The case for censoring pornography
Socialist Organiser1991 1991-08-08Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 14 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 14
aannaa Pornography consists women are like this, sex is like this. Pornography presents unreal images of women and their sexuality (and men's sexuality for that matter).
It degrades sex as well as degrading women.
Our sexuality as women is kept under more repressive social control than men's -though ultimately both men and women and the relationships between them suffer as a consequence of this inequality. Given this unequal power structure it is of crucial importance that women have positive images of sex and their own sexuali ty to counteract the narrow role defined for them by bourgeois patriarchy.
Women are not intimidated by explicit sexual images or descriptions of sexual fantasies. But we are threatened by images that presume a sexist ordering of society.
By re-presenting men's power over women in images of women as alldesirable, all-available, ever responsive to men, in short, public property for the use of men, pornography reinforces the status quo and keeps women "in their place".
But real women are not like this, sex is not like this. To be critical of the way sex is represented in porthink that Steven Holt was a little too uncritical of 1871 in his review in last week's SO (493). Engels claimed the Paris Commune of 1871 as the first dictatorship of the proletariat.
While only shortlived it demonstrated PERZI wolken own name and in their own interests and create a new, better society. It is undoubtedly one of the most important events of the last 150 years.
Its savage repression by the French army, in which over 30,000 men and women were systematically murdered in only seven days, demonstrated the extraordinarily brutal and bloodrographic images se anti-sex.
Censorship of pornography is criticised by those who see it as attacking the problem of sexism at the wrong place ie. attacking the symptom, not the cause - and consequently unworkable.
And some see censorship of pornography as opening the way for the abuse of state power against minority groups.
These criticisms are important and must be taken seriously, but neither of these criticisms is conclusive against restricting pornography by law.
The question of censorship goes wider than the law. A sexist society censors women's expression of themselves - their free choice and their sexuality. We already have censorship, both of this kind and in the interpretation of obscenity and indecency in law; these are usually interpreted in a sexist and heterosexist way in order to make judgements on, and penalise, those who "deviate" from the so-called norm.
Much freedom for women could be gained by legislation to restrict pornography, although ultimately the removal of all sexist images (pornographic or not) will only happen when we have created a non-sexist society. Pornography is a symptom, yes: a symptom that reinthirsty means that the ruling class were prepared to adopt in order to defend their rule.
The Catholic Church built the magnificent Sacre Cour as a monument to the soldiers who butchered the Communards.
It's a tragedy then that Ken McMullen's 1871 is such a confused, deliberately obscure attempt to capture the spirit of Paris in the period leading up to the revolution.
The action predominantly focuses on a small theatre company, but the film's nonnaturalistic style and slow pace make for difficult viewing.
McMullen couldn't really have wanted a wide audience for 1871 as it is virtually impossible to understand unless one has the most intimate
SDAPBOX
forces men's control over women's environment, a symptom of our hypocritical society that is happier with negative, furtive, "not-infront-of-the-children" notions of sexuality than any open expressions of sexuality that show the variety of human sexual being.
Banning sexist images
does not create a non-sexist society, but we should be aware of too simplistic a dismissal of the challenge to a propaganda fight.
Pornography has a place in the system of ideas and culture arising from an exploitative society. An ideological challenge is not mere abstract speculation, but is a struggle to win over people's understanding.
In other areas, the fact that we are only attacking the symptom not the cause is no argument against legislation, neither is the fac that the aim of the legislation is unworkable.
Health and safety legislation is unworkable in practice in a capitalist economic system. Capitalism is the cause, unsafe working practices are the symptom, but attacking the symptoms has improved the health and safety of workers.
What about the argument that any legislation will lead to power being used against such groups as lesbians and gay men It is undoubtedly true thai police will pursue with greater vigour any infringements by lesbians and gay men of any law. Already lesbian and gay writings are seized and obscenity laws are applied ludicrous situations.
What this means is that any legislation must protect the rights of lesbians and gay men to express their sexuality. We are socialists and not anarchists. We believe that the law can be used as tool to seek concessions from capitalism and a way of building for socialism.
If pornography is about sex — defining it in such a way as to maintain unequal power relations - then lesbians and gay men have little to gain from a society that gives licence to the pro liferation of pornography.
The experience of liberalisation and deregulation in the 1980s has been that it has increased the power of the already powerful against those who had a small amount of power. There is no guarantee that increased liberalising of pornography legislation will be beneficial to lesbians and gays.
A small market in images that show a variety of sexual experiences and question sexual orthodoxy may be encouraged, but the mass marketing of blatant heterosexist images will be the more significant result.
The danger of handing the state legislative power to censor certain images is that the harmful negative images we wish to see removed will not be the same ones that much of the bourgeois establishment and popular prejudice wish to act against.
This is not an argument against legislation. It is an argument against legislatio that has no safeguards for lesbians and gay men. ideal that we should he liberal bourgeois all be free to choose what we wish that does not harm others is very similar to the Tory rhetoric of individuals competing as free agents harmonizing in the free market. It totally ignores the political realities of economic power in the situation.
There is a danger that by advocating no censorship we go along with an individualistic libertarian ethic that has no place in a socialist society. The sort of freedom that we as socialists should be about is less to do with "free choice" and more to do with access to free choice.
In our present society free choice means free choice for some at the expense of others. To ignore the power relations between men and women when considering restrictions on free choice is to ignore political realities. In order to be free to choose, we have to control our own lives. For women to be free to choose we mus have control and this means being free from being controlled.
Our sexuality is kept repressed: to be free from negative images of sex and sexuality especially at a time of vulnerability such as childhood is surely a prerequisite to growing up free to choose.
As socialists we support working people taking control - not just putting up with how things are.
When working class men and women take a stand and say they are not putting up with being exploited or degraded, we support them. When women take a stand against pornography because it exploits and degrades them, we must support them.