Not guilty! -12823B8 1295220 BIŞROBER Stalinism was the opposite of Bolshevism
Socialist Organiser1991 1991-08-29Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 6 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 6
BUKHARIN SVERDLOV STALIN ZINOVIEV KAMENEV TROTSKY Shot Dead Survivor Shot Shot In Exile TAI URITSK Y KRESTINSK Y SMILGA NOGIN ? Dead Shot Shot Dead SHOMYAN BERZIN MURANOV ARTEM STASSOVA MILIUTIN Dead Disappeared Dead Disappeared 3y John O'Mahony what is happening the HUSSR _ now symbolised in one scene in a Moscow street last weekend.
A group of monarchists stood by, singing the Tsarist national anthem, as the statue of Jacob Sverdlov, the Bolshevik who signed the death warrant for the murdering ex-Tsar Nicholas Il, was pulled Socialists who respect Lenin and Sverdlov, and who believe that the Russian Revolution of 1917 was one of the great liberating moments in humanity's history, that men like Sverdlov were heroes of human liberation, will nevertheless cheer the pulling down of their statues in cities all across the USSR, And it will be a good day for Lenin's cause when they burn or bury the great iconoclast's poor mummy, and shut his mausoleum forever.
Those : statues, like Lenin's mummy, were the icons of the bureaucratic ruling class. The images of socialists were used as the semi-religious monuments of the anti-socialist bureaucracy.
The socialists honoured in those statues died before the Stalinist counter-revolution, and could safely be used to help sustain the Stalinist regime's lying socialist pretences.
Jacob Sverdlov, who was the organiser of the revolutionary Bolshevik party, its general secretary before that title existed, died of typhoid in 1919. Lenin died in January 1924, having made a heroic attempt from his deathbed to get rid of Stalin. Even Felix Dzerzhinsky — the tabloids' "Iron Felix" — the founder of the police who organised the Red Terror during the civil war, was not a Stalinist.
He died in 1926. He was an ally of Stalin in the faction struggles of that time, and Trotsky wrote that had he lived he would not have hesitated to "shed the Opposition's blood" . Nevertheless he was not one of those who set up the Stalinist totalitarian regime at the end of the 1920s.
Is Mikhail Gorl sachev A communist Party of the Communist Party of the Soviet Union, and calls party to dissolve, the bourgeoisie celebrates the of communism.
Neal Ascherson in the Independent on Sunday (25 August) typically talks of the current events being the "end of more than 73 years of Bolshevik rule" - seeing Bolshevism and Stalinism as the same thing.
For hundreds of millions of workers around the world, "Bolshevik rule" is what has existed in the USSR for all the last 70-odd years. For them, the words communism and Bolshevism have become synonymous with Stalinism and totalitarianism.
In the USSR and Eastern Europe, great revolutionary leaders were turned into icons to be worshipped and revered - but no-one was allowed to study their ideas independently. The icons are now being dismantled, many years after the real ideas of the real people were SVERDLOV Dead URITSK Y KRESTINSK Dead Shot SHOM YAN BERZIN Dead It is not Lenin and Sverdlov and Dzerzhinsky who are coming down, but the filthy images of the Stalinist hut tha filthy imarac of tha Stalinict regime. A socialist system would not have had such images in the first place. Lenin was dead before they renamed Leningrad for him; his widow Krupskaya was against the worship of the mummy in the mausoleum.
t is understandable that the Soviet peoples should hate those icons; understandable, now, that they do not want to bother with the question of whether or not the system they hate was really the distorted and corrupted.
One-party rule, state-run trade unions, purges and labour camps; repression of nations and national rights; crushing of independent workers' groups and movements; oppression of lesbians and gays, Jews and women; incredible privileges for a minority, and bread queues for the majority — those are some of the hallmarks of "communism" as millions of workers the world over have come to know it.
The people of a third of the globe lived under that so-called "communism" . The system they experienced was a far cry from the communism fought for by Karl Marx and Frederick Engels and by Lenin, Trotsky and Luxemburg.
here has been only one successful workers' revolution in history, though there have been many abortive attempts.
There is not now, nor has there ever been, any working example ot a communist society. The bourgeoisie and their agents said that the regimes in countries like the USSR were "communist" because that suited them - it conveyed the idea that workers' revolution could only end in disaster — and the dictators backed them up. General Sta For the neo-bourgeois intellectuals, as for the gloating press in the West, it is a game of cynical propagandist pretence that the Stalinist system they are pulling down is identical with the 1917 Revolution. There is one aspect of the Stalinist edifice they have every intention of preserving: its lying self-identification with socialism and the October Revolution now serves their interests as it once served Stalin's.
Yet it is a transparent lie, this Leon Trotsky, one of the foremost leaders of the 1917 Revolution, spent the last years of his life in exile in Mexico, hounded, and eventually to be murdered, by Stalin's agents. He made great attempts not only to record the events of the revolution and its subsequent degeneration, but also to explain scientifically why it happened the way it did.
In his pamphlet Stalinism and Bolshevism (1937), Trotsky worked through the arguments popular at that time, and pretty much unchanged today, that Bolshevism inevitably led to Stalinism. He argued that "to represent the process of degeneration of the Soviet state as the evolution of pure Bolshevism is to ignore social reality in the name of one of its elements".
The writers of bourgeois history often mention the raging civil war, the mass starvation, the economic crisis which forced half the urban population to flee to the countryside, and even the invasions by imperialist armies trying to defeat the Red Army.
Some go as far as quoting Lenin, stating categorically that there could not be socialism in one country. But they then discard all that as irrelevant. The point they want to DZERZHINSKY BUBNOV Dead Disappeared STASSOVA MILIUTIN Missing Missing Disappeared identification of Stalinism.
The Russian Revolution proclaimed an end to exploitation: the Stalinist system that has existed for over 60 years was one of the most brutally exploitative systems anywhere in the world.
The October Revolution proclaimed and fostered national liberation, writing the right of nations to leave the state at will into the constitution. Stalinism was a system deservedly called a prison house of nations. Those nations are now taking the chance to organise a mass prison-break, from Armenia drive home - and they are doing it now with renewed vigour - is that Bolshevism, that is, a democratic centralist party dedicated to revolution, is inextricably linked to Stalinism.
They separate off the social reality as if it had no bearing on the day-to-day decisions our Bolshevik comrades had to make.
It is true that the Stalinist bureaucracy, on its way to the supreme power which it finally got by crushing and massacring the revolutionary Bolshevik party, gained advantage from measures taken in desperate straits by the Bolsheviks. But, for example, deciding to ban other parties and factions within the governing party — which the Bolsheviks did in early 1921 — was a temporary emergency measure. It was not an iron law of "democratic centralism" any more than banning strikes and conscripting youth to fight wars are an iron law of bourgeois democracy. They are measures employed in times of As Trotsky puts it: "As far as the prohibition of other soviet parties is concerned, it did not flow from any 'theory' of Bolshevism, but was a war measure of defence of the dictatorship [i.e. the workers' rule] in a the Ukraine to Lithuania.
The October Revolution organised the rule of the working class: Stalinism has been a savage decades-long rule by a privileged new exploiting class over the workers, The October Revolution was a revolution of socialist internationalists, seeing themselves as the first wave of an international movement. For over 50 years the Stalinist system has been a system of savage Russian chauvinism.
And it is a matter of history that almost all those who led the revolution, and survived more than a few years after it, were massacred by the Stalinists. Only a smattering of people who had been in the Bolshevik Party at the time of the Revolution survived the Stalinist purges of the 1930s.
et they tell us that the Stalinist system and the Bolshevik revolution on whose grave Stalin built are one and the same thing.
The victim is also the murderer; Abel is Cain: the fascistic regime of Stalin, keeping the workers down in the interests of the new bureaucratic exploiters, is the same as the workers' regime which suppressed the exploiters and took the power to exploit away from them!
The truth is encapsulated in that scene of the Tsarists singing their song as they hauled Sverdlov's statue down. Where were the political offspring of Sverdlov and Lenin? Extinguished by the bureaucratic dictators, from Stalin to Brezhnev and afterwards purged, repressed, and bound hand and foot far more than the neomonarchists have been.
In any other field of history or science, someone who asserted the identity of such opposites would be classified as either clinically schizoid or dominated by ideology. The idea that Stalinism and Bolshevism are identical is the ideology of the anti-socialist bourgeoisie (including the Kinnockite "socialists" who pant for a chance to run the capitalist system, and find it useful to be able to assert that if you try to over throw the bourgeoisie then you will wind up with Stalinism).
This is their day. Let them have it. The removal of Lenin and Sverdlov from the position of icons TOH those who overthrew the workers' state they set up in 1917 is the beginning of the process of allowing the real Lenin and Sverdlov to return where they belong - to those who have been the victims of Stalinism for so long and who are still, by the political confusion it engenders in them, its victims.
backward and devastated country, surrounded by enemies on all sides".
He goes on: "For the Bolsheviks it was clear... that this measure... signalised tremendous danger"
The opposition parties were, however, involved (to varying degrees) in civil war against the workers' government. The alternative was to "ban" the entire workers' state, that is, to drown it in the blood of the workers at the hands of •ithe counter-revolutionaries.
The recent events in East T ern Europe and the USSR have, as the papers say, finally laid to rest a "colossus", a "dictatorship"
But what is dying is not communism, but Stalinism, a distinct system of tyranny.
Trotsky truly wrote: "It is absolutely indisputable that the domination of a single party served as the juridical point of departure for the Stalinist totalitarian system. But the reason for this development lies neither in Bolshevism nor in the prohibition of other parties as a temporary measure, but in the number of defeats of the proletariat in Europe and Asia"
Scan page 7
bureaucracy which has sent uncounted Bolshevik-led r 2 millions untimely to theirs. collapse of thi Boris Ka jarlitsky, leade the new Socialist Party in Moscow, explains how sees the Moscow coup, the tasks of the left in Russia now.
you could say that the coup Y in faa treme was moe than In fact there was more than one coup. Or: there was a very complex coup. Or: what was known as the military junta was only a small part of the coup.
On the surface it would appear that the plotters acted in a very strange way. They did not arrest Yeltsin. They did not take over the buildings of the Russian government or the Moscow Soviet. They did not cut off their phones or electricity or the telecommunications of the Russian government. They did not try to arrest any of the other major figures of the Russian government. In fact, they did nothing. More than that, they even disarmed the soldiers which moved into Moscow. Not only did the soldiers have no ammunition, but even the officers had had their pistols unloaded.
This contradicts normal army procedures!
All these strange procedures could not be explained by the incompetence of the people who made the coup. For example, Kryuchkov is the leader of the KGB - well known for organising coups all over the world.
Kryuchkov himself was connected to the Polish coup of 1981, which from a technical point of view was well-executed.
The only explanation seems to be that the junta expected the Yeltsin administration to be their partners or potential allies - or at least to be ready for some compromise for co-management of the country. Otherwise, what they did is incomprehensible.
Moreover, the junta leaders could not have been fooled by illusions in this possibility. They must From page nano decrees against the CP for which it had great popular support - and for which its action drummed up more — without any legal or constitutional right to do so. Gorbachev, released from captivity, found himself Yeltsin's political captive. Real power in the USSR had already shifted to the elected representatives of the biggest republic, the Russian Parliament and Yeltsin.
Those elected structures formed a dual power structure under the old "Soviet" skin, ready to slough it off. With the disintegration of the Soviet Union and the breaking-away of the non-Kussian republics, the "USSR" represented by Gorbachev had anyway grown shadowy and insubstantial.
The failed coup was based essentially on the old weakened, hollowed-out, "all-Union" structures; the resistance on the new ones, in the first place the Russian parliament and its leaders.
With the failure of the coup there was a decisive shift to the new structures, an accelerated enfeeblement of the old; then the radicals attacked the vitals of the old system, backed by a burgeoning popular movement angered at the coup.
The CP crumbled with astonishing speed: it slunk into the grave, this 2302 Moscow youth on the barricades have had some communication with the Russian government which convinced I them that the Russian government was more or less capable of making a deal with them sooner or later.
I think that the Russian government just provoked them. The Russian government decided that they could get more without any compromise. They turned the coup around to make the coup's organisers be the main victims.
While the plotters were pretending to make a coup, without making a real coup. without establishing real control over the administration, the Russian government was doing exactly the opposite. It was establishing real control over all spheres of administration. It was taking over or destroying the functions of central government.
On the late afternoon of Monday 19th August the coup leaders realised that they had been cheated. Then they tried to make the coup serious — into a real coup d'état. Then they brought in the real troops. Armed troops.
Just today (27th August) we learned only on the afternoon of 20th August were the Moscow police given orders to crack down and arrest people.
After losing about 10 hours they realised they had to act seriously or be wiped out. People like Kryuchkov and Pugo tried to act seriously while Yanayev and proTret of the coup and what it he unbelievably inept characfailure led to, has made people of widely different polities speculate that it not a real coup attempt at all, but a putup job, designed to achieved what it has achieved - the destruction of the CPSU and a radical acceleration of the reform movement. There are other explanations.
There is a striking parallel in the history of the 1917 Revolution. There the socialist workers' councils, with increasing Bolshevik influence, vied for power with a Provisional Government, trying to straddle the left and right poles in politics.
The Government had little authority. Things were falling apart. General Kornilov tried to organise a coup, to destroy the democratic working-class movements. Provisional Government leader Kerensky vacillated; some accused him of collusion with Kornilov, but he opposed the coup.
The Bolsheviks organised the decisive opposition to Kornilov. They "defended" Kerensky, as Lenin was to put it later, "as the rope supports the hanged man", The Kornilov revolt melted away almost as surprisingly as the recent coup- Trotsky, who organised the bably Pavlov were in a state of shock and despair.
The people from the repressive apparatus - like Kryuchkov tried to get tough.
This is confirmed by Kravchenko's - the TV chief - recent interview. He said that he was invited to come to a plotters' meeting on Tuesday 20th August where Yanayev was utterly hysterical. Yanayev was demanding that Yeltsin be told that the Russian parliament buildings would not be stormed. But Kryuchkov replied that if it had already been announced that they were outlaws - then they had to do it.
They were only reacting to what Yeltsin did. This was not their original plan.
By the time they really tried to act seriously, Yeltsin was already firmly in control of everything, including most of the army. They were then sabotaged by their own structures.
During the first stages of the coup they had discouraged the military from taking any action.
So, late on 20th August, Yeltsin was already capable of arresting them. It seems that Yeltsin was waiting for someone to die. He was waiting for something inhuman to happen to blame the plotters for. He wanted to ride a tide of moral indignation. My guess at Yeltsin's thinking is that an atrocity could then be used as a further reason to ban the Communist Party and to close its newspapers. I do not know Bolshevik-led resistance, explained the collapse of the coup from the utter decay, demoralisation, and disarray of the old order.
Astonishing as is the coup-makers' failure to arrest Yeltsin, and even if we assume that there were all sorts of murky intrigues and double-crosses in the background, the fundamental explanation for the teebleness of the coup is probably the same explanation as for Kornilov: the decay, disarray, and demoralisation of the old order.
It is a different order of things to organise a coup in Moscow amidst great difficulties than to organise a military takeover in Warsaw in 1981, backed by the still-solid Soviet military machine.
During the hours when it seemed that the coup had been successful, the West was shaken but mostly reconciled to the coup.
The Financial Times put it like this: "Business leaders... suggested that — in business terms at least - an authoritarian economy was preferable to an anarchic one, and some executives believe Mr Gorbachev's removal might lead to a clarification of recent uncertainties.
'Economic progress can still be made in the shadow of authoritarian rule. China is the prime example of this', said one executive".
In the SO broadsheet how else to explain Yeltsin's lack of activity from the afternoon of Tuesday 20th August.
On the 21st of August, after the three people had been killed near the Moscow White House on the Tuesday night, the plotters were quickly wiped out.
It is interesting to note that, the plotters ran to Gorbachev for support, rather than to Cuba or North Korea. They expected Gorbachev to protect them.
This has led so-called democratic newspapers to accuse Gorbachev of being more involved than he pretends.
But the problem is that if Gorbachev was even partially involved, this underlines the connection of the coup with Yeltsin.
Yeltsin was the one to gain. The Yeltsin coup was covered by the junta coup.!
The result is that the Communist Party is dissolved. The Communist Party is banned. There is no major opposition party left in Russia. This is not anything like democracy.
Yeltsin has announced the triumph of democracy. But we have the opposite. We have the end of the democratic intermezzo. We have the transition from Communist dictatorship - which degenerated into democracy! - into an anti-Communist dictatorship.
This anti-Communist dictatorship is more dynamic and more capable of suppressing the people.
It is a tragic situation.
put out last week (most of staff were, like Gorbachev, we said this:
*The choice in the USSR now is either what the putschists want, Chinese-style authoritarianism and a growing sphere for market economics, or else a radical popular revolution which destroys the power of the old Gorbachev's course — democratic reform from above by an enlightened despot — has failed: now it is either reaction or revolution. If the working class and others rally now round Yeltsin and his similars, it will be a revolution having more in common with the French Revolution of 1789 than the working-class Russian Revolution of 1917. Yeltsin wants to clear the way for capitalism: but for now he has chosen the side of democracy.
A mass popular revolution to break the old state and win political and civil liberty - including the right to organise the free trade unions and working-class political parties now outlawed by the putschists — would be an immense step forward from Stalinism. In the course of such a revolution, workers who now follow Yeltsin, and who are not against the capitalist market, which they see as going with the comparative liberty and prosperity of the West, will find their political feet and begin to gain a class awareness of the need for socialism. That happened in very different social and industrial conditions during the • care feb se manine asialone This Now we have to explain the spate of suicides in Moscow in the wake of the coup.
Pugo is reported to have shot himselt, then crossed the room and placed his pistol on a table, returned to the place he shot himself (without losing a drop of blood) and then died.
The official explanation is that he was shot by his wife who then shot herself.
But then this story has the same flaw: she was lying next to him. This is all impossible!
Pugo was the most active man in the junta. A logical explanation is that he was killed by someone who did not want him to reveal the true facts behind his action.
His house was surrounded by people from the Russian KGB. There are no reports of anyone entering the house.
Was Yeltsin personally coordinating all this? It is not clear. It is possible that Yeltsin was being used himselt, by people around him.
Yeltsin is easy to manipulate — for people who are professionals at this type of thing.
The proofs of what I say will be hard to come by unless people begin to speak. And instead of speaking, they die. One by one.
Finally, there has been a vacuum created by the collapse of the Communist Party. The government is using this vacuum to construct what is already being called an "inverted one-party state"
On the other hand, the left could begin to fill the vacuum.
The position of the Socialist Party is much stronger. There is now a big discussion which is turning into practical action about the formation of a party of labour.
We do not want a party modelled on the one in Britain. The union connection should be through the participation of union activists in such a party and through, perhaps, union financing for such a party. Not through direct union affiliation.
The organising committee is in the process of being formed together with other forces. Details will be clearer in a few days time.
Great French Revolution.
If the neo-Stalinist, quasi-fascist backlash now triggers a deep popular revolution, it may not end quite as Yeltsin and the Russian neo-bourgeoisie want.
Socialists in Britain must give their unqualified support to the resistance to the neo-Stalinist dictatorship. Long live the Russian Revolution!"
There has not yet been that deep popular revolution. Far from it. Much of the state apparatus remains intact, the army high in prestige. The economy of the USSR spirals downwards daily into hyper-inflation and probable famine.
Yeltsin will now have to take responsibility. He will not work miracles.
The army has, by its shotgun divorce from the CP, been rendered a more credible contender for the Third World army role of providing a military scaffolding when the bourgeoisie is weak and the society in chronic crisis.
Last week's failed coup and the radical backlash it licensed tumbled the system Stalin built into history's dustbin. It may also have decided what kind of authoritarianism - one controlled by the vacillating Gorbachevite apparatus-men or one controlled by the radicals — will be imposed in the period ahead.
The headline of our broadsheet last week remains true: Only revolution -that is, the destruction of the state apparatus, including the army = can secure liberty.
Scan page 8
Eyewitness repor Anatoly Voronov, Moscow Socialist Party "The coup has pla coup ha role by leading role by leading to the old structures Party and the high bureaucracy"
Barricades in Moscow Victory march on Thursday August 22
----- pull-quotes -----
It is not Lenin and Sverdlov and continuity of what Sverdlov and identification of Bolshevism and Dzerzhinsky who are coming down, Lenin and Dzerzhinsky stood for. Stalinism.