Rizzi for Stalinist Russia, and thinking you had the theory Trotsky expounded against Rizzi in 1939!
You called it "permanent revolution". But from your "Bruno Rizzi" version of "workers' statism" you went on to incorporate what you called "Bonapartist workers' states" into your programme as an inevitable stage of development for most of the world, in the place where the Mensheviks had placed the bourgeois revolution.
Coherent, properly worked out, or intellectually respect-worthy this stuff surely never was, Dave. But it was quite powerful as a political artefact. If you didn't think about it, it would explain the world to you and your own place in it as a Trotmisuse of mathematics to fool the innumerate. Various pseudo-sciences are hauled into the dock, such as biorhythms, a concept invented by a friend of Sigmund Freud, Wilhelm Fliess. He proposed that our lives are governed by cycles of 23 and 28 days, observing that any number can be obtained by suitable combinations of these. Thus, 6= (23x10) + (28x-8). So any life event will coincide with some combination of these "cycles". Freud was very impressed with this, even believing that he would die at 51(23 + 28). In the event, he was able to hang on for another 30-odd years.
In fact, any number can be made from a combination of any two otlier numbers, if these do not share a common factor.
How about psychic powers such as dreaming of the future? Paulos shows that such dreams can occur quite commonly by chance. Suppose 1 dream in 10,000 is accident-predictive. The chance of a non-predictive dream is a massive 9,999 in 10,000. But in one year, the chance is 9,999 in 10,000 times itself 365. This gives a 96.4% chance of a non-predictive dream but a 3.6% of a predictive dream. In a country the size of the UK this means some million such dreams per year!
Paulos, a university lecturer, ruminates at length on the causes of innumeracy. The main fault seems to be in the education system, he thinks, which I think begs some questions. His suggestions for improvements include the use of more games and the teaching of estimation techniques.
Most of the book is quite entertaining and useful, and I am sure readers will agree that innumeracy is an obstacle in people's understanding of threats to their health, the results of government policies, of the claims of advertisers, of the behaviour of mortgage interest rates, and so on. * Innumeracy - Mathematical Iliteracy and Its Consequences, John Allen Paulos. Penguin, £4.99 (about £5 to the numerate). skyist. And now, it is gone where the Berlin Wall went!
That is left of your world outlook now? It is in tatters. And it is in this condition you set out on Healy's road to "build the revolutionary party"! Physic, heal thyself! Before you appeal to working class people to join this party, tell them tirst what you now stand for. Tell yourselves what you stand for.
Demand that your leaders — on both sides of the present dispute -tell you how they could have been so wrong on everything for so long!
Your tendency was built through routine propaganda activities within the protected environs of Labour's youth movement: and it is now quite plain that it was built on myths the myths about "Labour's mass left wing" and your predestined place within it and Militant's peculiar myth about *the world revolution" everexpanding by way of a "colonial revolution" that would inevitably - even in Portugal at the end of the '70s - produce progressive Stalinst "deformed workers' states"".
Probably it was inevitable that people with such a political record on the big questions would bungle things as badly as they did in Liverpool in the mid-'80s - and in Walton recently, where their stupid adventurism gave the Kinnockites the excuse for a new purge, and may well cost Dave Nellist and Terry Fields their seats in parliament. Some strategists!
This letter is overlong, and 1 must finish. Dave, for decades Militant has lived cut off from dialogue with the left. You poisoned the youth with bile and hatred against all the rest of the left. You affected disdain, and indifference, while your internal bulletin published vicious political misrepresentations, and often libels, of other left wingers — which their victims were not even supposed to know about, let alone have the change to reply to.
You should break with the hermit habits the *Exclusive Bretheren" Dave, and develop contact and dialogue with others of us on the left. In Socialist Organiser and the Alliance for Workers' Liberty we have long been grappling with the questions now placed brutally on Militant's agenda by the collapse of Stalinism in the USSR.
You have built an organisatior akin to a religious cult, not a healthy political party. Now some of those who built it find it turned on them. The organisation is starting out on a Healyite aventure, its ideas in shreds and tatters.
God knows what this organisation will now mutate into. But it won't - it can't - evolve into a serious revolutionary force in the British working class movement. For there to be any hope of that, you must first settle accounts with your history and draw up an honest political balance sheet of what you are, now that all your old ideas have collapsed, like your "perspectives" for the Labour Party Sean Matgamna
Scan page 13
isE
----- pull-quotes -----
cannot work in a complex economy: therefore