Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

[don't want you to believe that the system…]

Socialist Organiser no. 498, 5 September 1991 · scan pp. 8–9 · about 847 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 8 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 8

don't want you to believe that the system that produced Barbara Hutton [a famous heiress] can survive more than ten years, any more than the French monarchy could survive 1789."

So wrote the novelist Scott Fitzgerald to his daughter in 1938. In fact the system that produced vast luxury for a few and poverty for millions has survived another 53 years. It has survived not because it fixed itself up — it still produces the likes of Barbara Hutton, and terrible suffering in the slums just a few miles away from their mansions -but because no social system collapses of its own accord. A social class has to be ready, capable and mobilised to replace it with a new system; and the working class, largely because of the malign effects of Stalinism, has not yet been ready to replace capitalism.

Today in Britain the top 10% own 53% of marketable wealth, and the bottom 50% own 6%. (The latest available figures are for 1987). In the ownership of the property that brings power and influence - land and shares, as distinct from such property as a family home - the inequality is even greater. The top three per cent own about 75% of privately-owned land and shares.

Wealth not privately-owned is controlled by a small elite, tied to and much overlapping with the top 3% who own most private wealth. Ten men - bosses of the big fund management companies, highly-paid and wealthy men - control €100 billion of assets held by insurance companies and pension funds, or 25 per cent of all shares in Britain. State-owned businesses are run by people from the same class.

It the opposite pole from the A immense, concentrated wealth and power of the top three per cent is immense poverty.

The top 20% in Britain get 39% of all income. The bottom 20% get 9%. And the inequality is increasing. Real incomes for the poorest 10% of families, after housing costs, fell 7% between 1979 and 1987. Real incomes for the top 1% (after housing costs) rose 72%.

As a result many people do not families one child in ten under the age of five goes without enough to eat at least once a month because of lack of cash. goes without enough to eat at least once a month because of lack of cash. One parent in five goes hungry at least once a month. Over half the children and parents regularly had "nutritionally poor" diets. Two and a half million children live in families on income support.

There is even worse inequality in the United States, a richer country and one closer to the "ideal" of capitalism since it has had relatively little of a state welfare system imposed on its private-profit core by the labour movement.

The top 10% in the US own 65% of all marketable wealth. The top 5% get 26% of pre-tax income; the bottom 20% get 4%.

32 million people in the US are officially "poor"; of those, 45% spend 70% or more of their incomes on the basics of housing, water, lighting and heating. About 20 million do not get enough to eat; maybe 3.5 million (estimates vary wildly) are homeless. Around 35 million people have no health insurance, which means that for them national banks, demanding interest payments on their loans to Third World countries, translates into real wage cuts of 25% or 50%, increased unemployment in countries where scarcely half the workforce have regular jobs anyway, and millions of malnourished or starving children.

Why does capitalism create such inequality alongside its promises of democracy, freedom, and equality?

The free market, wrote Karl Marx, "is a very Eden of the innate rights of man"

Ironically, but only hallironically, he continued: "It is the exclusive realm of Freedom, Equality, Property and Bentham. Freedom because...buyer and seller...are free persons, who are equal before the law. Equality, because...they exchange equivalent for equivalent.

"Property, because each disposes only of what is his own. And Bentham [the philosopher Jeremy Bentham], because each looks only to his own advantage.

"Each pays heed to himself only, and no-one worries about the others. And precisely for that reason" — or so the philosophers of the free market claim - "they all work together to their mutual advantage...

All this, argued Marx, was not fices, mines...), the other those who have nothing to sell but their labour-power.

And the system reproduces those classes. For the owners it makes profits which add more wealth and power to their position as owners; for the workers it yields only wages, which do no more than enable them to scrape a living and continue as workers.

At work - that is, where the worker expends most of her or his energy, skill, and creative capacity — there is no freedom, equality or democracy. The capitalist owner is a dictator, the worker is a wagewith guardsSUPPOR

Scan page 9

MY MUM & D

----- pull-quotes -----

I wonder - is it more - or a one profitable to employ worker w a two-handed worker no guard

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 498

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →