Why we support a merged union in the civil service NUCPS/CPSA: yes to merger
Socialist Organiser1991 1991-08-15Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 15 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 15
their union as "unworthy of the cies, lack of prospects. In a DSS CPSA often fall into the tran _ we reiect this merger then To men who form these gains now also appear to be Discrimination on Acts have never enable lived their FLU ASSeSs OLE have won I/HL pay, our rights in the workplace and Within trade The meeting will be workshop Women natie attacks on women workers nig huts • anti-union legislation By Mark Serwotka and Steve Battlemuch the autumn, CPSA members, representing some of the lowest paid workers in the Civil Service, will be ballotted on whether they wish their union to merge with the National Union of Civil and Public Servants (NUCPS) which currently organises the low-paid cleaners, messengers and security guards right up to senior levels of management, some earning $30,000 per year:
The majority of NUCPS members are lower middle management, most of them in Executive Officer (EO) grades.
NUCPS has already voted for merger. CPSA did likewise, however, in another example of the right-wing leadership doctrine of "re-run the vote until you get the required result". , the ballot is to be run again. This time the Broad Left, particularly Militant and the SWP, and the right-wing will be going all out to secure a no vote.
Backed by conference policy, the leadership of the union, is campaigning hard for a no vote. Meanwhile the Kinnockite Broad Left 84 group will campaign for a yes vote.
Socialist Organiser supporters in the CPSA will also be calling on members to vote yes.
This position is not only at odds with the rest of the left, but is also the opposite of the flawed view we put forward in the ballot held last year. Why have we changed our minds? Why is the rest of the left fundamentally -wrong?
There are two broadly held views of opposition to the merger, firstly the opinion that a top to bottom union, representing all grades, is not in the interests of CPSA members. This opinion, often referred to as the opposition-in-principle argament, is the majority view of the vote no camp. It is the mistaken view that many of us shared in the first ballot.
In essence it starts from a view of the Civil Service that believes "management" begins at the EO or supervisory grade. That clerical Union members are more militant than EOs and that reporting officers cannot have any place in a workers' union.
These views are widely-held amongst activists. At heart, they involve a gut hatred of NUCPS as a union, often categorising its members as "'scabs" and their union name".
To be sure this bleak view is not expressed openly, instead it is toned down into reasonable arguments about reporting procedures, clericals being more likely to strike, and such like. But basically, it maintains that in some way, EOs and above are not welcome, or deserving enough to be in a clerical, militant union.
This may seem unbelievable to union members in other unions like NALGO or the NUT, but it is the view of many good, serious grassroots militants in CPSA. We must reject this CPSA chauvinism. We must refuse to bow down to those who think the issue is settled because some NUCPS members have crossed their picket lines in the past.
We wish to build a strong, radical and powerful Civil Service trade union movement. Not one based on local, sectional and often selective memories of yesteryear.
Civil Servants, regardless of grade, face the same problems, low pay, understaffing, Agen(TASS)
ND LWEEKS IN cies, lack of prospects. In a DSS office, the LO2 and EO grade face very similar problems. It is nonsense to proclaim, as do the SWP for instance, that only CPSA members want to fight.
The existence of two separate unions allows the management to divide and conquer. Recently in the DSS, NUCPS launched a 6 month staffing strike. In one office in Hull, they struck for 5 months whilst CPSA members worked. They worked because CPSA refused to allow them to join the dispute. 6 months later, NUCPS were at work while CPSA struck! The management were the winners, but so were the union bureaucrats, who refused to allow rank and file unity in defence of their interests.
Two unions create two bureaucracies. Two obstacles to rank and file militancy.
The second view of opposition to the merger is put forward by Militant. It is opposition based on the terms of the proposed new rule book.
Militant on paper are in favour of one Civil Service trade union, however, their supporters in the US WAR CPSA often fall into the trap mentioned earlier. One of their supporters at the recent conference debate ended his speech urging delegates "not to throw away 90 years of CPSA history". However, on paper at least, Militant reject this. They argue instead for a democratic, nonbureacratic merger. But in practice they always find some detail in the merger proposals to justify their opposition. This is a warped view.
The case for merger is overwhelming. It will make it easier to fight, more unity at office level, one set of conference proposals, one united office meeting are all positive steps.
It is easier to have unity in acdon if we are in one union. Yes, there will be some difficulties. Local office managers at union meetings, annual reports, different traditions. However, these can all be overcome.
If we are serious about building a stronger Civil Service trade union movement, merger makes sense. If for whatever reason — political sectarianism, workforce in Britain, IMMre and the government.
Equal and Sex national Government and emplovers are now trying to take away the tew movemens represenato and take action on issues which affect women at work. Many of 1991 10am TOMI Wesley House, 4 Wild Court, London ECI I was finished at the factory soon after and the dol found me a job on the railways. The NUR branch at least met, once a month, but it couldn't have been called lively.
The meeting was on the far side of town and lasted little more than half an hour. The half hour consisted of the secretary reading out all the correspondence from Head Office and deciding whether to note it or not.
The chair then asked for any other business, but during my short time in that branch there never was any. I felt very wary of speaking up in any of these branch meetings, not being sure how it would be taken and anyway I felt like I would be disturbing the peace!
My next branch was easier taking an active rôle.
Socialist Movement Trade Union CURTCHEESEEEREIOLP to snare Our in the unions Urus caucuses.
Workshone wil anendec • 1992 and immigration • internationalism unionisation of women problems • lesbians at work We hone nons encourage wor attend and if he event and t to cover our costs. - we reject this merger, then we will be making a massive mistake.
The Kinnockites favour merger because they believe it suits their careers in the union, and because of political agreements they have with the Stalinists in NUCPS. The rightwing in CPSA oppose merger because they fear losing their grip on power in a new union. Militant do not believe the time is right for them, after all they would be giving up control of the CPSA Broad Left without any guarantees in a new union. Many good CPSA activists reject merger on the genuine but mistaken grounds of hostility to having management grades in their union.
We reject all of this. We support merger, only on the grounds of it helping to achieve greater union organisation, increased militancy and better opportunities for rank and file struggle.
Merger should be supported because it strengthens Civil Service workers' ability to fight back.
this, women increasingly joining unions and Women for Socialism and the develop La Dictay Sessions organising in the taking up working women's hate sumne thetic unions and trades councils will possible sponsor the event and to send a donation - same union but in Shetfield. It met fortnightly in an easier place but the mair difference was that I had a different approach.
I was asked by other SO supporters to try and get delegates from it to a CND conference. That was at my first meeting! I didn't want to do it, but I had said I would try.
Right at the end I plucked up the courage to raise it, fully expecting rejection. But no. "Good idea," said the chair. "You go along and let us know what happens."
I think the point is that the first time 1 actually did raise something I was encouraged. And I wouldn't have known that if I hadn't actually tried.
Rob Dawber is Secretary of the Sheffield and Chesterfield District Council of the RMT
----- pull-quotes -----
ovement/Women for-Socialism itiarie" vroken in the mons
6 GIRLS OU SACKED
OBACCO ORKERS UNLOS TASS SUSPEND
careerism, or CPSA chauvinism N nearl of the
santons and to rights. WUHICH Ware occal fighting DEUT based
unnons Highting i Saturday 23rd November • abortion