After the
Socialist Organiser1991 1991-09-19Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 4 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 4
Laird wields the AEU's block vote (Photo: John Harris) omkusion over the amt-aton hams he only way the present пЕТИ been a right to strike. shall be via workplace ballots, Trong te (Nf TennifAre unicons. from the impact of a branch voting, postal ballots or a Or deg manil Moe eneral law by stating tha methods."
по носкор во хлаліміє unlawful in certain specified cir- Support for a right to prougl legisiao nimt rim cumstances. The immunity form idl bysamong омонитесм buttressed the idea that unions sharpen up our support for the We mov vere privileged and above the on secondary action and the clos tracks or, and justified the judges by ensuring that the nigI-ilm individual H (HUS. terpreting policy and unravelling legitimating criterion is always generalised of the immunities. We should union democracy hei leg legitimacy of trade Finally, as well as the content we have to organise, a right to recogni- we also need to examine who will ship, a right to strike, and a right administer it in practice. Unless of Neil ballots. Ron Todd, for example ment process.
We argues CUTE RESHE LAVOLUE ointment of the top judges mus *Total be subject to both popular and in the slogar favour of ballots, and uses this to parliamentary Labour the issuee are permaos pette ballots and secondary action the the continuation of The would produce Unionists and their Unions. similarly and effectively used to entify the left as opponents employment emocratic participation could NALGO, MSF will bargain, and will open up the the also be used to open up wide ficers to the ownership of in Glasgow vote did not seal things All workers more open situation. The best will the coite moocas for in sation's Workers' Charter of Positive THE-UNIONIS he Glasgow TUC had little that was new to say for itself, and still less that offered encouragement to the left.
It witnessed the further By Sleeper consolidation of the influence of the right-wing Shadow Cabinet and their policies of civilised Thatcherism. It confirmed the characterisation of the General Council - right and left — as a conduit pipe for the transmission of Kinnockism into the unions.
Not a lot went on. This September Song had time for nothing but the waiting game. There were more soundbites than substance. Speeches were studded with *social partnership" "workers' councils" , "ECstyle industrial relations" "enterprise committees" charm words for class collaboration.
The major debates saw victories for the right. Voting on the two central issues - the future of wages policy the repeal of the Tory employment legislation -had Kinnock's flunkey Tony Blair purring. The important exception, the vote to boycott the Tories' Employment Action Programme, was heartening.
Isolated from the general drift of policy and from any programme to fight unemployment now, taken with the other decisions, its significance becomes more limited. Its application will undoubtedly be subject to fudging by the new General Council.
On the whole, the lett remains fragmented and subordebat on ment Is COnt 218/13 anti-union legislation need to emphasise rights ony for workers. dinate, lacking any coherent alternatives to waiting for Kinnock and slavishly endorsing every jot and tittle of his disastrous policies.
The limitations of the left were highlighted in the debate on employment legislation. The TGWU Broad Left have correctly made this a central issue in their campaigning. The inadequacies of their approach and the tenuous nature of their control over the union were cruelly highlighted. Ron Todd Logisi ion immunised dustrial ction woul HOE be unionism by arguing for a righ tion, a right to 100% memberdemocratic participation for This latter is contentious, but me justified. It will acion, elc. but Calls for the repeal of roar inht. leaders arguments from election of ofdemocratically participate in managed to convince the delegation by a 7-1 margin that they should vote for continuing restrictions on secondary action, and the right not to belong to a trade union.
The super-yuppie Blair purred; "There will be no return to the 1970s, no flying pickets, and no secondary action". Presumably Ron and his successor Bill Morris agreed. The unions are now saddled with proposals that incorporate the Taff Vale decision; place control over mix of these and other en chon and form of future legislation magistrates and judges POVER CHE meton where greater ambers and replacement man the Twi alternatives once We must be prepared for this Rights. all forms of solidarity action in the hands of an unaccountable undemocratic judiciary; provide for total sequestration of unions' assets; and generally reproduce many of the problems that faced the unions prior to 1906.
Norman, Neil and their assorted honchos were also over the moon with the gargantuan composite on wages policy. This pleged support for a national minimum wage, a National Economic Assessment and co-ordinated wage bargaining. It was agreed that increases produced by the minimum wage would not be taken into account by bargainers • to restore differentials. However, there would be no pay norms and no incomes policy.
It is clear, however, despite the vigorous denials, that the carrying of this composite provides a smokescreen of legitimacy for the TUC to prepare the ground for incomes policy - as both John Edmonds, who supports wage restraint, and Gavin Laird, who opposes it, hinted.
The minimum wage is a welcome, if limited, innovation. It is popular, but is likeIv to affect under 8% of workers and wages not incomes. It will be difficult to police and will only increase hourly earnings to £3.40 -50% of the average. As Kinnock reassured The Director; "we will introduce the 50% level promptly, but any advance on that is going to depend entirely on the performance of the economy...It's likely that any advance will be beyond the lifetime of one parliament."
In return TUC enforcement of the "no knock-on effect" in other negotiations is already a foot in the door for wage restraint. Moreover, Kinnock's latest policy document, Opportunity Britain, specifically links the minimum wage with the
Scan page 5
Socialist Organiser