Ann Summer
Socialist Organiser1991 1991-08-15Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 7 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 7
graphy as that which attempts to separate sex from love, "to avoid any feelings of tenderness or warmth accompanying the sexual stimulation."
Most feminists would probably agree with this rather neutral view, but would want to add other, political, points to give a fuller definition. If it was as simple as Skynner makes out, we would just feel sorry for those people who use it Pornography, for example, is an industry, motivated by profit. It is not in the interests of the porsexual herd dudes in ople to dye joy real intimacy — sales would drop! Pornography is also a component part of an ideological system (both capitalist and sexist) which defines women as "other" seen in terms of male desires.
This ideology both derives from and props up capitalism, which relies on the family and women's subordinate role in it. Pornography is an element in Western society and traces of pornographic imagery are found throughout that society.
Maria Exall attempts to isolate pornography from the system which promotes it, and having isolated it, argues that a "ban" is possible and desirable. Either this is an unrealistic demand, raised in order to win people to our ideas, or it is wishful thinking.
It would be possible, for instance, to "ban" pornographic magazines, but this would probably quadruple the circulation of underwear catalogues! Because pornography influences so much visual imagery, society is saturated with pictures of women with a pornographic or voyeuristic "angle"
One could not hope to ban all such images.
Even if there was a committee somewhere in Whitehall which could sift through images of women and reject all those which portray female availability — would we want it to? Apart from the dirty mags, these pictures of women are part of the whole visual imagery of human society. I would like to see the balance redressed, to see images of women which are not about women as the "other" and do not put the viewer in the position of the male voyeur.
But I would not want to be A Women's Fightback pamphiet E3 E1 plus 32 pence p&p from Women's Fightback, PO Box 823, London SE15 4NA denied images to a greater or ed by the ide Human sexu: beyond the morality, and pleasure in : would also ob When atten people the ideologically those images, system. Caj much unwho and we are ce but even capil to the depths There is a evidence whi control and imagery is a l ruption.
If it were t be changed allowed to se for them the would have People are ca between wha tures and in the people, b ween ideo behaviour is ward.
Having sa: not argue nography, or demand mo women. We: lifting of ba lesbian and f But if the st powers over read it is like used against pression 'undesirable ly that rom:
nographic (which are ' proliferate, feminist ero out.
This is a do think "w choose what harm other"
which perve proclaiming Tory rhetor have what v capitalism fr the few.] socialists wa men picket sex shop in Marble Arch of women which are, lesser extent, informeas of pornography. ality is complicated reaches of feminist so it is possible to feel an image which we ject to politically. apts are made to give images which are correct, and only it is a sign of a rotten pitalism pushes too lesome imagery on us, rtainly corrupted by it, talism has not yet sunk of "socialist realism" regrettable body of ich shows that state banning of incorrect good indicator of cortrue that society could by people only being e things that are good n Stalin's 5-year plans been a wild success. pable of distinguishing t they are told, in picwords, and material reality. Not all the time, and not all a1 hasi and nat all ut the relationship betlogy and people's far from straightforid all of that, I would in javour of porsay that we should not re positive images of should also demand the ick-door censorship of gay images and erotica. tate were given greater what we could see and ily that power would be greater freedom of exfor those with " sexualities. It is likeantic or soft-core porheterosexual images "good for us") would and lesbian, gay and tica would be stamped libertarian argument. I ve should all be free to : we wish that does not . It is the Tory rhetoric erts this principle, by what is untrue. The ic which says we can ve want is a lie! Under ree choice is reserved for Free choice is what int - for everybody. I only mind sharing the Tory si of free choice because I know have stolen it and perverted it Socialism is not about creat society where a committee de what I can and can't loo Socialism would bring with it s flowering of both culture and uality that I think the most g offensive images would be p aside in favour of images show the whole human exper not just a tiny, warped part o is also the case that a socialist ty would choose not tc voyeuristic images of women shampoo!
Coming down to earth "Pornography cannot be isolated ment, should we argue that pornography should be banned in the meantime? I can see no reason for it. I do think we should take every opportunity to agitate against it, to demand that it is not served up with the breakfast cereal, and that dirty mags are wrapped in brown paper and labelled "degrading images of women, to be read by sexual failures only" . There is a case for demanding that public funding of culture goes to people who show positive views of women, so that women (and men) are able to reject "girlie" pictures in favour of something better.
Maria Exall says that "real women are not like this, sex is not like this" , ie. not like women and sex are portrayed in pornography. If that is true, there is no case for banning pornography because it has no effect. I think that many women are affected by the ideology of pornography - perceiving their own sexuality as primarily passive.
Many women are brought up to see themselves in the male gaze, their sexuality dormant until turned on by a man. This result of ideology is stifling for women, and needs to be challenged, both through alternative views of women, and through campaigns against the porlogan they ling a ecides kat. such a d sexrossly ushed which ience, f it. It socie• use to sell
ADULT VIDEO incl
Tape Centre nographic view. Many women see through pornography, see that it does not represent real sex, real women, but the all-pervasive ideology is not so easily escaped.
Maria does not say that women are unaffected by pornography, but nowhere does she really analyse how banning pornography would neutralise its effects. She says that women would gain "much freedom" from a ban on pornography - freedom from the economic necessity of prostitution? unpaid childcare? male violence? No. Women would only gain the limited relief of not having to pretend not to notice the Sunday Sport. That would be a nice thing to happen. But women can win that freedom without handing the state yet more power to tell us what we can and can't look at.
I do not want to suggest that women should wait for socialism when pornography will simply disappear. We should campaign against it (in all its forms) now. We can win limited concessions from the state in this area, but those concessions should be for greater freedoms, not less. We should demand an end to exploitation in advertising, and access to alternative images. Tied to those campaigns are campaigns for material enefits for women, which will change all women's position in society.
Pornography cannot be isolated from the society which supports it and no talk of "power structures"
"bourgeois patriarchy" will e that. The fight he tight For nography women's liberation. Liberation is about freedom, and freedom is not something which can be won by a series of unrelated negative "bans", It is a sad fact that feminism is becoming politics of control, ot "banning" of a rather reactionary morality. Feminists have started to tell us what is "good for us" and are "re-presenting" the concept of crime-thought in a new and alarming light.
Merely because some women want to ban pornography (under the banner of feminism rather than morality) is no reason to switch off our brains, dump scientific and critical reasoning and jump onto the bandwagon. President (Further Education Union Development)
abour's annual Youth Conference will be held in Morecambe, 15-17 November. Delegates attend from Young Socialist (LPYS) branches, Labour Student Clubs (NOLS) and trade The Labour Party organisers at Walworth Road have decided that the conference will be twice as big as last year's - guaranteed by doubling delegate entitlements. It would never occur to the student Kinnockites who own the "Labour Youth" franchise, to double the size of the conference by doubling the size of youth organisations on the ground.
Labour has a youth organisation in name only and does virtually no campaigning among young people. Consequently, few youth join the Party and many young potential Labour voters will not turn out to the polls.
The Kinnock bureaucracy is incompetent. But they also have a real problem: any open, campaigning Labour student or youth organisation whose leaders reflect the members, will be left-led. Radical youth, who would make up the members of a democratic youth organisation, did not support the Gulf War and are not pleased with Labour councils sending bailiffs against Poll Tax non-payers.
Labour Students have reaped the reward of years of bureaucratic mismanagement: a middle-class rump which does nothing except serve as a school for careerists.
The LPYS has effectively not existed since 1987. The bureaucrats lowered the upper age limit to 22 and increased the numbers needed to set up an LPYS branch to 10; in the constituencies, YS members were witch-hunted. The Militant, who had been running the LPYS like the semi-Stalinists they are, found the heat too great, and left to do their youth work outside the Labour Party. Now the LPYS exists virtually nowhere.
It is time to change that. It is time to start campaigning and building LYS branches. Youth, students and young workers must begin to take up the opportunities to organise - even within the bureaucratically limited structures - in the run-up to the General Election. The political situation will open up a little as we move to the election. We must take up the basic issues: the fights against racism, unemployment, slave labour schemes to both fight for youth rights and rally young people to Labour.
For socialist speakers for your LPYS meetings, write to: Maria Apruzzese, c/o West Yorkshire NUS, Brunswick Building, Leeds Poly, Merion Way, Leeds.
Scan page 8
Bank of Crime and Co
----- pull-quotes -----
The case for Socialist Feminism
POF THE RA
from the society which supports it.
unions; observers from Consti- tuency Parties without LPYS's.
Young Socialists has effectively not existed since 1987."