[Led their own opposition in IS, the Left…]
Socialist Organiser1991 1991-08-29Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 14 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 14
Led their own opposition in IS, the Left Faction, which fought the Cliff leadership on and off for a period of four years. It was essentially a group founded under the influence of Workers' Fight, but retaining many of IS's ideas; it was also, at its core, as much a group of personal friends — going back to college or even school days — as a political formation.
In 1975 the "Left Faction" too, was expelled. After a period of collaboration on a new paper, Workers' Action, with a number of people now associated with Socialist Organiser, and common membership in the InternationalCommunist League, Dave Steve McSweeney (sixth).
Hughes and some three dozen others went on to found the organisation and paper Workers Power. There can be no doubting Dave's considerable organisational abilities and political drive in helping sustain Workers Power since its founding in September 1976WP, good or bad, is to a considerable extent Dave's legacy to the socialist movement. Dave was, and WP remains, a strong opponent of Socialist Organiser. WP holds to a disastrous analysis of Eastern Europe, saying that the old regimes were "deformed workers' states" , and WP supporters went so far as to justify the bludgeoning of democracy demonstrators in Bucharest. However, there are many groups on the left far worse than WP, It is doubly sad that at this time Workers Power should be denied Dave's knowledge and his enthusiasm for links with the new trade union movement in the Soviet Union. The historic events now taking place there must be a time for a major reassessment for WP. That will be a task far harder to do without Dave Hughes.
We send our deepest sympathy to Dave's comrades and friends.
A memorial meeting for Dave Hughes will be held on 15 September, from 3pm at Conway Hall, Red Lion Square, London.
In reply to Tony Bruce (SO 494), I should point out that my review of 1871 had to be shortened by the editor and so a few sentences were left out.
To summarise some
points:
(1) The "slow pace" provides dramatic contrast to the violent events at the end lulling viewers (who will not all be dedicated revolutionaries) into openness to watch the film, and thus a possibility of being persuaded to support the Commune.
On first seeing 1871 I felt uneasy that we see only plush rooms, and no starving people or slum garrets, but in the context of how the film works, we see a facade of supposed normality overthrown as would hap pen in any revolution.
(2) As Tony Bruce points out, the film focuses on a theatre company, but also is important that the film presents itself as a staged spectacle in a Brechtian sense, which encourages a certain distancing in the viewer, allowing rational thought as well as emotional identification.
The theatre setting also is a metaphor for the limitations of politicised art; one of the reactionary characters states that "your weapons belong to the theatre! Ours are real!"
(3) I agree that more time could have been devoted to introducing the characters and providing some background information, at least to the 1867 war in Mexico.
(4) Tony describes 1871 as "confused, deliberately obscure", which is the way Stalinist and bourgeois critics deride anything that doesn't conform to "socialist realism" or the (less obviously manipulative Hollywood conventions.
As a fellow SO reader, I'm sure that Tony doesn't support these positions and probably just disagrees with me over whether the film works.
(5) Tony refers to the film's "non-naturalistic style" (which is not something separate from its political and emotional con tent). Alain Robbe-Grillet among others has shown that the conventions in cinema and literature are determined by conditioning. rather than being truly realistic. MeMullen's film concerns events from 1867 to 1871, but no-one would expect the film to go on for four years.
I would side with such diverse critics as Adorno, Benjamin, Breton and Schnebel in arguing for art that tries to communicate possibilities of emancipatios (this attempt being of necessity in opposition to dominant conventions, which of course often gives rise to communication problems).
1 agree with Tony that Zina is a better film, and that people should read Marx on the Commune.
Steven I South Lon