Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Dinosaurs and monkey trials

Socialist Organiser no. 498, 5 September 1991 · scan p. 15 · about 1,137 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 15 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 15

By Peter Strikes, far from being and part of the dinosaur past of the TUC, could generate massive anti-Tory sentiment if they were explicitly supported by the leaders of our movement.

A current example of potential lies in the Tunnocks' dispute. This dispute, by 500 mainly women workers at the Tunnocks factory in Lanarkshire, just a few miles from where conference is meeting, is now entering its fourth week.

The workers' claim for 10% has been supported by wide sections of the local community. It has also generated support from railway workers and fire brigade workers and it has been at the two latter groups' request that a mass meeting has been planned for Saturday 7 September.

Railway workers and dockers have both pledged not to touch Tunnocks stock.

This action highlights the flaws in the TUC leadership's position. Willis and Co. are utopian. For as long as capitalism exists, workers will continue to go on strike and support each other, as the interests of capital stand against the interests of the workers. Despite what Norman Willis says, there are two opposing sides in the class war, not a "partnership".

Support the Tunnocks strikers! Donations and messages of support and requests for speakers to Maria Friel, 11 Lynn Walk, Uddington, Lanarkshire, Scotland.

LES HEARN'S

By holiday reading has been another Ibook of essays by American biologist, palaeontologist and evolutionist, Stephen Jay Gould. Readers may recall my enthusiastic reviews of many of his earlier books.* This latest book, Bully for Brontosaurus**, is a sort of random walk, though there is usually some link, sometimes tenuous, with Gould's specialism.

In Grimm's Great Tale, Gould relates the evolution of languages (first systematised by the Brothers Grimm, in between collecting tales of Rapunzel and Rumpelstiltskin) to the spread of humans across the world and the accompanying evolution of various different characters. The distribution of blood groups suggest an African origin for humans, with one emigrant branch giving rise to European, North Asian and Amerindian groups, and another to SouthEast Asian, Pacific and Australian groups. This pattern links in quite well with attempts by linguists to construct a family tree for all (or most) of the world's languages.

Various types of pseudoscience or anti-science feel the lash of Gould's typewriter, though not without a certain sympathy (except in the case of "creation science"). Rather topical, given the plethora of "alternative' theories aromatherapy, crystals, psychoanalvsis) is the account of the scientific investigation of mesmerism by a French Royal Commission in the 1780s. Mesmer developed a theory of animal magnetism, an undetectable fluid found in all living things. In sick people, the passage of the fluid was blocked, but Mesmer was able to unblock it, inducing all sorts of dramatic displays in his patients (shaking, screaming, falling, etc) and curing their illnesses.

The commission, including Antoine Lavoisier (discoverer of oxygen) and Benjamin Franklin (US ambassador and electrical experimenter), carried out a full set of scientific tests of the claims of Mesmer, with the latter's cooperation since he sincerely believed in his own powers. The details are fascinating but lead clearly to the conclusion that the symptoms of mesmerism were induced by self-suggestion and the only illnesses cured were ones that would have got better anyway or which were psychosomatic.

Nowadays, only religious fundamentalists (definition: SOmeone who speaks through their fundament) reject Darwin's theory of evolution and past opponents are generally seen as obscurantists, but Gould shows that their motives were not always suspect.

Tolstoy, for example, rejected what be mistakenly saw as a justification for a society of struggle in which the poor and disadvantaged would Lose out. Another, William Jennings Bryan, whose campaign against teaching evolution in US schools culminated in the Scopes "monkey" trial of 1925, was in other respects a reforming politician. He campaigned for the presidency on a platform of independence for the Philippines and against US imperialism, for women's suffrage and for a graduated income tax, and he resigned from the government as a pacifist over US entry into World War I.

Darwin's theory had been hijacked and used to justify and reinforce oppression, class society, racism and militarism (particularly by the German officer Even the textbook used by John Scopes to teach evolution discussed the harm to society from a class of people who spread crime, disease and immorality. Humanity could not kill these people (!) but could prevent them breeding and perpetrating "such a low and degenerate race" . Bryan's gut feeling was that these ideas were an abomination but he chose the wrong way to fight them. He died shortly after his humiliation by radical lawyer Clarence Darrow while the US went on to develop the most comprehensive set of "eugenics" laws outside of Nazi Germany.

But there were Darwinians who rejected the misinterpretation of natural selection as justifying capitalism and imperialism. Prince Peter Kroptotkin, the Russian anarchist socialist and naturalist, found in his studies a bitter struggle for survival with nature but a great deal of cooperation between living things in that struggle. He used his findings to introduce his book on social cooperation, Mutual Aid.

"Darwin's theory has been hi-jacked and used to justify and reinforce oppression. "

Gould injects a more personal note in The Median Isn't the Message. In 1982 , he learnt he was suffering from mesothelioma, a rare cancer usually associated with exposure to asbestos. Recovering from surgery, he asked his doctor what technical literature she could recommend on mesothelioma. She said there was nothing worth reading. Gould discovered this to be a white lie as the literature he consulted told him that the cancer was incurable, with a median mortality time of eight months.

Initially stunned, Gould started thinking. "Median" isn't the same as "mean" or average. It means that, of all cases, half die before 8 months, and half after. The half that die before include those who are dead already when the cancer is discovered, or whose cancers are very advanced, or who were old and frail, etc. Gould was relatively young with an early stage cancer, and he had every chance of being in the second half. But was not his chance of living long still very low?

That would depend on the mean time of survival, or, more accurately still, on the mean time of survival of young, fit people with small cancers operated on early, and so on. Nine years later, he's still going strong.

My only carp about this book is the use of American colloquialisms and baseball terms which mean nothing to me. It's a little expensive in hardback, so l suggest waiting until it comes oin paperback. His other book are all in paperback, so might like to start with them * Wonderful Life, The Pam Thumb, The Mismeasure of Mar * Hutchinsop Radi

----- pull-quotes -----

SCIENCE COLUMN

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 498

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →