Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Images into a show

Socialist Organiser no. 495, 15 August 1991 · scan p. 13 · Vicki Morris · about 601 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 13 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 13

Vicki Morris reviews with Madonna f you don't like Madonna's music don't see this film. If you do, go, but prepare to be tested... felt more ambivalently about her after seeing it than I had ever before.

"In Bed With Madonna" is the story of her 1990 world tour with scenes in colour from the shows, and irritating grainy, black and white ['cinéma verité"? Ed], in the main, video footage from behind the scenes.

The scenes from the show fail to impress as much as they might on two counts: they are real takes from the shows but filmed as though they are a pop video, so they don't convey much sense of the exciting live performance that the distantly perceived audience are enjoying, whilst being, simultaneously, not nearly glam and polished enough to serve as the video accompaniment to your newly-bought Madonna CD played at home.

This said, still there isn't actually enough of this footage, because it does show, albeit imperfectly, that the show is a technical and artistic extravaganza. turns them show.

The film's other contrivances are too painfully reminiscent of college drama productions to do anything other than convince me that, if Madonna is nice underneath, I'd rather see that than her trying so hard to live up to her image.

Sometimes she is downright pretentious. Maybe she does feel maternally towards her dancers — you have surely heard about that -but it's hard to imagine that their lives are genuinely enriched by her backgrounds' with "family problems' '. Doesn't she care enough about these people to let them define themselves a bit? There's no doubt about it, she has got to be in charge. She admits as much, but, whereas that turns out good where the dancing, singing and costumes (the stuff that matters) are concerned, I'm sure glad she ain't in my family.

Speaking of family... the girl got alent. She can use the most unpromising material to some advanage. Her family, appearing at intervals, are downright homely, yet she lavishes filial affection on them. That way we are reminded that she's just like the girl-next-door all the Wannabes remain.

And she probably is just about as enigmatic as them, for all her mother died when she was very young (grossly exploitative scene of Madonna visiting mother's grave and sentimentalising about a woman she can scarcely possibly remember — yes, with Madonna all is grist to the mill).

As for her stock-in-trade, she's probably about as raunchy in real-life as the person sitting in front of you in the cinema. The difference being that what we all do, she simulates on stage - and what modern dance troupe doesn't go in for a bit of that? (Not a nude body in the whole film bv the wav for all the dirty talk and unlike most of the theatrical circles I ever moved in.)

Well, perhaps that is her main appeal, and why she is taken as a rồle model by so many young people.

Forget the 'madonna-whore' dichotomy reviled by many feminists today, and which she does not use - the real Madonna uses the most unpromising images of womanhood in terms of their potential for commercial exploitation. All that corsetry, the evidently bleached hair, the jumble-sale outfits and gum-chewing of her earlier incarnation, exaggerates and turns into a show.

Likewise, in her film, she is careful to appear as often as possible in the backstage scenes without her make-up, in her dressing gown and shower cap, telling winsome rhymes about farting. Well, she

----- pull-quotes -----

*Madonna exaggerates the most unpromisin images and

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 495

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →