Outmoded concepts?
Socialist Organiser1991 1991-09-05Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 14 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 14
In his article on "Who are the Democrats?" John O'Mahony raises a number of issues which he leaves unexplained and no doubt a number of readers like myself would welcome clarification.
1. John is keen to reassure us as to the commitment of Lenin and the Bolsheviks to democracy and in particular a plurality of political parties. He tells us that, "nobody in the communist movement advocated the idea that soviets would be ruling organs of the state in a one-party system." Yet nowhere in his article does he produce a single quotation from Lenin or his co-thinkers that would suggest that this was adhered to as a matter of principle. There are a large number of quotations from both Lenin and Trotsky which would suggest the opposite:
*We have more than once been accused of having substituted for the dictatorship of the Soviets, the dictatorship of the Party. Yet it can be said with complete justice that the dictatorship of the Soviets became possible only by means of the dictatorship of the party... in this substitution of the power of the party for the power of the working class there is nothing accidental and in reality there is no substitution at all... the Communists expressed the fundamental interests of the working class." (L. Trotsky, "Communism and Terrorism" 1920, Ann Arbour, 1961, p.109).
... to allow... the idea of a partíal, whether open or camoflauged curtailment of the leading role of our party would mean to bring into question all the achivements of the revolution and its future... The party created the state apparatus and can rebuild it anew, if it is really the party. If there is one question which basically not only does not require revision but does not so much admit of the thought of revision, it is the question of the dictatorship of the party and its leadership in all spheres of our work." (L. Trotsky, "Tasks of the 12th Congress of the Russian Communist Party" 1923, in 1 "Leon Trotsky Speaks" ', Pathfinder, 1972, pp158161).
"Yes, it is the dictatorship of one party. That is what we stand for and we shall not shift from that position." (Lenin, "Speech at the first All-Russia Congress of Workers in Education and Socialist Culture" , July 1919, in Collected Works, Vol 29, p535).
The above is only a small selection from a large number of quotations along the same lines.
2. Evidence would suggest that it was not until 1936 that Trotsky, having finally abandoned the project of reform of the CPSU, endorsed the principle of a plurality of political parties. "A restoration of the right of criticism and a genuine freedom of elections are necessary conditions for the further development of the country. This assumes a revival of freedom of Soviet parties, beginning with the party of Bolsheviks and a resurrection of the trade unions," (The Revolution Betrayed", 1936, Pioneer, 1957, p.289).
3. John's "proof" of the Leninist commitment to political pluralism is the continued legal activity of other parties throughout most of the Civil War. The key phrase here, however, is, in John's own words, "non-Bolshevik parties loyal to the workers' state" . The definers of "loyalty" and therefore the arbiters as to which parties should be allowed to function were clearly the Bolsheviks. Moreover, any serious student of the period who has studied the relevant literature, such WHAT: SiON Thisden 5 September done". Hosted by Nottingham Trades 7.30, Friends Meeting House, Clarendon Findey 6 September 220 g Saturday 7 September as Leggett's book on the Cheka, is well aware of the severe restrictions under which "loyal" parties were allowed to function.
-4. John's position becomes even less tenable when he tells us that, "When, in March 1921, at the end of the Civil War, the Bolsheviks banned all other Soviet parties, was a temporary measure." This is somewhat contradictory. If these other parties constituted a threat to the "workers' state" , then surely they should, according to John's criterion of "loyalty" , have been banned during the Civil War and not after it.
Lenin's commitment to political pluralism was limited irrespective of the conditions which prevailed in Russia in the post-Revolution years.
It is worrying therefore, that John should continually seek to disguise this fact and try to recondemocracy? cile Leninism with a full-blooded commitment to representative democracy and political pluralism.
There is a genuine and fundamental dilemma confronting socialists, how to reconcile within the framework of a future socialist society, the maximising of opportunities for working class people to participate, to express their interests of l Gordon and to exert their power with the preservation and development of representative democracy based on universal suffrage and a commitment to political pluralism.
Continued adherence to outmoded concepts of Leninism only serves to confuse and obfuscate that McCalman