Capitalists Stalinist
Socialist Organiser1991 1991-09-19Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 10
Bdarling!" This was one ut socialism is dead, response on the street to the front page of the last Socialist Organiser: "Stand up for socialism". And there were many similar responses, sad as well as gleeful.
For sure, if the Stalinist systems were any sort of socialism, then socialism is dead, and it deserves to be dead. It was rotten and stinking for decades before its recent outright collapse.
But Stalinism was not socialism. It was the opposite of socialism.
Throughout our existence, Socialist Organiser has championed the underground workers' movements and the oppressed nationalities in the Stalinists states. We have waged war on the idea -held by many in the labour movement - that the Stalinist states were socialist in any sense or in any degree. It is the same idea being peddled now - but from the other side, not by confused would-be socialists, but by bourgeois propagandists who insist that Stalinism was socialism because they want to discredit socialism and bury it.
If socialists hold their course then we will find the collapse of Stalinism and the discrediting of its bureaucratic falsifications of socialism has cleared the ground for a new flowering of unfalsified socialism. Socialist Organiser is one of the bearers of the seeds of this new growth of socialism. Fighting the lies that socialism and Stalinism are identical, and that Stalinism was the same thing as the Bolshevik Russian Revolution, we will hasten the new growth of unfalsified working class socialism.
The first thing now is to answer the lies of the bourgeoisie and of the ex-Stalinists.
The system now disintegrating in Eastern Europe was socialist No it wasn't! It was a system of extreme exploitation of the workers and peasants, run by a backward bureaucratic ruling class with a monopoly of power. It was that bureaucracy which decreed that socialism meant their state nationalising and controlling everything - not Marx, or tor thạt matter Lenin.
Far from representing the working class, the Stalinist systems were characterised above all by a savage repression of the working class, and relentless persecution of working-class dissidents, especially workers who tried to organise independent trade unions The collapse of the planned economies in Eastern Europe means the eclipse of socialism Quite the opposite. It means the renewal of socialism. The disavowal of socialism by the Stalinists will help free socialism from the Stalinist, statist taint which poisoned much of the socialist and communist movement for six decades.
Socialism is a good idea — but it is not just a good idea! It is rooted in the class struggle of the working class. That struggle continues. The collapse of Stalinism has already opened up space for the workers, long suppressed, to begin to organise independently and think for themselves. They will formulate their own ideas. "Stalinism was not Bolshevism, any more than it was who was to die at the hands of Stalin assassins, put it w and truly when he said that a river of working class and socialist blood separated Stalinism from Bolshevism."
Marxists do not believe that the dominance of socialist ideas is inevitable among workers. The hard truth is that there are great obstcles in the way of workers becoming socialists when they have lived all their lives under a Stalinist totalitarian system disguised as socialism.
We see Eastern Europe. In the ex-Stalinist states the working class looks to the West and to market economics for its solutions. It mirrors the way in which working class movements in the West have for decades mistakenly looked to the Stalinist East as a model of escape from the peculiar horrors of our own society.
Nevertheless the prospect in all the East European states is for an intensified class struggle.
Many workers, faced with class conflicts, in the new conditions, will move towards a genuine working class world outlook. They will understand that the free market is no acceptable alternative to Stalinism, just as Stalinism was never a genuine working class alternative to the free market.
The rebirth of a mass socialist movement, cleansed of Stalinism, is a certainty in these conditions. It is a hard road from now to then, and it may be a long and winding road, but there is no other road for workers who want to defend their class interests to take.
Just as in recent years we have seen the inspiring development of such working class movements as South Africa's non-racial trade unions and the Brazilian Workers' Party - and Solidarnose too - in previously more or less fallow areas of class struggle, so we will see the emergence of new workers' movements in the opened-up exStalinists states.
Leninism bred Stalinism, is discredited with it -This is the central pillar of the edifice of lies now agreed on by bourgeois and ex-Stalinists alike. It is the biggest lie of all.
Lenin and the Bolsheviks led the workers to power. They fought ruthlessly against the bourgeoisie and the opponents of socialism. They smashed the walls of the Tsarist prison-house of nations. Far from substituting for the working class, the Bolshevik party, by its leadership and farsightedness, allowed the working class to reach and sustain a level of mass action hitherto unparalleled in history.
The Bolsheviks based themselves on a system of democratic working class councils (soviets). Their goal was working class democracy.
They never believed that they could make socialism in backward Russia, only that the Russian workLeaders of the Left Opposition in 1927
----- pull-quotes -----
any kind of socialism. Trotsky,