How the jobless organised in the '20s and '30s The Angel Marches
Socialist Organiser1991 1991-08-15Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 10
East London 1931: unemployed demonstrators fight the police larches of the 1980s were a pallid re-run of the marches of the Two million official y unemployed, which means real figure of three or fou And the unemployed facerepeated attacks on their benefits and rights from ti Tory government. Lessons from the unemployed workers' movement of the 1920s and '30s are once again relevant. Mick Sidaway reviews the history.
The unemployed movement started with the setting up of Local Unemployed Exservicemen's Organisations after the First World War.
Shop stewards and other experienced trade unionists thrown out or their jobs in the years after he war soon took a leading role By the end of October 1920 twelve London district organisations came together to form the London District Council of the unemployed. The LDC proclaimed three slogans: "Work or Full Maintenance" "Go to the Guardians" [the local "Poor Law Guardians" who then administered the dole), and the demand for suitable premises for the unemployed to meet in.
The key to the organisation of the unemployed was direct action. The Library in Essex Road, Islington, Is. was seized by the unemployed who "after taking possession... barricaded themselves in and had a constant guard day and night against being evicted... Whenever anybody left the hall, or wanted to enter it, a strong body of men stood at the door ready to defend the hall if any attempt was made to rush it. This went on for several weeks...
The same direct action tactics were used against workhouse authorities, Poor Law Guardians and employers. The London unemployed pioneered the factory raid, a tactic which succeeded in cutting overtime in a number of poorly organised factories.
At the Central Aircraft Factory in Kilburn, the employees had accepted reduced rates of pay and overtime was being worked. The LDC had some contacts in the factory who supplied them with a plan. So as not to arouse suspicion as they approached the factory, the raiders all carried football gear. At a signal they all rushed the gates and entered the factory, first finding the power-motors and switching them off. At the same time the telephones were commandeered.
The workers were called to hear the raiders and soon, of course, the manager arrived. The raiders assured the workers that they were with them in their struggles, and that their aim was to see that no overtime was worked.
The incident ended with victory for the raiders. The manager agreed to halt overtime as from the coming weekend. Perhaps he was a little upset, as he had just been beaten up by police who had rushed to the plant, and mistaken him for a raider!
KKOW April 1921 saw the birth of the National Unemployed Workers' Movement. Within months the government had revised unemployment benefit rates, reducing them to the rates in force at the beginning of the year.
The response was quick to come: in August 10,000 Sheffield unemployed marched to the town hall under the sign of the skull and crossbones and the words, "Death is better than starvation" • After a series of big and bitter demonstrations in Bristol, the guardians there agreed to raise their scales.
At its conference in November 1921 the NUWM decided to organise to resist evictions of unemployed workers who had fallen in arrears with their rent. Special tenants' organisations were the formed, scouts foot bicycles.
The biggest eviction fight in Glasgow took place on 17 May 1922. It gave the lead to many other parts of the country, and led the Glasgow City Council to set up a special rent fund to relieve tenants who were in danger of eviction.
At the end of July 1922 the Birmingham branch of the NUWM decided to march to London. By winter the local idea had taken on national proportions, and the NUWM was busy organising the first National Hunger March. The 2,000 marchers tramped through blizzards in the bitterly cold October and November of 1922 to "fight for bread." Stoner Mach, the 192 rud hortly before the National Congress had received a delegation from the NUWM. On 20 December 1922, with the marchers in London, the NUWM sent another delegation, which proposed to the General Council that a day of action be called for 7 January 1923, to be known as "Unemployment Sunday"
A central organising committee was immediately set up, consisting of an equal number of delegates from the NUWM, the TUC General Council, the London Labour Party, and the London Trades Council. Calls were issued to trades councils, trade unions, and Labour Parties throughout the country to establish similar joint machinery in every centre to organise powerful demonstrations on the appointed day.
So which ended decisively after the defeat of the General Strike in 1936 - in which the official movement played a useful part in organising the unemployed and bringing about unity between the employed and the unemployed.
After the successes of the Unemployment Sunday agitation, the NUWM approached the TUC with more ambitious proposals.
• Closer relations between employed and unemployed, by establishing a joint committee with equal representation from the TUC General Council and the NUWM.
• That the General Council should circularise the trade unions encouraging the formation of unemployed workers' committees in every locality, attached to the NUWM.
• That at the next Trades Union Congress the affiliation of the NUWM to the TUC should be placed on the agenda.
• When the TUC met that September in Plymouth, a General Council recommendation was accepted, that the first two proposals be carried but the third rejected. It was not until late in January 1923 that the first meeting of the NUWM-TUC Joint Action Committee took place.
The JAC drafted a Charter and prepared for another Unemployed Sunday in June. The Charter's points were explained in a series of șix leaflets on Maintenance, Housing, Work Schemes, Hours of Work, Training and state workshops.
By the middle of the next year the TUC's attitude was distinctly cooler. The NUWM's resolution was not even allowed on the order paper at the TUC's Special Conference on Unemployment in 1924. With the right turn of the TUC after the defeat of the General Strike, official support for the unemployed struggles ceased. Tsuike and the subsequent he defeat of the General defeat of the miners meant the most intense suffering in the mining areas. The pit owners used their victory to increase hours and throw thousands out of work. Between April and September 1927 300,000 miners were axed from the workforce.
In September 1927 Hannington and AJ Cook, the militant general secretary of the Miners' Federation, addressed a great demonstration of Rhonda miners and their families, calling for a march to London. As for official support, not even the Executive of Cook's own union would support the march.
The Prime Minister refused to meet a delegation of the marchers when they reached London. Eventually the Minister of Labour, Sir Arthur Steel-Maitland, agreed to meet a delegation.
"One of the deputation inquired whether the Minister thought that a man, wife and four children could live on 16 shillings a "ek, such as many miners' families were expected to do?
"In challenging tones he said to the Minister 'Could you exist on such a pittance?' But Sir Arthur only fidgeted in his chair as he evaded the question. When the deputation demanded that all persons who had been struck off the exchange registers should be placed back on benefit, the Minister said 'You are asking me to break the law' "We don't care one jot about your law!' said the marchers. We are concerned about saving human lives, and if the law has to be broken in order to do that, then the law should be broken!" The ondal 22 deter winter he Second National Hunger le ordeal of bitter winter weather, opposition from the official labour movement and brutality from the police and civil authorities.
It set out from Scotland late in January 1929, determined to break the ruling from central government that the authorities on the way should treat the marchers to "casual conditions" only.
This march had as a particular objective the fight against the "not genuinely seeking work" ruling, which had struck thousands off the books of exchanges and subjected tens of thousands to useless wandering only so that they could meet the expected questions at the interrogations of the Public Assistance Committees.
A Third National Hunger March set out on 30 March 1929 and for the first time included a contingent of women. Other contingents came
Scan page 11
Rafsanjani, no gains for the workers from Scotland, Durham, Northumberland, Plymouth, Yorkshire, Lancashire, Notts, Derby, South Wales, Staffordshire, Midlands and Kent.
While the marchers were on the road the Labour government elected in May 1929 abolished the "not genuinely seeking work" clause and raised the adult rate of benefit from 7 shillings to 9 shilllings.
The fall of the Labour government when the Labour Prime Minister Ramsey MacDona Id went "With the right turn at the TUC after the defeat of the genera strike, official support for the unemployed gles ceased.
over to the Tories in 1931, unleashed a dramatic rise in mass struggles.
he "National" (Tory) government elected in October 1931 quickly introduced the notorious means test.
For a year the means test was the main focus of the struggle of the unemployed. At the end of that period, in September 1932, three big struggles erupted with barricade fighting and many clashes with the police and, in Belfast, with the army On 13 September 10,000 Birkenhead unemployed demonstrated to the Public Assistance Committee with the following simple demands: Relief to all able-bodied unemployed and an acrease of 3s per week; immediate apply of boots and clothes and one undredweight of coal during the inter; and the starting of work Memes at trade union rates.. away, the police interfered unemnloved began to cession, a conflict took umber of arrests went made. Two daysulater the unemployed again demonstrated against the Public Assistance Committee to secure improvements in their relief scales..
"Suddenly large numbers of police were ordered to draw their batons and they began to club to the ground demonstrators pedestrians, including men, women and children, the aged and infirm.
*This roused the feeling of the whole of Birkenhead, and that night a tremendous demonstration assembled at the park gates as a protest against the police action. After short speeches they formed up and marched round the town, returning to the park gates, and when the demonstators were just about to disperse to their homes the police, without any apparent reason, made a baton charge.
"Unemployed and employed workers stood their ground, and one policeman was thrown through a plate-glass window. The crowd took up the offensive and the police eventually were compelled to run; but they rallied again and a pitched battle ensued. Workers tore up railings to defend themselves and the fighting went on until eleven at night, 37 policemen being carried to hospital."
In the new year of 1934 another National Hunger March set off - this time, in Hannington's estimation, rallying wider sections of the working class movement than any previous march. Three days before the marchers were to enter London the police arrested five in the Tyneside contingent for "deserting their wives" , though each marcher was able to prove he was there with his wife's support.
Seven West Fife marchers were even arrested on the same charge after they had returned home!
On 1 March, 300 succeeded in getting into the outer lobby at Westminster and 24 into the public gallery. Then suddenly a cry rang from the public gallery: "Meet the Hunger Marchers" "We refuse to starve in silence" "Down with the National Government"
When news reached the lobby that fighting had broken out in the gallery, the 300 marchers there started to sing the "Internationale"
at the top of their voices.
The April 1923 Budget DUR HISTORY the cuts that had been made. But the victory was not to last long. The 1934 Unemployed Assistance Board (UAB) Act called for compulsory training for the unemployed. Even the Home Secretary Sir John Gilmour described the training camps as "concentration camps"
The Act also reduced benefits for all over the age of 14; single adult males lviing with their families lost 7s; subsequent members of the family lost 9s, while a single female worker living with her family also lost 7s. In addition, there were wholesale disallowances of benefit.
Finally, after strike threats by the Cambrian Combine miners of the Rhondda and nationwide marches and protests, including the sacking of the offices of the Public Assistance Committees in many towns, this Act was repealed. Now the campaign was for the immediate restoration of the old scales - and again, finally, the government gave way.
Throughout the history of the unemployed movement, the central organising and initiating force in it was the then-revolutionary Communist Party. After 1935, when the CP turned to the policy of the "Popular Front" — meaning suppression of class struggle in favour of alliances with bourgeois liberals - the unemployed movement declined. organisation of the unemployed, and direct action to win their demands — no longer fitted with the CP's new line.
Before 1935 the ultra-left line pursued by the Communist Party -the so-called "Third Period" policy of 1928-34 - had hindered the movement. Its effects were limited by the fact that the Communist Party leaders in the unemployed movement, while paying lip-service to "Third Period" dogma, ignored it in practice much of the time, and continued to try to orient the movement towards official politics and the official labour movement.
The combination of direct action and organisation by the unemployed themselves with an orientation to the official labour movement is what is needed today.
(This article draws heavily on Unemployed Struggles 1919-36, by Wal Hannington. The passages it quotes are from that book.) M. Razi of the Iranian Workers' Socialist Notebooks group, analyses the talk of reform in Iran he recent policies of the Islamic Republic and the clear and open orientation of Rafsanjani's regime towards imperialism, especially since the end of the Gulf War, has caused excitement and anticipation amongst the 'liberal' and 'democratic' forces of the Iranian opposition.
Some are so enthusiastic that they are preparing themselves for imminent return to Iran and servitude to the Rafsanjani regime. Others have already arrived in Tehran hoping to benefit from the new economic climate.
In truth, the nature of the Iranian regime has not changed since the February 1979 uprising. The socioeconomic crisis of the late 1970s that led to the February uprising, together with the organisational weakness of the working class in responding to this crisis, allowed the establishment of another form of capitalist state. It replaced the Shah's regime.
The Islamic regime in Iran came to power with the approval of imperialism, whilst relying on the religious hierarchy and the bazaar under a to delude the anti-imperialist exploited workers and peasants.
From the very first day, the new regime's principal aim was to restore the previous economic and international relations.
These aims and ambitions were not achieved as smoothly and as easily as the new rulers hoped. The continuing economic and social crisis, and the active presence of the masses in the political arena after the overthrow of the Shah, did not allow a speedy return to the previous order. The religious character of the regime was also an obstacle.
Some of the religious capitalists expected a feudal, patriarchal manner of resolving all economic and political issues. The factionalism within the regime was caused by these expectations, and continues to this day. The faction labelled "radical' or 'extremist' - as opposed to "liberal' and 'moderate' — existed at the same time as the uprising and is by no means a new phenomenon.
There was Socialist Organiser No. 495 page 11 between the two factions" in implementing repression, execution, iniustices and exploitation. Most of the executions, kidnappings, repression had the complete personal approval of Rafsanjani. The regime remains the same, only the elements have changed place. Secret relations with the US and imperialism have existed all the time and they continue today.
However, the new policies of Rafsanjani, especially the open way in which he invites western governments to invest and his invitations to Iranian and foreign capitalists to return to Iran, demonstrate change in the balance of forces in his favour. The victory of the moderate faction is more certain.
For the first time in the life of the Islamic regime, Rafsanjani feels confident enough to invite the leaders of imperialist countries to visit Tehran. The French and German foreign ministers and the Austrian president have all visited Tehran.
Iran is expecting to make major deals with western businessmen. Recently, over $2 billion of petrochemical products were pre-sold to foreign companies. France has signed an agreement to market iranian crude oil and invest in explorations in the waters of the Persian Gulf, and a consortium of foreign banks has agreed to pay for this joint Franco-Iranian plan.
Iranian capitalists who fled during the Shah's time have been invited to return. Mr Noor Bakhsh, the economic minister, and Adell, the governor of Iran's Central bank, have met exiled Iranian capitalists to invite them to return to Iran.
On the political front, the Rafsanjani faction is defeating all opponents. Supporters former premier Bazargan, remain in prison and, for the first time, Mullahs associated with the "Rajatyoun' (resurrectionists) faction were recently executed in Ghom. The Rafsanjani faction is preparing itself for next year's elections to the Majles (parliament) and, in order to deprive its opponents of any chance of victory, it is proposing new laws concerning candidature to the Majles.
"Peace and freedom" for Iranian capitalists means increasing repression for the oppressed. Contrary to the beliefs of Iranian «liberals" and "democrats" who are anxiously awaiting the democracy and freedom promised by Rafsanjani and western governments, revolutionary socialists have no illusions about capitalist democracy.
Political and economic democracy and the resolution of the present crisis is impossible under a capitalist regime. The working class must use its independent force from within its own organisations to overthrow the present regime.
Published by: WORKERS'
SOCIALIST NOTEBOOKS (Journal of Iranian Revolutionary Socialists)
Address: BM WSN, London WCIN 3XX Other articles published by WSN:
• War in the Gulf and Revolutionary Socialism. (Maziar Roozbeh - 6.2.91)
• Why the Kurds were defeated.
(Mariam - 10.4.91)
Workers' Socialist Notebooks is a journal of Iranian Revolutionary Socialists, which deals with current historial and political issues facing the vanguard of the Iranian working class. WN is a bi-monthly journal which appears Farsi. For back issues please contact us.
Scan page 12
Those who do not learn from history Socialist Organiser No. 495 page 12 Tony Brown reviews The Permanent Revolution? Conservative Law and the Trade Unions by John Mcllroy Thatcherism failed, writes union laws together with other social and economic changes have changed British industrial relations, perhaps irrevocably.
The accumulation of anti-union laws under the Tories has been so dramatic that it is possible that the system that existed before Thatcher's election in 1979 may never be visited again.
In these circumstances both the trade unions and the Labour Party have to consider how best to dismantle the laws in a strategic and realistic manner.
What has progressively changed throughout Thatcher's terms has been a shift in the generation of alternative policies from the trade unions to the Labour Party. Today rather than the TUC proposing what should replace the Tories Laws, all policy proposals emanate from Walworth Road. The TUC is prepared to cop anything, including retaining central aspects of Tory legislation, in order to get a Labour government.
But the biggest absence from the discussions of how best to deal with the Tory's laws is the rank and file union member.
In stark contrast to the healthy shop steward movement, which, because of their organisation and strength, were able to play such a prominent role up until the late 1970s, today the TUC and Labour Party have consciously sought to exclude workers from their policy Mcllroy's book is a timely contribution to the debate now needed. Even before the book has had time to circulate, Michael Howard, the Employment Secretary, has foreshadowed new legislation further restricting picketing, and compulsory seven day notice periods before industrial action. This new legislation stands a good chance of going one step too far.
Recent opinion polls indicate that people no longer consider the unions to be the ogre so successfully depicted by the Tories over the past decade. A good majority now consider unions to be essential defenders of their rights, and that more anti-union laws are primarily vindictive and motivated purely by considerations of electoral advantage.
If that is so then it is not because the TUC, having waged a war, or even a fight, against the laws, finally came out on top. Far from it. Mollroy's book traces the evolution Norman Willis: neither imagination nor fight register had provided in 1971.
Thatcher also had to accept the reality that she was not yet in a majority in her own Cabinet, and had to be prepared to accomodate, for the time being, the old wing of the Conservative Party.
Her programme was nevertheless clear and had been carefully thought out and planned during her years as opposition leader.
Three reports — Carrington's in 1975 examining Heath's downfall; Ridley's in 1978 which prioritised which unions to fight; Hoskyn's which focused on the propaganda necessary to make unionism a dirty word - provided a blueprint for the Thatcherites to smash the post-war consensus that Labour, the unions, business and even parts of the Tory party still accepted as ongoing.
In this early period the conflict within the Cabinet was over whether the unions should be given some role in the economy (Jim Prior), or whether they should be decisively weakened and given no role in economic decision making (Thatcher, Tebbit and others).
While the 1980 Act represented a victory for Prior, the eventual winner enjoyed her spoils by making Prior Northern Ireland Secretary.
Restrictive legislation was not new. Labour had tried it under Wilson and the Tories under Heath. What Mellroy argues was distinctive about Thatcher's approach was the combination of legislation with economic policy.
Rather than just take on the unions with new laws and fight it out, Thatcher had determined to "integrate economic policy and legal restrictions so that the unions' strength would be sapped by economic policy at the very moment they were faced with a legal offensive"
Full employment, welfare and subsidies to industry, notably manufacturing industry, which strengthened the unions had previously led to the collapse of anti-union laws. The state had not backed up its policies with the full force of the law, and here again Thatcher and her colleagues developed new policing methods specifically aimed at dealing with strikers, but which were not unleashed until they considered the time ripe.
An ideological fervour fuelled their crusade. Hayek spoke in terms. of enemies, "the real exploiters in our present society are not egoistic capitalists or entrepreneurs and in fact not separate individuals but organisations which derive their power from the moral support of collective action and group loyalty." He went on: "There can be no salvation for Britain unless the special privileges granted to the trade unions three-quarters of a century ago are revoked."
Interpreting these laws once they had been passed was left, of course, decade each pisce of legislation had been interpreted as widely as possible, giving greater scope for its use against workers and providing penalties designed to cripple their organisations.
The NUR asked its members in a ballot in May 1980: "Do you agree to support the executive committee in their fight to maintain the current agreement on seniority and to resist the imposition of organisational changes, unsatisfactory attendance procedures and compulsory tendering by taking strike action?" This seems pretty clear and members voted their support. But when London Underground went to the judges they ruled that the question was unclear and ordered the NUR to stop the strike.
Jimmy Knapp declared that "we are rapidly reaching the position in this country where it is not possible to call a strike and remain within the law.
In the NGA dispute over Eddie Shah's Warrington print plant in 1983, for instance, the union was fined £50,000 on November 17, 100,000 on the 25th, and a further £500,000 in December.
This anti-working class bias is not surprising. In 1987, of the top 465 udges. 17 were women and one was black, hardly a representative cross section of society, yet one that interpreted the laws regarding all facets of employment.
Law Lord Salmon of Sandwich (sic) summed up his brothers' attitudes "we cannot close our eyes to the fact that there are groups very small numerically but extremely cohesive and tenacious who have infiltrated the unions with the intention of seizing power if they can. Their avowed purpose is to wreck the Social Contract and the democratic system under which we live." The TUC were caught off ow did the TUC respond?
guard. They didn't understand mounting a counter-offensive anti-union laws had disappeared.
Confusion reigned within the TUC. The 1985 Congress voted for a TGWU motion calling for the complete repeal of all the laws and for a CPSA motion calling for a review to see which laws should be retained, which amended and which repealed.
Gradually the TUC had abandoned making policy on union rights and handed it over to the Labour Party. The Labour Party's policy reviews of 1989 and 1990 now commit it to retain key parts of Tory legislation.
Sequestration is to remain though it would stop short of total confiscation of a union's resources; ballot would be modified but its essentials remain; solidarity action will remain illegal; secondary picketing will be permitted only where the second employer was "directly assisting the first employer to frustrate the dispute"; sympathy action will be legal only where the second employer was taking over the work of the first employer or where the outcome of the dispute would "necessarily or probably" affect terms and conditions; the freedom not to join a union will be officially recognised.
The 1990 TUC Congress accepted Labour's proposals and hence central aspects of Thatcher's legislation.
cilroy doesn't accept this as the best way to attack the legislative edifice, although he is unequivocal about the need for a Labour government at the next election.
What he argues for is the labour movement to take the initiative and fight for positive rights. The positive right to organise, to bargain, to strike, and to picket. Such an approach could be linked to the demand for wider constitutional reform, particularly reform of the judiciary and new methods tor adjudicating industrial disputes. It could assert a new social legitimacy for trade union purposes.
With trade union membership having declined from over 12 million to 8.5 million under Thatcher, the new industries of the 21st century looking at this stage as though they may be relatively union free, and the composition of the working class also being significantly reordered, the time for a positive, assertive, and imaginative fight for union rights is critical.
Neither the imagination nor the fight will come from Norman Willis or Neil Kinnock.
Mcllroy's book will assist workers who want the background to, and the detail of, the anti-union laws introduced over the past 12 years, and hopefully help in the construction of a militant pro-working class fight back.
----- pull-quotes -----
million - that's the prospi for several years to come.
"When CP turn-
ed to the policy of the popular front... the unemployed struggles declined.
ran: gains for PLATFORM
"Political economic democracy ar the resolution the present crisis is impossible
capitalist regime."