John McCarthy and British hypocrisy
Socialist Organiser1991 1991-08-15Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 3 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 3
Jubilation over the release of John McCarthy is understandable. We share it wholeheartedly.
The record of his friends implacable loyalty, and their determined activity over five years to gain publicity for his plight and to win his release is a truly inspiring story.
Of course the press Is now diminishing the story of Jill Morrell's loyalty to her friend by trying to cram it into the mould of a conreMmnDan Ladmmirn Wner erer Engleton Intin spria ilsaimr B1 aR kESec tinsi Dorothy Mecedo Joen Marino John ME Iroy Ubhna dictiblisps Peter Tatchell Members of the Advisory Committee ar drawn from a broad cross-section of the ty's witch hunt against Socialist Organiser. Views expressed in articles are ih oheh Adursor E WE ventional romance, for which they demand an immediate conventional "happy ending". That is to be expected.
But not even the all-dirtying tabloids can dirty the tale of friendship and loyalty, which cuts so sharply against the cash-on-the-nail philosophy now dominant in the Britain Thatcher made. It shows up their philosophy for the anti-human crap it is.
The return of John McCarthy throws a glaring light on another aspect of Britain too: the prison system. "The prison system backs up a monstrous system of 'justice' in which the say-so of self-perjuring policemen sends people to these hell holes."
What a glaring contrast there is between the care and concern for McCarthy's psychological wellbeing after 5 years incarceration, and the treatment given to 50,000 prisoners in Britain's hell-hole jails!
Of course, McCarthy suffered special stress and uncertainty, and was a pure victim who had done nothing wrong to merit imprisonment. But the recent spate of proven cases of police making up evidence suggests that a lot of people in British jails are no less innoçent.
McCarthy's experience has much in common with the experience of Britain's own prisoners.
Up to 50,000 men and women (a quarter of them under 21) are locked away in hellish conditions. They live in terrible overcrowding. They get wretched food. Most of them are locked away for all but a couple of hours a day. Most are left to rot with no occupation. With their liberty go old sexual relations and activities. They are beaten and brutalised by warders.
The law of the jungle prevails among prisoners: "inside" the hard men and women rule and terrorisation, bullying, sexual abuse are the norm.
Most of the inmates of Britain's jails are there for crime against property, much of it comparatively petty. Many of them need psychiatric care, not punishment. Nothing is done to rehabilitate prisoners for a return to normal life.
In short, the British prison system ranks with such things as the army of homeless youngsters thronging central London as a major blight on British civilisation. A future better time will look back on what is now done to many tens of thousands of people with the same feelings of disdain and incomprehension with which we look back on the prison system 150 years ago when people were imprisoned for debt.
But it is even worse that that: the prison system backs up a monstrous system of 'justice' , in which the sayso of self-perjuring policemen sends people to these hell-holes.
Let us say it plainly: in the system we have now, the police routinely decide on whether someone is guilty (or a suitable frame-up victim) or not and then manufacture "evidence' to get a conviction in court.
This happens all the time, everywhere in Britain (or at least in the cities). That is what happened with the Birmingham Six, for example: idiotic scientists decided the Six men had traces of explosive on their hands (in fact, it seems, traces from a pack of playing cards!) and then the police beat confessions out of them. It is only an extravagantly monstrous example of routine police procedure.
..this system thousands and thousands of often very vulnerable people - or entirely innocent people - into psychological ruin, and most people Britain turn a blind Our hell-hole prisons are filled by lying, thuggish police and irresponsible, caste-minded judges (remember Lord Denning's public statement that it was better to leave wrongly convicted men to rot in jail for the rest of their lives than to give them a belated justice that would discredit the British judiciary?
Together with the vicious criminals, this system grinds thousands and thousands of often very vulnerable people — or entire= innocent people- into psychological ruin — and most people in Britain turn a blind eye.
There is enough evidence now, publicly available of both the corrupt nature of our police and judicial system, and of the savage, torturing, antirehabilitatory na ure of the prison system, to make the turning of blind eyes one of the most shameful facts of contemporary British life.
The psychological care given to John McCarthy tells you a great deal about British society and its positively medieval double"The emancipation of the working class is also the emancipation of all human beings without distinction of sex or race."
Karl Marx • Pagemiser PO Box 823, London SE15 4NA Newsdesk: 071 639 7965 SeboTIEN MondeN dobwOlMiaheny IDnS LN 0 PO Box 823, Landon SE15 4NA pi eo Registered as a newspaper at the Post Office Articles do not necessarily reflect the views of Socialist Organiser and are in a personal capacity unless otherwise
Scan page 4
Into the time warp Tory MPs in the closet vote for homophobic legislation. 'Outing" those MPs would not have helped the campaign against Clause 28 one bit.
Could this be 1991? Surely, scenes like this belong the dark, Fordist age of the 1970s? Haven't Marxism Today and the Financial Times assured us that the days of the mass meeting, the megaphone and the militant majority are long-gone, killed off by the Glorious Actually, it wasn't exactly like the old days: for a start, the sun was shining and the field wasn't either frozen or a mud bath (employers used to ensure that disputes always started in winter). And the show-of-hands vote was called "indicative" , prior to a ballot. And the action being called for was not an all-out strike but a work-torule and overtime ban. But still, it was enough like the old days to warm the cockles of my Fordist old heart.
The dispute was that most worthy of all possible disputes: victimisation. The place was KN's Hardy Spicer plant in Birmingham. The victims were two union activists accused of pocketing the takings from the work social club, but cleared of all charges by the Birminghan GKN sacked them last November and now say that they won't be reinstated, regardless of the Crown Court So 600 out of a possible 1,000 of these men's workmates met in a field outside the factory, to discuss the situation and give an "indicative" vote on action. The vote was unanimous and I hope and believe that the But the point here is that despite all the Marxism Today theorising about the "end of the working class", and despite more reputable evidence from the government's Employment Gazette (to the effect that recorded strike action is presently at its lowest level since 1942), industrial militancy is still far from dead.
The Tory legal offensive has taken its toll and the economic recession of the early '80s has now been followed up by the recession of the early '90s — with predictable results in terms of strike statistics as recorded by the Employment Gazette. What we are now facing is "War of Position" between Labour and Capital, in which negotiated settlements, compromises and deals are the order of the day. The low strike statistics are misleading because most disputes presently involve the threat of strike action, or action (like overtime The "Waiting for Kinnock" factor is also of importance: most union officials are presently counselling caution in order not to jeopardise Labour's chances at the next general election. Whatever the outcome of that election, union militancy is bound to rise: if Labour wins, trade unionists will be faced with an incomes policy in one shape or form; if the Tories win, we can expect an all-out fight for basic trade union rights.
Meanwhile, good luck to the workers at Hardy Spicer Some readers may have been a little taken aback by explain: Mr Dromey wants to be Deputy General Secretary of the TGWU and is eminently qualified to fulfil that role. His close links with Neil Kinnock and the Labour leadership will facilitate full co-operation between the TGWU and any "National Economic Assessment" that a future Labour government might have to Jack Adams, on the other hand, is one of the old breed of ex-shop stewards who still cling to the outmoded idea that representing "the membership" should take precedence over the prospect of a future Labour government: T&G branches should nominate accordingly.
-TEES woke up today to find INSIDE myself in a time warp:
I was in a field, THE: UNIONS surrounded by hundreds of industrial workers, while a union official ant then a convenor and ther a Labour MP shouted at us through a crude PA system.
The sense of deja vu was completed by a show-ofhands vote before we dispersed either back to Sleeper work, down the pub, or home to sleep off the night shift.
Thatcher Counter-Revolution?
Peter Tatchell and 494) seem to argue that whilst 'outing' in general a bad idea, that in the case of those attacking lesbians and gays, it is justified. I would like to disagree.
Crown Court last month. "Outing' celebrities - pop stars, actors, sports personalities — is simply wrong.
A person's sexuality, and decsion. how they choose to express it, is their own business. 'Outing' a celebrity opens them up to abuse and often physical harrassment, and ballot will produce a similar result. denies them the very important, personally liberating experience of coming out for themselves.
It would not matter if there hi never been one single famous person who was gay = our struggle is for only freedom in our bans) that does not show up on the statistics. everyday lives.
*These are principles that we hold dear for friends, family and workmates. To abandon them for celebrities is to go along with the notion that loss of privacy is the price of fame'. Every low-life you're not the past, you're the future! tabloid hack's justification for snooping, muck-raking and gossip.
The tabloids themselves have outed many celebs over the years - Russell Harty, Maureen Colquhoun, Pam St. Clement, Elton John -making their lives a nightmare, and frightening introduce. ordinary people premaring to come out.
Is 'outing' really any different? any less of a callous invasion, if lesbian and gay activists or socialists do it?
We object to the way that tabloids glibly push genuine X 36 :
LESbA MOTE news aside to make way for voyeuristic peering into people's private lives. So why give them the material to do it? Our justified denunciations of tabloid scum "journalism' lose all credibility when we write their storylines.
But what of celebrities as positive rôle models? A positive rôle model for young lesbians and gays is a person who is lesbian or gay and proud of it, not someone dragged kicking and screaming out of the closet. Famous rôle models misses the point. We want equality and liberation for all. We fight bigotry and homophobia because of its effects on the lives of ordinary lesbians, gays and bisexuals. It would not matter if there had never been one single famous person who was gay — our struggle is for freedom in our everyday lives.
A more controversial area for lesbian and gay activists is the outing of those closet cases who positively harm our struggle - Tory MPs who vote for homophobic legislation, judges who criminalise our sexuality. 1 believe that this is also wrong - that the above reasons hold true, and that it is a tactical mistake. The case for outing these people is that it betrays them as hypocrites and traitors to the lesbian and gay community. But I do not accept that they are part of our community in the first place. Being lesbian, gay or bisexual is good and positive and something to be proud of. I do not want a bigot - even a sad, self-oppressed one — to share the identity that is for so many people an assertive statement of our rights.
The problem with such people is that they are bigots, not that they are closets, so let's tackle their bigotry. Is a homophobe who is a closet worse than a homophobe who is straight? I don't think SO.
It is also argued that outing gay Tories exposes the vital class differences between lesbians and gay men - that there are those who share our sexuality who will never share our struggle for lesbian and gay liberation and for overthrowing the system that bestows them with such privilege. This is a crucial point that needs to be explained and won politically. There are already more than enough 'out and proud' gay Tories. Let's expose them for their politics, before exposing their Tory colleagues for their A positive role model, famous Derek who is proud of being gay STEV sexuality.
I remember a headline in the short-lived "left-wing" newspaper, News On Sunday: 'Spanker Proctor Resigns'. Why not "Tory Proctor Resigns'? 'Racist Proctor'? Vile Bigoted Rightwing Toe-rag Proctor'?
Even if it were possible to construct a socialist case for outing, we could not control the way people respond to it. There are those who would add homosexuality to their reasons for hating the Tories. It would boost the idea that homosexuality is an upperclass recreation, a sad scene of double lives and anonymous encounters. And it would open the door wide open to an orgy of tabloid persecution of everyone and anyone they don't like.
But don't Tory MPs "deserve' outing? Quite possibly, but they probably deserve shooting as well, and few people claim that would take the struggle forward.
"Outing' is a tactic born of desperation. It stands in a vacuum, and could not form a basis for a mass campaign. It is a retreat from even the ambition of building a mass movement. It is a retreat from the need to bring politics back into the lesbian and gay movement.
Jarman)
Scan page 5
Right-wing thugs confront the police outside the hall where De Klerk was 3 racists dead, 1 black murdered, 3 policemen shot "addressing the local bourgeoisie" Organiser
----- pull-quotes -----
Adw/nsory Eidlitomad Boand
the debate around 'Outing Janine Booth continues
DISCUSS cialist Organiser No. 495 page 4 WHOSE RIGHTS
NEXT STCP YOURS
OUT AND PROUD