Marxism. Stalinism and the Militant
Socialist Organiser1991 1991-08-15Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 14 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 14
more successful in safeguarding the basic rights of all the Yugoslav peoples.
Steven Holt South London The Alliance for Workers' Liberty has just reissued a pamphlet first put out 6 years ago. It analyses thi reasons for the Russian invasion of Afghanistan in December 1979 and the arguments of the kitschTrotskyists who supported the Russians against the Afghan peoples.
It deals in particular detail with "Militant's' arguments for backing the Russians against what an article in "Militant" by one of that group's leaders, Alan Woods, described as 'the dark masses' of Afghanistan.
In this extract from the introduction to the new edition John O'Mahony explains how we tried to function as Marxists within the false theoretical framework we then shared with 'Militant' and others.
The debate in these pages is a debate betTween two versions of the so-called orthodox Trotskyist' assessment of the class nature of the old Stalinist states, which we described as degenerated and deformed workers' states.
Socialist Organiser has since formally abandoned that conceptual framework. The Stalinist bureaucracies are, we now believe, ruling classes, and the Stalinist states are a variant of class society.
The consequences of this change for the validity or otherwise of the ideas I express in this pamphlet are less than you might expect. The reason for this is that the descriptions Socialist Organiser and before it, Workers' Action, and before that, Workers' Fight!) made of the workings of Stalinism were to a large extent uninfluenced by adherence to the 'workers' us only the idea that the fully statified Stalinist economies were historically postcapitalist. And we were already implicitly questioning that when we insisted on the centrality of Trotsky's way of putting the question in 1940: such nationalised economy is only 'potentially progressive'. It is not, without qualification, progressive now. That potential will become real only on condition that the working class makes a new revolution.
For technical and dogmatic reasons we described that revolution as a 'political revolution', but when we spelled it out to include the *smashing of the state' we described and advocated a full revolution of one class, the working class, against another, the bureaucracy.
In fact, Trotsky's way of posing things at the end of his life implied jettisoning the whole 'workers' state" schema once it became clear - as it did in the early or mid '40s - that Stalinism was no mere episode in the history of the degeneration of the workers' state set up in 1917 but a comparatively stable system capable of replicating itself (and going on in the old way for another half century, as it turned out).
The entire 'workers' state" framework was radically wrong. The whole notion that Stalinism was 'postcapitalist' was radically wrong (right now it looks more 'pre-capitalist'!).
We should have long ago shed that framework. What we did instead was slough it off by way of dealing concretely and honestly and without dogmatic blinkers with the Stalinist reality. As in the discussion in this pamphlet, this led us, despite the workers' state schemata to which we still — just about — subscribed, to deal with the class reality of Russian imperialism. Looking at the horrible reality of the USSR's attempt to subjugate Afghanistan, we rejected the idea that 'workers' statism' implied support for Russia's Vietnam war.
A clear rejection of the workers' state' schemas would have been better; nevertheless, even with it we grasped more or less adequately the class realities of the Russian-Afghanistan war. Nothing - throughout our history as a tendency in our version of "workers" statism' ever implied for us adopting the viewpoint of the Russian ruling class.
The case daine Soviet inyation of aganistan 5 Eston with gent in paucion A Workers Liberty Pamphlet E2 plus 38 pence from PO Box 823, London SE15 4NA
----- pull-quotes -----
Marxism, Stalinism and the Militant