A right-on Robin
Socialist Organiser1991 1991-08-08Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 13 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 13
An antidote to Neighbours stereotyping Tony Brown reviews "Robin iews Hood: Prince of Thieves" Thieves Robin Hood is both in the Pradition of and a drier ture from, earlier portrayals of the 12th century outlaw of Sherwood Forest.
There are no real plot surprises which is only to be expected. What is interesting is that this version is rooted in the 1990s.
From the very first scenes in the Jerusalem dungeon to the final flower-child wedding in the forest, what we get is a modern, political/psychological, right-on, anti-authoritarian play.
For a film-maker, myths both constrict and allow great freedom. The basic storyline has to be told, but that story is so widely applicable that it can be moulded to explore new ideas.
Certainly Errol Flynn didn't need to take account of a feminist Lady Marian. Indeed, In the 1930s she was Maid Marian - perhaps a different translation from the original? Richard Greene relied on his own wits and made do without a black Moor as his right hand man.
And neither Flynn nor Greene gave a second thought that their noble origin should be questioned as something that artificially separated them from their salt of the earth comrades.
But in between sword-fights, derring do, romance and oppressive plunder by the evil Sheriff of Nottingham, we reflect on these and other important questions.
Returning from the Crusades to find his father murdered and his lands stolen, Robin is outlawed after defending a young boy who has stolen a deer from the loathsome Guy of Gisborne.
Forced to flee into Sherwood Forest he encounters a rag-tag bunch led by Little John, who he beats in a quarterstaff fight, and eventually stays to lead the men in their fight against injustice, official forces to end the conspiracy of fear. • If ever a set of women needed to learn to fight back, it was these women, their whole lives fenced in by fear - fear of rape, fear of the stigma of rape.
But "Shame" didn't really provide answers for them. At the end, they joined up and were pressuring the police for action, but only after Asta had stirred them up. Had she never turned up, they'd probably have gone on as they were, miserable, angry, but resigned.
Asta was like some superwoman - articulate, forceful, game, able to defend herself against a gang of men, schooled in the law. How many women could live up to that?
"Shame" was a different kind of fantasy, but a fantasy all the same, a feminist revenge fantasy that didn't tackle why rape happens, but merely kneed therapists in the balls. pillage heavily system:
Robin considers the Crusades wrong, an adventure against the Muslims that should never have been waged. Through his experience he has become an anti-militarist, though not a pacifist. He embraces Azeem, his fellow escapee, as an equal and discovers from his wisdom, new technology and a new form of birth delivery (I told you this was a modern interpretation).
The core of the Robin Hood myth remains the same — a simple fight back against oppression. It is necessary to take from the rich to redistribute to the poor in order to right the wrong. It is a simple evocation of socialism.
In order to make the point crystal clear, the oppressor - the Sheriff of Nottingham - is drawn as heartless, tyrannical and bloodthirsty, and Alan Rickman (the Germanic terrorist leader of Die Hard I) gives us a very camp, satanical Sheriff.
I was reminded of Neil Kinnock who, only days earlier, had said that 'the Labour Party does not and never will support breaking the law' . At the time I wondered about his attitude to those who had refused conscription to fight in Vietnam.
But as I sat in the Enfield Cannon, I realised that Kinnock would have supported the Sheriff of Nottingham and called for a stiff sentence for Robin before expelling him from the Sherwood branch.
Forget the mean-spirited criticism of Kevin Costner's accent and instead enjoy the garrulous bon viveur Friar Tuck, the tormented Will Scarlett, the fat, corrupt Bishop and the heroic Little John.
And there is of course the romance between a newly-assertive Lady Marian and a sensitive Robin.
It's all there, including a famous cameo King Richard who suddenly appears so he can give Marian away (well, it's not all new-age) typifying the good humour of the film.
kept silent And the rest have had enough. But next day there waves again The red flag of the proletariat On the engineering works roof Again Thuds through the dead-still town The stormtroopers' tread. In the yards There are no men to be seen now. Only women Stand with stony faces; hand shielding their eyes, they g At the roof through the flurr of icy rain.
And the beatings begin once more. Under interrogation The women testify: that flag Is a bedsheet in which We bore away one who yesterday.
You can't blame us for colour it is.
is red with the murde man's blood, you sho know.
THE LAST In Altona, when they raided.
working-class districts They caught four of our people.
For their execution Seventy-five were dragged along to watch.
This is what they saw: the youngest, a big chap, when asked His last wish (in line with standard procedure)
Drily said he wanted once to stretch his limbs.
Freed from his bonds, he stretched and with both fistsHit the Nazi commander on the chin With all his strength. After which they strapped him To the narrow board, face upwards, and cut His head off.
January 1933: Hitler comes to power because the German working class movement did not mobilise its united strength to defeat him.