Only revolution cé
Socialist Organiser1991 1991-08-20Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 2 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 2
Is we go to press, at noon on Tues day 20 August, the centre of Moscow is split between armea camps and miners in Siberia and in the Ukraine are on strike, in what may be the beginnings of a general strike to stop the Stalinist military-police takeover in the USSR.
The elected leader of the Russian Republic, Boris Yeltsin, has called for a general strike to smash the coup.
They control the radio and TV stations. In the era of satellite broadcasting such control has a limited effect. In Poland, during the strikes in 1980, broadcasts beamed in from beyond Poland's borders broke the state blockade of news about the strikes at Gdansk and helped the strikes to spread.
Two decisive questions will govern events in the USSR now.
Has the chaos unleashed by Gorbachev's economic "reforms" created such an antagonism to Gorbachev and all he stands for that large numbers of workers will back the coup, or refuse to do anything to stop it? The new rulers have promised the hard-pressed people of the USSR wage rises and price freezes, and an end to chaos.
That must have some effect. But Boris Yeltsin may be decisive here. Unlike Gorbachev, Yeltsin — who so far has been a pro-capitalist populist demagogue - has great popularity. His brave defiance of the Stalinist establishment will help workers to see what the issues are — an opening society, with the beginnings of the rule of law and some degree of democratic self-control, on one side, and stifling ice-age Stalinist dictatorship on the other.
A general strike could destroy the coup. The clearest precedent is Germany in 1920. An attempt at a military takeover - the 'Kapp putsch" - was defeated by a great general strike by a labour movement responding to the lead of middle-of-theroad socialists.
The USSR's working class attempt to restore Stalinism.
The second key question is whether the armed forces remain united or split into factions willing to fight each other.
Armies and militarised police forces are hierarchical: they obey orders, until they shatter. Will the armed forces hold or shatter? The soldiers are conscripts; but conscripts have been used in coups many times, in Chile in 1973 for example. The fact that many of the conscripts are from nationalities claiming independence may destabilise the USSR's army: the example of the Yugoslav army, riven by ethnic conflicts is now before our eyes; yet a Serbiandominated Yugoslav army still exists.
In what may be the beginning of a major split in the armed forces, a cluster of 20 tanks has gathered to defend Boris Yeltsin's Russian Federation parliament. Crowds are gathering there, and have built barricades. Should the Kremlin use force, the moment of truth will come when the soldiers it sends into action have to decide either to act for the new dictators or to go over to the people. robably inevitable. For decades o ran a command economy controlled by a massive centralised bureaucracy. That economy stagnated and fell behind the West. The new bureaucratic Tsar, Mikhail Gorbachev, who came to power in 1985, faced the desperate need to revitalise the economy.
He found he could do little against the dead weight of the bureaucracy. The previous reforming Stalinist Tsar, Khrushchev, had found that too, before he was overthrown in 1964. So Gorbachev decided to take a cudgel to the bureaucracy. He opened it up to the light of day and to public criticism.
But by introducing chaos and confusion and uncertainty into the bureaucracy, "glasnost" — openness - made the existing system even more inefficient. "Perestroika" - restructuring — followed. And more chaos. The dead weight of the bureaucracy was immense. Will the armed forces split? A woman argues w The bureaucracy began to fall apart Some bureaucrats - in the first place Yeltsin, the former Moscow party boss -openly • advocated the restoration o! capitalism. Responding from day to day a: the crisis grew, Gorbachev inched toward: formally abolishing the political monopol! of the "Party" - it had already beer broken in fact by the first fruits o "glasnost". A month ago he went further and at a Communist Party Central Com mittee plenum formally broke with "com munism" - that is, Stalinism, the systen Stalin created at the end of the 1920s.
At the heart of the Stalinist system, an‹ of the command economy fallen into chao because the centre had become too weal and uncertain, was now a leading tean steering the USSR towards the restoratior of capitalism.
As a by-product of his attempt to escap from the contradictions of a vastl overstretched, economically backward world empire - maybe one third of th USSR's income was going on military spen ding - Gorbachev allowed the East Euro