Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Why Militant

Socialist Organiser no. 499, 19 September 1991 · scan pp. 8–9 · about 1,772 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 8 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 8

When Militant had the initiative: on the left is Tony Ateman, a strategist; Tony Mulhearn and Derek Hatton - who advocated a Tory vote in the Walton by-election. The bearded man beaming Nancy Reagan-like adoration at the back of Derek Hatton's head is Richard Venton, Militant's Liverpool organiser.

Dave, Militant is now in the Mimidle of a profound crisis. It is not only a crisis about your relationship to the Labour Party, though that is one part of it, and immediately the focus of it.

It goes deeper and wider. The collapse of Stalinism has brought sharply into question — I would say shattered and destroyed - the entire world outlook on which Militant has stood for the past 44 years. Every key idea specific to the Militant as a political formation lies in ruins, the last of them, your ideas about the Labour Party, shattered by your "open party" faction. All revolution, socialist "colonial Militant's theories about the ever, all your illusions about the progressive role of Stalinism in developing the economies of underdeveloped countries have now been reduced to the same degree of credibility as the theory that the earth is flat and was created in six days by a benign God four-and-a-half thousand years ago! I will return to this fundamental aspect of Militant's difficulties.

I want to discuss Militant's crisis with you, Dave. It has been a long time since we talked. As you know, it is one of the things I hold against Militant most, the Stalinist spirit of dogmatic intolerance and hatred of others on the left in which it systematically trains its members, inculcating contempt for the ideas of everyone outside your Church of the Lord.

Given the way you are organised, and the schoolroom sort of internal life you have, this means in reality contempt for the ideas of everyone but a tiny group of your own leaders, who give "the line"

You call this *Bolshevik discipline" But the Bolsheviks were never like that. They had more confidence in their own ideas: their leaders were ideologically braver.

The crisis now is caused by Militant's turn to electoralism, by the adoption by most of Militant's leaders, of a perspective of "one, two, many Waltons."

The turn to electoralism against Labour is undoubtedly the turn to "building the open revolutionary party" , a turn to Gerry Healy's old politics. You don't think so?

the cabbblthe Soyle nyasion of Afganistan By Lahn o Matorty Reprinted from the orgina *96s Eaton ath new introducion Reprinted g A Workers Liberty Pamphlet A Workers Liberty Pamphlet E2 plus 34p post Box 823, London SE15 What is it then? It is not possible to stop halfway down that road, Dave! Already, Militant's Walton candidacy has led to this turn. That •gic is irreversible, and the youth ho now press for "independence' will make sure it is.

The irony of staggering, Dave?

In 1984, when the miners were making the biggest attempt the labour movement ever made to break Thatcher, Militant had the leadership of the Merseyside labour movement. Instead of standing up to the Tory government, fighting side by side with the miners, Militant left the miners in the lurch and did a deal with the Tories - which lasted just a year, and then, the miners beaten, they came for Militant. You also played into the hands of Kinnock.

In 1984 Militant's leaders should dared to fight'. Liverpool dared to fight: Militant did not."

have been willing to stand up to the Tory government, letting the logic of the class struggle decide, and if necessary breaking with the Labour leaders.

Large numbers of labour movement activists could then see plainly that Kinnock was playing the role of outright scab against both the striking miners and the Liverpool council. Today, those of them still active are prepared to put up with almost anything from Kinnock because they can now see no way of beating the Tories except a Kinnock General Election victory.

If necessary, if the logic of the class struggle dictated it, then Militant should then have broken the Liverpool District Labour Party away from the control of Kinnock and his friends - and appealed for support from class struggle Labour people throughout the country.

That would have been the opposite of the little sectarian, electoralist stunt in Walton which has (LITANT FOR LABOUR AND YOUTH DEFENCE FORCE When reality was brutal Militant always took refuge in pipe dreams: the Protestant and Catholic communities are murderously divided on the national question? Pretend that they can be united around minimal trade unionism, which avoids the great political issues! all this is pretty though, isn't it Direct from Bugside barricade Past Jones (Derry Lab Party Young Socialists) Aug. 25. IRELAND now become the occasion for your break with the Labour Party - at a time when the class struggle is at the lowest ebb in 50 years, and the Labour left is weaker than at any time in 30 years!

Both the class struggle and the left in the labour movement are now at such a low ebb because we suffered defeat in the miners' strike, and the defeat, or surrender, everywhere, of those who, in the early '80s, posed as a local government left.

If Militant had pursued different policies in the mid-'80s, it might have made a radical difference: we might have won.

You say Militant was too small, with only a few thousand members? It was small, but it held a commanding position in Merseyside. Merseyside could have been brought in to struggle against the Tories together with the striking miners. The potential leaders of other local government struggles could then - perhaps - have followed Liverpool's lead.

Yet other workers could have been drawn in to a burgeoning and coalescing wave of class struggle -the dockers, for example.

You will recall that on two occasions during the miners' strike the dockers were on the edge of a national strike.

That strike alone might have tipped the balance in favour of the miners and against the Tories. Not the miners but the Tories would have gone down to defeat.

And the dockers would not later have been defeated and the National Dock Labour Board destroyed, as it was two years ago.

I put it to you that such a scenario is not mere fantasy. All the elements were there in the labour movement at that time. All those possibilities were there in the real situation. They only needed a catalyst.

Defiance of the Tory by Liverpool council been that catalyst.

A Liverpool general strike alone - and an opinion poll in 1983 showed that a majority of Liverpool workers would have backed a general strike in support of Liverpool council if it had confronted the Tories, as its leaders promised the great mass demonstration they led through the centre of Liverpool that To work in the mass party of the trade unions, the Labour Party, Militant needed to pretend that it's right wing leaders could be made to bring in a socialist programme. Leaving the Labour Party, they are still advocating "Labour to power on a socialist programme" (it was one of their slogans in the Walton by-election!) they intended to - would have decisively ended the isolation of the miners.

Everything in the last seven years might have been different, Dave. Thatcher was not as strong as she seemed, nor were the Tories: they seemed so strong, and looked so invulnerable only after they had beat the miners.

The way in which the panicky Tory MPs ditched Thatcher last year showed decisively that Thatcher was never as strong as she seemed.

And even if the miners, dockers and left-led local government had combined and coalesced their interests in 1984, and had nevertheless still suffered defeat, even then, things would be better than now. The labour movement would have been beaten in a fight, not suffered the demoralising horrors of a major defeat without a fight.

In fact, of course, only the miners fought, while the rest of the labour movement, from the TUC leaders to Militant - where Militant was in a position to lead a fight, and a crucial one — slunk away instead of fighting.

That is the shameful reality behind Militant's big talk about *Liverpool, the city that dared to fight" . Liverpool dared to fight: Militant did not!

This may seem a very harsh judgement, Dave. It is harsh. But it is a tair judgement, and true to reality. -Militant chose to do a deal with the Tories, left the miners in the lurch, and allowed the mass support in Liverpool for a fight to bleed away slowly. Why people who call themselves Trotskyists did this is a mystery to me. But many things BUTR that happened in Liverpool then are beyond my comprehension, especially the bizarre doings of Derek Hatton, your leader there — and that, Dave, is what he was, whatever place he had in your hidden inner hierarchy.

That was the time to break with Kinnock! If you wanted to make this turn out of the Labour Party, it such an attempt was to be anything other than a politically suicidal desertion of the political labour movement, there was your chance.

It would have been the Liverpool Labour Party backed by much of the working class in the area. After it, others areas might have followed, in an atmosphere of solidarity strikes with the miners. Not only could the Tories have been brought down, but the "Kinnockite Tendency" in the Labour Party could have been stopped in its tracks by the working class movement Militant might have unleashed, had its leaders had the stomach for it.

At the very least, - forgetting for the moment about the development of the class struggle, and thinking only about the development of your "revolutionary party" — you would have had a vastly greater number of people around you to build your organisation from, many of them tempered class struggle fighters too.

The truth is that the leaders of Militant did "forget all about the development of the class struggle" They hung on to "power" in Liverpool, just like any of the other local government left cliques, in the safest way they could devise -manoeuvring with the Tories.

Like the old routinists of the Second International, Militant's leaders put the preservation of their

Scan page 9

oporter of Militant is in disarray ep Labour

----- pull-quotes -----

Marxism, Stalinism and the Militant

«The reality behind Militant's big talk about "Liverpool, the city that

NORTHERN FOR A UNITED WORKERS

NOW CARRY OUT A SOCIALIST PROGRAMME

RARXISR TRIA

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 499

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →