Bearing witness
Socialist Organiser1991 1991-09-05Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 12 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 12
Those who do not learn from history n the year when the Italian Communist Party, the PCI, changed its name to the Party of the Democratic Left, making the final, formal break with the legacy of the party founded at Livorno in 1921, it is interesting to look at the life of one of that party's founding members, the well-known novelist Ignazio Silone.
Ignazio Silone was born Secondo Tranquillo in the village of Pescina dei Marsi in southern Italy on May Day 1900. By the age of 17 he was a committed socialist, succeeding in meeting the challenge so many socialists failed to do when it came to opposition to World War I. Amongst his earliest writings were articles for the socialist papers attacking the corruption of the contractors awarded money to rebuild areas devastated by the 1915 earthquake in the south of Italy.
The works of Ignazio Silone should be essential reading for socialists, especially his earliest works before the atrocities of Stalinism drove him back into the arms of the Catholic Church.
Silone has never achieved the degree of fame one would expect in his native Italy where too often his insight was too close to the bone for the many fellow travellers of the PCI or too political for the various avantgardists who felt anything which dealt with the struggles of workers and peasants tainted the purity of their art.
He found considerable success in the US where many liberals adopted him because he'd split with the Party, had become pessimistic about the revolution and critical of dogma. Of course, just like the right wingers joyously proclaiming the end of socialism today, they missed the real essence Vishinsky sums up at the first Moscow Trial are condemned to relive it Stalin and the USSR's bureaucratic ruling class consolidated their grip through terror. During the late 1920s and 1930s the Bolshevik Party, the party of the Russian Revolution, was purged and destroyed. The party became its opposite -from the party of working class liberation it was transformed into the central organising mechanism of Stalinist totalitarianism.
Trotsky had been deported in 1929. His supporters and other oppositionists were herded into prison camps. Then, on 19 August 1936, the world was shocked as news spread of the first of the three major Moscow show trials. The main defendants were Zinovie and Kamenev, and, in his absence, Trotsky. Old Bolsheviks were accused of conspiracy with both the Gestapo and Trotsky. The broken "conspirators" admitted fantastic crimes including plotting the reintroduction of capitalism in the Soviet Union, and the murder of Sergei Kirov, the Leningrad Party boss, in 1934.
Andrei Vishinsky, the State Prosecutor (perversely, a former of what had led him to split with those who falsely claimed to have inherited the mantle of the revolutionaries of 1917.
gnazio Silone stands head and shoulders above most of the writers of fiction this century who were motivated by left politics and with whom he has been compared, such as Orwell and Koestler. He didn't just dabble in politics or give a nod and a wink to ideas which were fashionable.
He actually involved himself in the day to day work of fighting and organising for socialism.
A founding member of the PCI at the age of 21, he brought most of the PSI youth wing with him at the Livorno Congress in 1921. He was the first communist speaker at the PSI Congress where the Communists were to split from the Socialists marching defiantly from the congress hall singing the Internationale.
He was a member of the central committee of the PCI, in charge of underground activity and was forced into exile by the Fascists.
In 1927 he found himself in Moscow and what he saw was to lead to his eventual break with the Comintern in 1931, The Executive Committee of the Communist International condemned Trotsky's communication to the Party Political Bureau of the Soviet Communist Party on Stalin's China policy without having seen it. The Comintern was preparing the ground for the expulsion of Trotsky, Zinoviev and the show trials, purges and massacres that were to follow.
This was one of the most important moments for workers throughout the world for it was the real turning point towards Stalin's dictatorship. Silone refused to join in this condemnation. The die was cast, he had made his "gran rifiuto" (his great refusal), as he was later to call it in his play about the life of the hermit pope Celestino V, The AdvenMenshevik), denounced the accused, several of whom had been close colleagues of Lenin for many years as: "contemptible, base, vile, despicable murderous scoundrels, not tigers or lions but merely mad Fascist police dogs, humanity's dregs, the scum of the underworld, traitors and bandits." As some of the accused wept in the dock he ended the unedifying spectacle with the vengeful cry: "Shoot these mad curs, every one of them."
Kamenev and Zinoviev were shot. Trotsky was sentenced to death in his absence.
From exile in Norway, virtually gagged by the government, Trotsky attempted to reply to the Stalinist lies. It was only later, in 1937, living in the the more liberal conditions of Mexico City, when Trotsky and his American supporters could thoroughly refute the Stalinist allegations. They organised a series of hearings in front of a distinguished jury which included the American intellectual John Dewey. The jury found Trotsky "not guilty" of the Stalinist charges.
16192 ture of a Poor Christian.
Celestino is the only pope to have abdicated and the popular story is that he could not stomach Vatican corruption. As for Silone, he couldn't stomach what the revolution had become and he set out on a road which culminated in him describing himself as a "Christian without a church and socialist without a party". One of the many revolutionaries lost from the fight through the scourge of Stalinism.
Having leit the Party, isolated from the other still Party-faithful Communist exiles, and desperately ill, he decided to write a novel which would be a testimony to his hatred of Fascism and what Fascism had done to his fellow peasants in southern Italy. Up to this point his only writing experience had been as a journalist for the Party newspapers, but he thought he was dying and this gave him the drive to write his testimony.
A simple story of a peasant village destroyed by the Fascists, the emphasis is on the univeral nature of the peasants' exploitation. This time it is the Fascists, but they've always been oppressed. The village, Fontamara, also the title of the book, is in the south of Italy, but it could just as well be a village in China or South America.
The peasants have been exploited by semi-feudal landowners for as long as they can remember, but they find themselves faced by a new exploitation. The Fascists brought capitalism and with capitalism comes the worst, naked, brutal exploitation. In the end the peasants are tricked out of the very water which keeps them alive.
When Silone revised his first novel, Fontamara, for the first edition printed in Italian, he omitted one of the central lines. In the original edition the protagonist, the peasant Berardo Viola, who has been imprisoned for association with the anti-fascist Resistance, then confesses to save the lives of the real members of the Resistance. He gives a message of unity.
*Unity! No more hatred among peasants. No more hatred between peasants and workers. We need just one thing. Unity. All the rest will come of itself."
By the time of the revised edition Silone had become more concerned with the idea of the exemplary hero, the Pietro Spina of Bread and Wine and A Handful of Blackberries. He had developed a disdain for slogans. He felt the movement he had once been faithful to was reduced to sloganeering and was not fighting for socialism.
However, he didn't change the end of the novel where one of the couple of peasants who survive the Fascist massacre poses the question, what is to be done?, echoing Lenin. So it does end on an upbeat, the message is made clear: the revolutionary road is the only one.
ilone's communism was always tinged which were still common in the south of Italy. The dream of the Eternal Kingdom embodied by the likes of Gioachino da Fiore, the Celestines and the bands of wandering Christians on the fringe of the Catholic Church, preaching ideas which were soon to become regarded as dangerously subversive: their tradition had never died out.
At the time of writing Fontamara and for a few years afterwards Silone still regarded himself as a Marxist, but by 1949 when he wrote the autobiographical essay Emergency Exit, he was writing that he was still a socialist because of his sense of injustice and that he still had the strong desire for equality and fraternity that had originally brought him to Marxism.
However, he saw no common ground with the PCI of that time. This isn't at all surprising. This was the PCI which had just sold out the revolution through its class-collaborationist policies in the immediate post-war period, and was to continue doing so at every opportunity. The party that disarmed the workers and peasants who had defeated Fascism and driven the Nazis out of Italy and were willing and ready to go further and overthrow the whole rotten capitalist system.
The movement could have been seized by the PCI which had emerged as a mass movement, despite all of the years of Fascist repression. The moment was thrown away and the workers and peasants paid the price as the PCI deputies took their seats in the parliament of the new Italian republic; and they have paid the price ever since.
Is a writer Silone was obsessed with telling the truth. He reviled the Stalinist lie machine. He felt a need and a duty to bear witness to the evils of Fascism, of Stalinism and of capitalism.
He wrote in Emergency Exit of when he went to Moscow in 1927 with his comrade Togliatti, a future Party leader, Silone reports that both were shocked by what they saw, but history speaks for itself. Silone was to become an outcast and Togliatti's future was in being the central leader in building the PCI into a mass but largely impotent party. Though Silone had turned to writing in his years of exile as his form of political expression, he did briefly re-enter politics in the immediate post-war period. He sat in the Constituent Assembly as a supporter of the PSIUP, which was on the verge of splitting once more, with the right winning the upper hand. He didn't stand in the elections of 1948.
-From that point onwards he concentrated in writing, his works becoming more and more concerned with questions of faith and morality. But within all of his works was still the anger of the young man who had seen the revolution devoured by the Stalinist monster, who had seen many of his comrades fail to stand up and fight against Stalinism.
He always said that if he would have got away with it, he would have kept on rewriting the same book until he got it right. In a way he did this; all of his protagonists are versions of himself, their dilemmas his dilemmas.
In his period of political militancy he was an invaluable fighter for the class but what should have been a lifelong commitment to fighting for socialism was curtailed by his desperate need to distance himself from the lies and betrayals that became essential to the PCI and masqueraded under the name of socialism.
Scan page 13
Organiser