Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

The Gorbachev years

Socialist Organiser no. 497, 29 August 1991 · scan pp. 4–6 · about 2,006 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 4 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 4

orbachey became CP Nagorno Karabakh demands Russian Parliament elects March 1985. His firs ers to rule "plesnost" times. In July, a miners' strike lapse: food rationing introduced Gorbachey transferred from central to Rus promises Europe. *9 plus 1" Union Treaty the Armenian-populated area of dependence, and the CP aban- republics.

General General Secretary transfer from rule by AzerbaiMOVESHUT TENNIS AHM vatives Ligachev and Gromyko, and KGB boss Chebrikov. and, in the economy, an ad- 1989: The last Soviet troops mainedrei vendid engined SCOT SOMACH TRITION.

Line first genuine parlamentar.

1986: Gorbachey proclaims elections since revolutionary "perestroika" economic — DeleS meaning in the irst place having state factories on to political demanos, marks keep their profits (or go bust if the beginning of a new workers mey nave Tosses ame anowe At the end of the year withdraw from Afghanistan. popular revolutions clear away though the party will still vet 1990: January sends troops into Azerbaijan; nassacre in Baku. March Lathuania declares dons its Meading role! Mar Yeltsin president. September isers produce the March, reformers poll well in bachey shies away from it, but Yeltsin adopts it.

The economy begins to col across the USSR, starting on in Moscow, Leningrad, and many other areas. ad March Mar n in Lithuania and ovement and new independent a new trade union WEYC DE BEHICE strikes. GorDecner makes a cear wiln erein o ena me stikes mines ian Federation control. New drafted, proposing to transfer most powers and industrial assers trom the centre to tit caricatures of those ideas as his own ideological self-justifications.

The negative impact of bourgeois market capitalism and the exploitation of workers by private capitalists allied to the state helped shape the anti-capitalist labour movements in Europe and pre-1917 Russia, pushing workers struggling against the system towards collectivism, and allowing the socialists to be the most conscious element of the class, rendering the gut reactions of workers in struggle coherent and scientific.

All that is turned inside out and upside down in the crazy mirror-image society created by Stalinism.

Whereas in the 1890s the first great wave of mass working-class strikes could link up with the Marxists and the young Russian working class began the work of hammering out an independent working-class programme and an organisation to fight for it, now the very opposite course is almost mechanically imposed. The instinctive reflex reaction against totalitarian collectivism pushes the proletariat not towards its own necessary programme, the alternative to all exploitation, capitalist or bureaucratic, but organically

Scan page 5

to restore capitalism HINA Defiant demonstration On immediate class struggles - both the sectional economic struggles and the political struggles to win, consolidate and defend democracy, in which the socialists should take the lead, competing with the Yeltsins -and out of the discussion of what went wrong with Stalinism.

here is on another level, too, a lawfulness about the bourgeois character of the revolution. In terms of human liberty - freedom of utterance, organisation, sexuality, habeas corpus, the rule of law - the Stalinist world until recently had fallen backwards in history hundreds of years, further back even than some of the notoriously brutal Third World authoritarian regimes.

It was as if all the advances since the Middle Ages associated with the rise and spread of bourgeois civilisation had never happened: except that they existed and flourished in Europe and the US and other places, side by side with but beyond the borders of the Russian Empire. Inevitably this system acts as a great magnet and beacon for the lost tribes of the Stalinist world. They have looked across the borders - especially the thinking intelligentsia in the Stalinist states — at the advanced bourgeois world as from across hundreds of years of historical time.

No independent working-class outlook was formed, for all the reasons above and because of repression, but also because Stalinism was above all characterised by a propensity to disguise itself in forms taken from advanced bourgeois society. Thus you had "unions" that were police-state unions, anti-unions; empty political parties; and you had the old socialist ideas of self-organising democratic collectivism transmuted into ideological camouflage for the bureaucraticcollectivist ruling-class exploitation.

Vast difficulties were thus placed in the way of the proletariat developing its own outlook; those difficulties still operate now, after the era of savage police-state repression has passed.

And yet the only way that the Acold from Stalinist totalitarian collectivism to democratic working-class socialist collectivism could be a direct one, eliminating the capitalist stage now at hand, would be for the working class to be able to formulate its own clear programme and organise itself. For the totalitarian state economy to be replaced by a working-class, democratically-planned socialist economy and not by chaos, as now, the working class would have to take central directing control of the economy. Everything has militated against the working class being prepared to do that.

Stalinism in its long, but until recently still savage, stagnation and decay, pinned the working class under its own dead weight. To change the image: it was not working-class socialism that could gestate within the womb of the Stalinist society. At the same time, a bourgeoisified layer of the bureaucracy, and a sizeable "middle class" , developed. The only way the system could open up was when its own central rulers acted to paralyse it at the centre.

ahe Bolsheviks in 1917 knew that the Russian workers' state could not escape from world capitalism and build socialism. They could only act as a pioneer for the West European workers who would overthrow advanced capitalism.

Neither did it prove possible for the Stalinist system - which also counterposed itself to the bourgeoisie and proposed to find its own way to the future, competing with advanced world capitalism - to supplant Western capitalism starting on the basis of the backward Russian empire: they were too poor for the competition; and the bureaucratic ruling class never succeeded in establishing an articulated, coherent, selfregulating economic system.

Everything including the empire and the pretensions to world power status rested on the grotesquely inflated military machine, which devoured maybe a third of the gross product of the empire! Collapse was inevitable.

As I have argued above, only a sharp degree of independent class consciousness would make independent working-class politics possible, a sharper degree of historical and theoretical awareness than was necessary to make independent working-class politics possible in 1917. Inevitably, since independent working-class politics in the Stalinist state require the working class to go against the grain of its own repulsion from the system of its immediate oppressors and exploiters, vastly greater masses of workers would have to consciously understand and hold to a broad historical perspective than held the socialist perspective of the 1917 Bolsheviks.

Its existence in misery and oppression, without free speech or free organisation or honest information, under the control of the bungling, ignorant, hierarchically-organised, medieval-minded bureaucracy, was the worst possible conditions for the working class to achieve that, or for the socialists even to prepare the ground for it. The reviving socialist movement in the USSR is at an even more rudimentary stage than it was 100 years ago.

Everything seemed organised by some malign spirit of History to push the working class behind a bourgeois revolution in the Stalinist states.

nd not only behind it: one of the most remarkable events of history is the fact that the Polish nation came after 1980 to re-form itself around the labour movement, and still it was a bourgeois anti-Stalinist revolution that issued from the ultimate victory.

And yet what happened in Poland corresponded more thari any revolution since the Russian Revolution of 1917 to Trotsky's formula of the permanent revolution - "the reconstruction of the nation under the leadership of the proletariat"

The working class took the lead, with a great revolutionary strike and the creation in 1980 of the Gdansk soviet, rallying all the people around it against the autocracy and against foreign domination — and produced a bourgeois revolution. The facts above, and the "consciousness of priests" and pro-capitalist intellectuals, influencing Solidarnosc in the dog days of its 1980s outlawry, explain that result.

At the core of this experience is the ideological defeat of the working class and its consequent political enslavement to alien forces, the terrible havoic wreaked by Stalinism and by its ideological forgeries and palimpsests on the old working-class socialist ideas and programme. It is all, in its own way, a terrible negative proof of the truth of the Marxist teaching about the class struggle and about the need for a political organisation of the working class able to play the vanguard role of political and ideological trailblazers. As the Communist Manifesto defined it: the Communists have no interests Socialist Organiser no.497 page 5 apart from those of the working class, but they represent the future of the movement in the movement of the present.

For all the bourgeois propaganda that the idea of a working-class vanguard organisation is inevitably, even organically, Stalinist, they have won their victory and are set to win more because they have their "vanguard" in place — their coterie of priests and academics and groups of defecting bureaucrats.

Despite the vast propaganda equating Marxist organisation with Stalinist pseudoparties, what the USSR, like Eastern Europe in the Last two years, shows us most powerfully is that its own class-conscious, fighting Marxist party is irreplaceable for the working class in it is to free itself from bourgeois influence.

These are he explanations why socialists like ourselves see things developing in a radically different direction to the one we hoped for why we are reduced to Kautsky's ana Plekhanov's fury at history's perversity. But it is not perversity. One consequence of Stalinism is to ensure that those who insisted that Russia could develop only by way of capitalism towards the possibility of working-class power are, after a detour of three quarters of a century, proved right!

They were not inevitably right: the victory of the working class in Western Europe which was possible would have saved the Russian Revolution from the Stalinist counter-revolution and the world from Nazism. It was not inevitable, but it is what is happening now.

A strong socialist movement in the West might have helped ensure a different evolution for Solidarnosc, the only real mass working-class movement to have been consolidated in the Stalinist societies. If the Western labour movements had not - under Stalinist, and sometimes "Trotskyist", influence — scabbed on Solidarnosc, or had effectively helped independent trade unions in the other Stalinist states instead of junketing and hobnobbing with the police-state "trade unions" , then things might have gone differently. But things have gone the way they did.

Our hopes and expectations that after this system would come workers' power are now shown to be so many delusions which must be painfully shed. Without illusions, we must support the democrats in the revolutions now taking place. Recognising that the more thoroughly democratic these revolutions are, the more the old Stalinist state is destroyed, the better for the free development of the future working-class struggles and for the growth of a socialist labour movement, we must do what we can to help them. In the first place we must try to understand them.

Above all, we must give practical and moral support to the tiny groups of socialists now painfully beginning to rebuild a real socialist movement and a socialist labour movement in the states where Stalinism is collapsing on the ground poisoned for so long by the Stalinist counterfeit of socialism. "To say that conscious leaders cannot divert from its path the movement created by the interaction of the environment and the material elements is to ignore the truth that consciousness participates in this interaction. Catholic labour unions are also the inevitable result of the interaction of the environment and the material elements. The difference, however, is that it was the consciousness of priests... and not that of socialists that participated in this interaction"

Lenin

Scan page 6

STALIN'S SYSTEM COLLAPSES Socialist Organiser no.497 page 6

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 497

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →