Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

What did you do during the war Norman?

Socialist Organiser no. 498, 5 September 1991 · scan p. 5 · Andy Dixon · about 1,253 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 5 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 5

John Mcilroy takes a look at how the unions have fared after 12 years of Tory rule When Mrs. Thatcher W came to power in 1979 a central part of her strategy for restoring the profitability of British capitalism focussed on weakening the trade unions as effective defensive organisations for working class people.

Trade union coverage has been seriously weakened. The membership of TUC-affiliated unions is down from over 12 million in 1979 to just over 8 million in 1990 and such unions now represent around 38% of the labour force, far short of a full majority.

This decline has not, as many argue, been cyclical. It has been structural and that is far more serious. The unions have failed to recruit in tne new expanung dustries as ihe union 1L a indina in strongholds contracted with the old industries.

Density in the UK is still far higher than it is in the US, Japan or France, and still higher than that in Germany.

Nonetheless, its decline has been a success for Mrs Thatcher.

So, in relation to the 1960s and 70s, has been her achievement in putting on the statute book six major pieces of legislation and a host of ancillary measures which have bred cases in the courts and influenced the behaviour of trade unionists.

The employment legislation has restricted the purposes of trade unions and limited their achievements. The 1989 Dock strike provides the most recent graphic case study of how it can be utilised strategically by the employers.

We can get some measure of Thatcher's success by comparing her handling of this difficult area with Wilson's attempts to use legislation to batter the unions with In Place of Strife and Ted Heath's attempt to domesticate militancy with the 1971 Industrial Relations Act.

A further reverse for the unions was their exclusion from political influence. Even at their zenith in terms of political involvement bet- af malitinal inunluement hat. ween 1974-79 the union leaders only exercised influence on • governmental decision-making, not power. Actually, if you look at the statistics from 1979 you will find that the number of meetings and contacts with government ministers, though scaled down, remains surprisingly high - set against the popular stereotype of total exclusion from the corridors of power.

But the contacts are more and more at a junior level and what those contacts achieve compared with the '60s and '70s is trite and derisory.

The Tories have won the big set-piece confrontations: the Stockport Messenger dispute, the miners' strike, Wapping, Sealink, and the Docks dispute. Strikes have declined in the 1980s.

The unions have been reduced in size, internal differences have been amplified, the power of the TUC, albeit generally used against the unions, has diminished, the sense of movement is weaker.

But decentralisation and a new political and economic framework have not broken "If job losses and wage cuts are not resisted now it may mean a fundamental weakening of the unions. the unions - although the dangers of this are growing. A surge of initiatives intended to incorporate a weakened working class, trom greater share ownership to the flexible firm, with a core of secure, highly paid workers, and a periphery of super-exploited labour, are shown on closer examination to have had a far more limited impact than you would believe from the headlines.

Despite the reversals unions have suffered, wa outstripped • inflation 1982-89 and demonstra tremendous resilience in face of political offensive a sustained unemployment.

rang VI 0U45560 A range of etrucales -rail dispute, the dock stri the NALGO action in k government, the ambula dispute - still erupt. So! like the NALGO strike : the movement for a 35-h week, have been both off sive and successful.

The first Thatcher re sion of 1979-82 enabled TI cher to make a breakthro in utilising unemploym and legislation to weaken unions.

There are clear differer in this recession. The To have overdrawn th credibility.

However, the work class is weaker and the lef weaker. There are fi million fewer trade union today than there were 1979. We still live in shadow of important defe the iges in ted the the ike, GRAN scal ince me, our fenceshatugh lent the Ices ries leir ing ft is our lists in the ats, from the miners' strike of 1984-5 to the docks dispute of 1989.

On the other hand, many workers have seen their living standards increase in the late 1980s as wages outstripped inflation. Both sides of the coin induce caution.

The number of strikes in 1990 was the lowest since 1935. There have been no macuts. Workers have acquiesced in pay freezes at Michelin, Philips, IBM and Thomas Cook. The AEU reported loss of 90,000 jobs in manufacturing between February and May with minimal resistance.

On the other hand, wage deals running at 6-7% when 3 million are unemployed show that the employers too are exercising caution - witness the partial retreat at Rolls Royce, where management were forced to abandon their attempt to sack the entire workforce and impose a wage freeze.

The recession is driving the working class into political opposition to the Conserdelegate, Glasgow 1991, NUT Executive he highlight of the General Council's spectacularly inactive year was surely its craven support for the slaughter in the Gulf.

At the height of the nage the TUC put out the following statement:

*While we regret that sanctions were not given longer to operate, that issue is past and the positive development which must come out of the war is the enhancement of the authority of the United Nations, its Charter and SecuriKuwait.

Translated into English that means *Peace is good but war is even better". The TUC's official stance on the war was probably the most uncritical and jingoistic of any national trade union centre.

In the USA, nine national trade union leaders had the courage to put their names to an Open Letter to Bush calling on him to pull back from the brink. No such call ever came from Congress House.

In Italy and Spain general strikes, though of only token duration, were organised against the war. The General Council didn't even dare to organise a token petition around the theme of "Let sanctions work" •No attempts was ever made by the leadership to explain the issues in the conflict te the wider trade union move ment.

Nor did the General Coun cil point out the costs of thi war both to the people o Iraq and Kuwait in terms o death and destruction, and tr the people of Britain.

The war cost around E3( million a day, money tha should have been spent or housing, education, healti and other public services.

No debate, no consulta tion, no democracy wa allowed. The General Coun cil simply assumed that al trade unionists backed th war. Delegates to this year' TUC should protest at thi shameful record.

The section on the Genera Council's report dealing witl this episode, which ironicall comes directly after the sec tion on peace and disarma ment includes the following "The General Counci declared its full support fo the allied forces in pursuit o the [withdrawall of the Irac forces from Kuwait".

This section should b referred back and thos unions, like the NUT, whic did oppose the war shoul speak up at the conference t show that not everyone in th trade union movement sup ported the slaughter.

Trade unionists must say:

Lobby the TUC

----- pull-quotes -----

ty Council resolutions, following the liberation

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 498

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →