SWP Open Letter: a statement of faintheartedness Ope
Socialist Organiser1991 1991-09-05Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 14 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 14
The Socialist Workers ] Party (SWP) has pro duced yet another Open Letter".
The latest "Open Letter" is to "Labour Party members and socialist activists" and begins by referring to the threat of expulsion hanging over Labour Party members who canvassed for Militant candidate Lesley Mahmood in the recent Walton by-election.
Naive readers might believe that this introduction would be followed by a strategy for fighting the witch-hunt, or maybe an appeal to support the antiwitchhunt conference being held in Manchester later this month, given the SWP's apparent concern about Party members facing expulsion.
In fact, what follows is the usual dreary denunciation of Kinnock for ditching left-wing politics in order to win a general election. It's hardly news, is it? And in any case, the SWP has never lifted a finger to try to stop Kinnock ditching such policies. In fact, it has — marginally - helped Kinnock and the right by its campaign to get people to leave the Labour Party to Kinnock: Kinnock pushes, the SWP pulls.
*Many of us (ie. the signatories to the letter) hav left the Labour Party in disgust at Kinnock's policies", continues the letter.
Any half-way serious
socialist should surely be embarrassed to put their name to such a statement of faintheartedness and desertion.
What it means (insofar as i means anything at all is that the letter's signatories have simply responded on an emotional level to Kinnock's right wing offensive ("...in disgust at...") and, by leaving the Party, have helped Kinnock to continue his offensive by weakening Open letter to Labour Party members and socialist activiste Not a strategy for witch-hunt the opposition to it. And if it is legitimate to leave the Labour Party "in disgust at" the leadership's policies then presumably the letter's signatories would recommend that socialists should pull out of trade unions where the leaderships have equally disgusting policies.
The letter concludes with the usual ritualistic call to "build an independent socialist alternative to Labour", by which the SWP means the SWP (although a number of signatories to the letter would place a rather di ferent meaning on this phrase). Thus, an "Open Letter" which begins by lamenting the plight of socialists facing possible expulsion from the Labour Party ends up recommending that they leave the Labour Party voluntarily and join an organisation which has been expelling socialists even longer than Neil Kinnock (and an awful lot more of them, as a matter of fact!).
This is what the SWP calls "party-building", However, an article on the recently formed Liverpool Independent Labour Party (ILP) which accompanied the "Open Letter" in Socialist Worker No.1254 provides an insight into what "party-building" SWP-style is all about.
The article itself is the literary equivalent of the Tower of Babel, where one half-truth and incoherency follows another. The really interesting statement is: *...Lesley Mahmood was soundly beaten [emphasis added] (in the Walton by-election). For in the weeks preceding the vote, oppor tunities to build an all-out strike (in the Council dispute) were thrown Now the idea that Mahmood was "soundly beaten" in Walton because there was no all-out strike by council workers is simpl gobbledeygook.
She was "soundly beaten" because her campaign was based on a pack of lies, was run by a bunch of sectarians and because she stood in the tradition -and the odium - of Derek Hatton's version of Tamany Hall politics.
But in the "Open Letter" produced by the SWP immediately after the Walton by-election, the SWP declared that Mahmood had achieved a great feat in her election campaign, and Paul Foot was positively ecstatic about the election result in Socialist Worker. It was proof, he wrote, that nationally the left could win a half million votes!
So why the difference the interpretation of the significance of Mahmood's vote? The answer is simple.
Immediately after the by-election the SWP was seeking to ingratiate itself with the fools in Militant who had decided to stand Mahmood. Hence the SWP's silly attempt to present a humiliating defeat as a great victory.
In the article on the Live pool ILP, on the other hand, the SWP wants to persuade the former that elections are really a waste of time and that all that really counts is strikes. Hence the reference to Mahmood being "soundly defeated".
As is always the case witl the SWP, an honest analysi of reality is ditched in favour of the most promising recruitment gambit -even if it means saying one thing one day and the opposite thing the next day.
And these are the people who call themselves "Marxists", and who claim that they are "an independent socialist alternative to Labour'"!
Scan page 15
lise
----- pull-quotes -----
EYE ON THE TEET