Anglo-Catholics in British Trotskyism
Socialist Organiser1991 1991-08-29Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 14 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 14
Fr Leech in 1973- Wellington Fortunately some of the Salop t is a pity that since Al Richardson wished to query my comment on Sam Bornstein's account of the origins of the Balham Group he did not so do when Reg Groves and Sam Bornstein were alive.
Even if he did not see my earlier published accounts, he is presumably aware that I had an exchange of letters with Sammy, referring him back to Reg.
I assume that copies of that correspondence survive in Socialist Platform files.
No one doubted that the Groser-Purkis-Groves group broke with the Catholic Crusade. If Richardson will refer back to Groves' account of the decision to rejoin the CPGB (which was published in IS magazine in the 1970s) he will find that, even though reference to the Crusade was cut by the IS editors, that Reg still clearly states that the decision was made in Fr. Grosner's sitting room, and that their host was involved.
The grouping met as one of the Chapters of the Crusade, and opted out. The grounds for that break were that the Crusade had grown too critical of the Soviet Union, and was no longer sufficiently oriented to the CP.
They rejoined the CP, though at first all retained criticisms of the party. Subsequently John Grosner and the rest split. I do not know whether or when he left the CP, but certainly he was not to be part of the Balham Group. Since they had broken with Noel (temporarily, as it happened) before reentering the CP obviously they would not have held meetings at Thaxted, but until the break with Grosner they did use his house.
Given that Fr. Grosner's views were quoted in the CP leadership's answers to Purkis and Groves, Richardson's argument that the absence of any reference to Purkis's and Groves's religion proves something, is hardly conclusive.
Stuart Purkis edited the Socialist Christian (journal of the Socialist Christian League) from the time of the war, until the majority of the SCL voted to wind up to enter the new Christian Socialist Movement in 1960. (Four votes were cast against this liquidation, Reg, Stuart (editor), Fr. Gresham Kirkby (chair) and mine.)
Though I had subscribed from the early '50s I did not attend a meeting until the 1959 AGM. It was there that I met Reg and Stuart; and it was at a tea-break there that I asked whether Trotsky had known they were spikes (Anglo-Catholics). They were both very emphatic that of course" they had mentioned this in their first exchange of letters with Trotsky, though there had been no occasion for it to be mentioned subsequently.
My connection with Reg Groves didn't cease with the end of the SCL (Stuart didn't approve of non-violent Direct Action - 20 years earlier Desmond O'Neill Belshawe had been expelled from the Crusade for advocating it) and so he disapproved of my Direct Action Committee and of Committee of 100 role.
Reg was on the subscribing list for Logos which I edited in the late '60s and early '70s; he published a reprint of the Catholic Crusade's Manifesto in 1969, and I helped sell this. He and I were amongst the early members of Jubilee (named after the Year of Jubilee in Deuteronomy), founded by editors of Revolutionary History have a more definite regard for historical accuracy than Al Richardson.
P.S. One extra circumstantial note — and if Reg's files were as complete, and have been examined as carefully, as Richardson suggests, it can hardly be new to him.
In 1975 or '6, Jubilee published a three-foolscappage account by me of the anglo-catholic role in the origins of British Trotskyism. Ken Leech let me know a little after that Reg was not completely happy with it, but did not say why; so I wrote Reg (I think, but can't be certain, with a copy to Ken) a fairly lengthy letter elaborating my account and the reasons for saying those things which I thought might be debatable:
I didn't hear at tirst, so wrote again, and then heard from Reg to say that there was nothing in my account with which he disagreed, but he was not convinced of the wisdom of publishing it.
Laurens Otter