Scrap all the anti-union laws!
Socialist Organiser1991 1991-09-05Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 16 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 16
TUC's debate law reports on the on trade union always thought this movement was built so that the weak would be supported by the strong. What's wrong when nurses or other healthworkers request the support of other workers?"
That's how miners' president Arthur Scargill defined the issues during the debate on the anti-union laws at the TUC Congress in Glasgow this week.
He's dead right. The issue is solidarity. Trade unions depend for their strength and effectiveness on sticking by old principles like "unity is strength" and "an injury to one is an injury to all".
All workers who want to take solidarity action in support of other workers (and vote to do so) should have the right.
It is simply wrong for the Labour Party and trade unions to put forward any other position. But, sadly, they do.
Ron Todd, general secretary of the TGWU, moving the resolution finally adopted by Congress, talked about the next Labour government making some forms of currently 1llegal secondary action legal again.
But Todd focused on the example of employers setting up operations under different company names. This is a device to ensure that workers who all work for the same boss can't go on strike to support each other because they have dif ferent "legal" employers.
Todd failed to make it clear that the Labour Party statements that he endorsed (as good bases to build on), "Looking to the Future" and "People at Work", have been interpreted by the Labour front bench as outlawing solidarity.
Michael Meacher (golden boy Blair's predecessor, sacked for being too soft on the unions) was very explicit about this back in 1989:
*Would it be lawful [under a Labour government] for workers to refuse to handle imports from South Africa? Answer, No.
"Would meat porters be allowed to take action in support of nurses? Answer, no...We would retain the current code of practice on peaceful picketing which limits the number of pickets [to six]." (Independent, 9 October 1989)
The issue is not ballots for strikes and the election of union executives versus no ballots, as the press and the right wing have tried to present it./ What the NUM, PTAT, MSF, NALGO and others were fighting for at Congress was the right to solidarity action, industrial and political, and effective picketing.
The issue is solidarity, not ballots. And as Arthur Scargill put it: "With workplace ballots the NUM gets 80% turn outs. Under postal balloting that can fall to 35%."
Safeguarding democracy and participation in the trade union movement - including ballots and the election of executives - is a matter for the union members themselves, not the law.
Ron Todd may have won the day for Kinnock with a 2:1 majority for his resolution, but the issue is far from dead.