Asking for leniency
Socialist Organiser1991 1991-08-15Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 14 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 14
In last week's Women's Eye column Liz Millward argues a plea of manslaughter cannot be justified where a woman claims she was provoked into killing her husband when previously she had made several threats to kill him.
But how can you tell whether such a plea seems credible if you do not know the exact circumstances of his killing? The Appeal Court's ruling in this case seems to be to be very dangerous.
By the same logic, are we to assume that a woman cannot accuse a man of rape if prior to that rape she had told all her friends she wanted to sleep with him?
Liz's arguments seem quite confused but she does appear to be saying mitigation, or special pleading, from someone who does not deny their guilt - in the case of murder - is not acceptable. If she is making this conclusion, I think she is wrong.
First let me get out of the way some common ground. I would assume Liz does not think killing in self-defence is in the same category as premeditated killing. Also I do not believe that people can or should opt out of responsibility for their action even if you can find tangible causes (such as violent abuse within the family) for violent and destructive behaviour. I also see the point of Liz's argument about double standards. Of course men and women should be treated the same by the law, But that does not mean we should pay no attention to what a murderer may use as evidence in mitigation.
First you would have to ap ply this rule to all crimes. For instance, a pensioner who forgets to pay for some shopping would be convicted of shoplifting. That's pretty unreasonable. Of course this is a stickier subject in some instances.
For example, a man, not denying rape, might say he was confused or mistaken because his victim did appear to be willing. But you can't prove a point through good and bad examples.
Someone convicted of any crime should have the opportunity to explain themselves. to ask for certain factors to be taken into account, to ask for leniency. This seems to me to be progressive and humane.
Capitalist laws work badly. They are never straightforwardly progressive or humane when they seem to be. For instance in the US -as far as I understand — there is a very complex system of charges and acceptable mitigation surrounding the crime of homocide.
You can commit murder in so many different degrees — depending on the state you are in. However, the courts and police will opt for a charge which is administratively efficient -the one they hope they can get a conviction on. So, far from being a humane system, it is a bureaucratic farce. This does not mean we do not defend progressive elements within bourgeois law because of the way they are implemented.
There are situations, maybe even the one Liz writes about, where murder is more complex than Liz makes out. I have read the story of one woman who was locked into a violent relationship. She had in the past had the support of Women's Aid without being able to find any self-esteem; she continued to stay in this relationship; she regularly threatened to kill her partner, kill herself; he regularly threatened to kill himself, kill her.
Who was killed in the end might have been just a matter of pure, terrifying, horrible chance. This experience is acually very common. And if she had killed her partner, would not like to say well, the law is the law, and murder is murder.
Cathy Nugent South London