Why the workers want
Socialist Organiser1991 1991-08-29Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 4 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 4
Socialists like ourselves, watching State conomics not ig socalist state economies not by socialist workers' power and a democratic collectivist system, but by capitalism, are in a position roughly similar to the pioneer- talks ing Marxists George Plekhanov and Karl Kautsky when they watched the Russian workers take power although their dogmatic expectation was that only the bourgeoisie could replace the Tsar.
In fact not the Russian bourgeoisie, but the working class led by the Bolsheviks, replaced the Tsar. The parallel has lessons for us.
What we are witnessing in the USSR is a bourgeois revolution. The leaders of the anti-Stalinist revolution and their ideas; the ideas in the heads of the mass of the people (including the working class); the West European and US social models they look to — all define it as a bourgeois revolution. It is not a bourgeois revolution against the working class, or against feudalists, but against the Tule of the collectivist bureaucratic ruling class, the class which clustered around the once all-controlling state which was, so to speak, its property.
It is a bourgeois revolution having much in common with the revolutions against absolutism in France after 1789 and in various parts of Central Europe in the mid 19th century. It has more, a great deal more, in common with the (abortive) bourgeois revolution against the decayed oriental despotism of China at the beginning of this century, though the USSR is greatly more developed and it would probably be misleading to draw an exact equivalence between the Stalinist system and oriental despotism.
Nevertheless, a bourgeois revolution it is. It faces tremendous difficulties. But they are material, practical, technical difficulties — the lack of markets and of an entrepreneurial bourgeoisie, the tremendous weight of the bureaucracy even after it is certifiably braindead, etc. — not difficulties arising from the resistance of the working class, or by the coherent resistance of any other class.
he bureaucracy is a class - the class which has organised the system of production and appropriated the surplus product for over 60 years — but it, too, or its thinking layers anyway, favours the full bourgeoisification of Stalinist society. When Gorbachev now calls himself a "Scandinavian social-democrat" , it is just an legac Stalinist slave labour camp (and liberty and prosperity are socialist values), ideas of class interest seem to be rudimentary and trade-union level.
The very conception of class consciousness is discredited and tainted by its misuse in the ideology of the bureaucracy, who presented their savage repression as a matter of fighting the proletarian class struggle.
Worse than that, the experience that has shaped and is still shaping the working class in the Stalinist societies propels them away from socialist collectivism, towards marketism and individualism: the hated old system was collectivist.
For masses of workers to form the idea of their own democratic collectivism would be difficult in the circumstances even if a respected and big working-class-based democratic-socialist anti-Stalinist organisation had presented and argued for such a programme in the heat of the struggle against Stalinism. No such party exists: the Stalinists saw to that.
No tradition of independent socialism has been allowed to survive: Stalin saw to that, too, extirpating socialists and even socialist ideas as well as presenting grotesque towards the programme of the bourgeoisie.
The weak socialist groups in the Stalinist states have to argue against the grain, parallelling perhaps the few honest utopian liberal democrats back in 1917.
The collapsing system was imposed Tby Stalin on a largely petty bourgeois society and economy. Nothing in the Marxist programme indicated such all-embracing collectivism, even for a far more developed and less petty-bourgeois society; Trotsky criticised it, though not enough.
In fact Stalin's action in this grew from the competition of the bureaucracy with the petty bourgeoisie and aspirant bourgeoisie for the surplus product: it arose in the bureaucracy's struggle to root out all competitors. The natural evolution would have been to collectivise the "commanding heights" of the economy, controlling and regulating the rest, making controlled links with the world market.
That was the policy after 1921 of Lenin and Trotsky. Even when the Left Opposition argued, between 1923 and 1929, for more "socialistic" measures, they argued within the market-based "New Economic Policy": Stalin broke it entirely.
Now the Stalinist economy is unravelling because for nearly 4 decades it has had neither the Stalinist terror that energised it and controlled the bureaucracy in the early decades, nor conscious working-class democratic self-control in society and the economy:
The consequence for socialists now in the USSR who want to stand against the tide is that they have to argue for a better and different sort of collectivism in face of the utter failure of the Stalinist totalitarian collectivism. It is probably a task difficult to the point of impossibility: that is why the socialist groups remain tiny and isolated, unjustly tainted with both Stalinism and utopianism. They are powerless to demonstrate except in words - words worn away and debased by the Stalinist counterfeiters -what their socialism is; and powerless also against the pressure of international capitalism.
The political force able to conduct the necessary struggle — a democratic socialist party - will have to emerge out of the