Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Three Labour Parties in Liverpool?

Socialist Organiser no. 498, 5 September 1991 · scan pp. 2–3 · Anne Field · about 1,959 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 2 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 2

The Liverpool Independent Labour Party (LILP) was formed on 18th August.

The process which led to its creation began over a year ago, when 29 members of the Labour Group on Liverpool City Council were suspended in order to allow a takeover of the group by the Harry Rimmer-led right wing.

Local Party officials and rightwingers also rigged the panel of candidates for this May's local elections. Six Labour Party wards in Liverpool chose to stand candidates bureaucratically debarred from the panel. Five of the candidates were elected to the Council.

The bulk of the sitting suspended Labour councillors allied with the newly-elected independent Labour councillors to form the Liverpool Labour Councillors (LLC) Group on the Council.

Shortly afterwards, Eric Heffer MP died. Intoxicated by the election of five independent candidates in Mood as the " Real a bouley Mahmood as the candidate in the subsequent by-election in Walton.

Many in the Liverpool Labour Party Broad Left were against standing a candidate in Walton. Their hostility increased even more as a result of the narrow-minded sectarian manner in which "Militant" ran the Mahmood campaign.

After Mahmood was heavily defeated, the hostility reached the level of open warfare, as "Militant" remained unrepentant about the fiasco even describing it as a "victory" So the non-"Militant" elements in the Broad Left and the Liverpool Labour Councillors Group decided to set up the LILl, as a way of distancing themselves from 'Militant" was not involved in the formation of the LILP. It has also been made clear to them, that their supporters will not be allowed to get involved in the LILP:

The formation of the LILP proves beyond a doubt that the Mahmood candidacy was only a sectarian adventure monopolised by "Militant", and leaves those leftwing organisations which backed Mahmood in Walton looking more stupid than ever.

The Socialist Workers Party (SWP), for example, backed Mahmood to the hilt. (So great was its devotion to the "Militant" sectarian stunt in Walton that the SWP in Liverpool recently refused to allow supporters of "Socialist Organiser" into an "Open Meeting" on the Walton by-election. Why? Because we had failed to support Lesley Mahmood and "therefore" forfeitted the right to take part.)

Instead of facing up to reality, the SWP endorsed the sectarian fantasy of "Militant" that Mahmood represented a broad labour movement left current, and ended up being cheerleaders for their stupidity.

Whilst the Labour left (now ex-Labour left was repelled by "Militant's behaviour in Walton and was pushed in the direction of creating the ILP, the SWP merely boosted the hollow pretensions of Mahmood, and then excluded from its "Open Meeting" socialists who refused to back the SWP-endorsed sectarian fantasy of "Militant"

"Militant" itself has, of course, been hit hardest of all by the formation of the LILP.

Militant" supporter and Broad Left chairperson, Tony Mulhearn, has condemned the lack of consultation which preceded the formation of the LILP, and described it as 'superfluous'. "We see no reason for this departure, given the exesterday, or the day esterday, or the day

Scan page 3

seemed to be a great seemed to be a great power in the world, and / it swer in the world, and it already controlled a third of it. ready controlled a third of it.

With its nuclear weapons, and With its nuclear weapons, and immense armies, it could threaten mense armies, it could threaten the bourgeoisie, and maybe even e bourgeoisie, and maybe even defeat it, as Stalin's armies had feat it, as Stalin's armies had defeated those of Hitler. It seemed feated those of Hitler. It seemed able to compete with capitalism le to compete with capitalism economically, too. Walled off onomically, too. Walled off behind bristling borders, it built its hind bristling borders, it built its own parallel, "socialist" , economic vn parallel, "socialist" ', economic system.

Thirty years ago, Gorbachev's Thirty years ago, Gorbachev's predecessor Nikita Khrushchev felt edecessor Nikita Khrushchev felt confident enough to announce that nfident enough to announce that the USSR was on the point of mov- : USSR was on the point of moving on to the highest stage of 3 on to the highest stage of socialism, and he shouted across the cialism, and he shouted across the airwaves to the rulers of the system waves to the rulers of the system in the West: "We shall bury you" the West: "We shall bury you"

And now it is all gone, like the And now it is all gone, like the euphoria from last night's drunken phoria from last night's drunken spree. It was always a dream, a ree. It was always a dream, a delusion, a pack of lies. Political lusion, a pack of lies. Political regimes frequently more savage gimes frequently more savage than fascism, and a brutally an fascism, and a brutally wasteful economic system, capable isteful economic system, capable only of crude industrialisation - ly of crude industrialisation -that was Stalin's "socialism"

Such "socialist" societies were in fact a great deal further from the socialism of Marx - and of Lenin - than is the bourgeois system in countries like Britain, France and Germany. Stalinist "socialism" was the stark opposite of socialism. Winis until stalinist e have not waited to say "socialism" collapsed in the Russian empire.

Socialist Organiser has said it repeatedly and outspokenly. Trotsky, over half a century ago, compared Stalin's political system unfavourably with Hitler's; and as long ago as 1935, in The Revolution Betrayed, he defined the limits of the Stalinist system's capacity for economic development.

Nor have we waited until the rulers of this foul counterfeit of socialism declared themselves bankrupt to support the fight of its victims to break its grip. We supported free trade union movements (and called on the British unions to recognise and help them, and break their links with the Stalinist policemaham Bash labi miriderer Terry Engeon Jalind pria homema Black Sectipns)

oroth ye Macerlo per Mi arino John Mcllroy bhnPeter Tatchell Members of the advisory Committee are drawn from a broad cross section of the DIATO left who are opposed to the Labour Par With n urganiser. views expressed in articles are the responsibility of the authors and not of the Advisory Editorial Board. state unions); we championed the right to self-determination of the oppressed nationalities.

Many other socialists in Britain and across the world - and the persecuted, underground, real socialists in the Stalinist "socialist" states — said the same thing as we did, and took the same stands. Such socialists were a small minority. The great movement of History towards a "post-capitalist" world seemed to be represented by the lumbering dinosaurs of Stalinism, not by the sour, ultra-critical, little mammals of Trotskyist socialism.

Most of the fashion-conscious 5p-a-dozen left "intellectuals" who now sneer at socialism, or wag their heads sadly at the inherent foolishness of socialist hopes and dreams, sneered at working-class socialism then, too, while they treated the Stalinists - whom they called socialist - with the respect due to people with big incomes and a seemingly assured future!

O and suddenness do we find nly in its completeness anything surprising in the utter collapse of Stalinist "socialism"

Yes, we had hoped and believed that from Stalinist collectivism the working class, once it had broken the power of the bureaucratic dictators, would go straight on to establish working-class democratic socialism. Ourselves knowing that Stalinism was the opposite of socialism, we underestimated the power of Stalinism to discredit our socialism too in the eyes of generations of workers who grew up under Stalinism without free speech or free information, and took its "socialist" claims at face value.

We | underestimated the great long as capitalism exists class struggle will power of attraction that liberal capitalism would have for East European and USSR workers, for whom the Western capitalism we exist to fight and overthrow truly seems to embody many of the values (liberty, prosperity) that Stalinist "socialism" had promised to bring but never did.

And of course we are grievously disappointed. Yet here too, there is nothing that is really surprising. There is even a precedent: the great commitment to systems such as the "The socialist criticism of British with which the great mass of the people of Europe emerged from ite under tascism in the 1940s. Nas been won in the ot working-class socialism East, but freedom for the working class to remake itself; and that is the greatest thing won in the world for many, many decades.

Socialism, however, is weak, both in the West and in the East, and it is — it must be said plainly -discredited by Stalinism. From the serious bourgeois press to the tabloids and down to Neil Kinnock's own little pack of witch-finders in the Labour Party, the "Labour Coordinating Committee", , they are all agreed that Stalinism was the socialist future and it did not work; socialism is dead, or at best it is just another political ad-man's meaningless plastic word.

Socialism is weak; but socialism is not dead. It will not die, because capitalism has not died. Now that most of the Stalinist dinosaurs are gone, socialism will revive, perhaps rapidly.

It will revive because it is rooted in the realities of working-class life under capitalism. It will revive because there is still a powerful pre-Stalinist and anti-Stalinist socialist tradition in existence, despite all the efforts over decades of Stalinists and fascists and liberalbourgeois "repressive tolerance" to wipe it out. It will revive because the socialist criticism of capitalism is true and just and unanswerable except by lies, misrepresentation, and repression.

et the great scientist Albert Einstein explain the socialist #case against the liberal capitalist system. The words and the approach to the subject are his own, the ideas are the common coin of Marxist socialism.

"We see before us a huge community of producers, the members of which are unceasingly striving to deprive each other of the fruits of their collective labour - not by force, but on the whole in faithful compliance with legally established rules. In this respect, it is important to realise that the means of production - that is to say, the entire productive capacity that is needed for producing consumer goods as well as additional capital goods - may final premale propery or int legally be, and for the most part dividuals.

The owner the Socialist Organiser No. 498 page 3 duction is in a position to purchase the labour power of the worker. By using the means of production, the worker produces new goods which become the property of the capitalist. The essential point about this process is the relation between what the worker produces and what he is paid, both measured in terms of real value.

Insofar as the labour contract is 'free' , what the worker receives is determined not by the value of the goods he produces, but by his minimum needs and by the capitalists' requirements for labour power in relation to the number of workers competing for jobs. It is important to understand that even in theory the payment of the worker is not determined by the value of his product.

Private capital tends to become concentrated in few hands, partly because of competition among the Turn to page 4 "The sena pation tone wan Class: 2a0м em human beings without distinction of Seciate Orgeniser PO Box 823, London SE15 4NA Newsdesk: 071 639 7965 Lodest deleirol deports: Monday after John CUM Published by WL Publications Ltd, 300-80 • Londo Printed by Tridant Press, Edenbridge Registered as a newspaper at the Post Office sari rent views of Socialist Organiser and are in a perspini ca stated

----- pull-quotes -----

Yoefore, "socialism" before, "socialism'

Advisory Editonal Board

capitalism is and just and unanswerable.

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 498

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →