Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Workers' dictatorship

Socialist Organiser no. 494, 8 August 1991 · scan pp. 11–12 · about 2,476 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 11 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 11

It is the threaten now. Re former chi says: stop a fascistic coup - they organised it!

itself from abolition."

The Crown still retains an unfettered legal authority to dismiss an elected government, dissolve an elected House of Commons, and precipitate a general election at any time it chooses. To do so it need only call upon its prerogative powers as used by the Governor General of Australia when the Labour government of Gough Whitlam was dismissed…..

*All cabinet ministers derive their executive authority, in its legal sense, not from election as leaders of the majority party in the Commons, but as members of Her Majesty's Government, formed by the prime minister at the Crown's invitation...But the courts and the armed forces swear allegiance to the Crown and not to the elected government."

Though Benn's writings are of great value in opening the eyes of the broad labour movement to the realities behind the parliamentary facade, none of this is very startling to Marxists. For example, Trotsky wrote this in Where is Britain Going? in 1925:

Labour Parta leaders, does not the terfere' with the country's progress... The royal power is weak because the instrument of bourgeois rule is the bourgeois parliament, and because the bourgeoisie does not need any special activities outside of parliament. But in case of need, the bourgeoisie will make use of the royal power as a concentration of all non-parliamentary, ie. real forces, aimed against the working class.

Tony Benn sums up:

*The democratic rights the of people can, in a crisis,. ad- be judicated to be illegalin exlegitimising the military inguishing them" (from 'Britain as a Colony', in Arguments Jor Socialism.

ruling class who will the democracy we have ad what lan Gilmour, a ir of the Tory Party, "Conservatives do not worship democracy. For them majority rule is a device...Majorities do not always see where their best interests lie and then act upon that understanding. For Conservatives, therefore, democracy is a means to an end, not an end in itself.

*In Dr Hayek's words, democracy 'is not an ultimate or absolute value and must be judged by what it will achieve . And if it is leading to an end that is undesirable or inconsistent with itself, then there is a theoretical case for ending it. 'Numbers in a state' , said Burke, 'are always of consideration, but they are not the whole consideration'. In practice no alternative to majority rule exists, though it has to be used in conjunction with other devices.

Listen to the brutal truth expressed by Bonar Law, Tory leader during a Tory/landlord revolt against a Liberal government (and later a prime minister): *There are things stronger than parliamentary majorities"* On the eve of World War 1, sections of the British ruling class and the army, and the entire Tory party, raised a storm of revolt against the Liberal government's decision to give Ireland Home Rule. There was an officers' revolt in the British army in Ireland. They armed and drilled a large - Orange - private army (with German guns).

They succeeded. They forced the Liberal government to abandon its plan to solve Ireland's British problem by way of an all-Ireland Home Rule parliament. Eventually, partition and all that has flowed from it was the direct result of the Tory revolt. Listen to Bonar Law again: "We regard the government as a revolutionary committee which has seized I upon despotic power by fraud. In our opposition to them we shall not be guided by the considerations or bound by the restraints which would influence us in an ordinary constitutional struggle..l can imagine no length of resistance to which Ulster can go in which I should not be prepared to support them, and in which, in my belief, they would not be supported by the overwhelming majority of the British peon e When Lenin here talks about "dictatorship" he means the rule of class, not the rule of a Hitler or a Stalin. He sees "the dictatorship of the proletariat" as a great expansion of democracy. This is an abridged version of Lenin's "Theses on Bourgeois Democracy and the Dictatorship of the Proletariat", adopted by the Founding Congress of the Communist International in March 1919 Faced with the growth of the revolutionary workers' movement every country, the bourgeoisie and their agents in the workers' organisations are making desperate attempts to find ideological and political arguments in defence of the rule of the exploiters.

Condemnation of dictatorship and defence of democracy are particularl prominent among these arguments. The falsity and hypocrisy of this argument are obvious to all who refuse to betray the fundamental principles of socialism.

First, this argument employs the concepts of "democracy in general" and "dictatorship in general" , withos posing the question of the class concerned. This nonclass or aboveclass presentation, which supposedly i popular, is an outright travesty of the basic tenet of socialism, namely, its theory of class struggle. For in no. civilised capitalist country does "democracy in general" exist. All tha exists is bourgeois democracy, and it not a question of dictatorship in general", but of the dictatorship of the oppressed class, ie. the proletariat over its oppressors and exploiters, ie. the bourgeoisie, in order to overcome the resistance offered by the exploiter in their fight to maintain their domination.

History teaches us that no oppresse class ever did, or could, achieve powe without going through a period of dictatorship, le. the conquest of political power and forcible suppression of the resistance always offered by the exploiters - a resistance that is most desperate, mos furious, and that stops at nothing.

The bourgeoisie, whose domination is now defended by the Socialists who denounce "dictatorship in general" and extol "democracy in general", won power in the advanced countries through a series of insurrections, civil wars, and the forcible suppression of kings, feudal lords, slaveowners, and their attempts at restoration.

In books, pamphlets, congress resolutions, and propaganda speeches socialists everywhere have thousands and millions of times explained to the people the class nature of these bourgeois revolutions and this bourgeois dictatorship.

The most democratic bourgeois republic is no more than a machine fo the suppression of the working class by the bourgeoisie, for the suppression of the working people by a handful of capitalists.

It was Marx who best appraised the historical significance of the [Paris] Commune [of 1871]. In his analysis, he revealed the exploiting nature of bourgeois democracy and the bourgeois parliamentary system under which the oppressed classes enjoy the right to decide once in several years which representative of the propertied classes shall "represent and suppress" the people in parliament.

The significance of the Commune, furthermore, lies in the fact that it endeavoured to crush, to smash to its very foundations, the bourgeois state apparatus, the bureaucratic, judicial, military, and police machine, and to replace it by a self-governing, mass workers' organisation in which there was no division between legislative an executive power. All contemporary bourgeois-democracy republics, including the German republic, which the traitors to socialism, in mockery d the truth, describe as a proletarian republic, retain this state apparatus. We therefore again get quite clear confirmation of the point that shouting in defence of "democracy is actually defence of the bourgeoisie and their privileges as exploiters.

*Freedom of the press is another of the principal slogans of "pure/ democracy". And here, too, the workers know - and socialists everywhere have admitted it millions. of times - that this freedom is a deception while the best printing presses and the biggest stocks of pap are appropriated by the capitalists an while capitalist rule over the press remains, a rule that is manifested throughout the world all the more strikingly, sharply, and cynically, the more democracy and the republican system are developed, as in America for example. The first thing to do to win real equality and genuine democracy for the working people, for the workers and peasants, is to deprivi capital of the possibility of hiring writers, buying up publishing houses, and bribing newspapers. And to do that the capitalists and exploiters have to be overthrown and their resistance suppressed.

The capitalists have always used the term "freedom" to mean freedom for the rich to get richer and for the workers to starve to death.

In capitalist usage, freedom of the press means freedom of the rich to bribe the press, freedom to use their wealth to shape and fabricate so-called public opinion.

In this respect, too, the defenders ol "pure democracy" prove to be defenders of an utterly foul and venal system that gives the rich control over the mass media. They prove to be deceivers of the people who, with the aid of plausible, fine-sounding, but thoroughly false phrases, divert them from the concrete historical task of liberating the press from capitalist enslavement.

Genuine freedom and equality will be embodied in the system which the communists are building and in which Lenin there will be no opportunity for amassing wealth at the expense of others, no objective opportunities for putting the press under the direct or indirect power of money, and no impediments in the way of any workingman (or groups of workingmen, in any numbers) for enjoying and practising equal rights in the use of public printing presses and public stocks of paper.

The imperialist war of 1914-18 conclusively revealed even to backward workers the true nature of bourgeois democracy, even in the freest republics, as being a dictatorship of the bourgeoisie. Tens of millions were killed for the sake of enriching the German or the British group of millionaires and multimillionaires.

The main thing that (Reformist] Socialists fail to understand and that constitutes their shortsightedness in matters of theory, their subservience t bourgeois prejudices, and their political betrayal of the proletariat is that in capitalist society, whenever there is any serious aggravation of the class struggle intrinsic to that society, there can be no alternative but the dictatorship of the bourgeoisie or the dictatorship of the proletariat. Dreams of some third way are reactionary, petty-bourgeois lamentations. That is borne out by more than a century of development of bourgeois democracy and the working class movement in all the advanced countries and notably by the experience of the past five years.

This is also borne out by the whole science of political economy, by the entire content of Marxism, which reveals the economic inevitability. wherever commodity economy prevails, of the dictatorship of the bourgeoisie that can be replaced only by the class which the very growth of capitalism develops, multiplies, welds together, and strengthens, that is, the proletarian class.

Proletarian dictatorship is simirar ne the dictatorship of other classes in it arises out of the need, as every dictatorship does. the resistance of the class that is losin its political sway. The fundamental distinction between the dictatorship of the proletariat and the dictatorship of other classes - landlord dictatorship in the Middle Ages and bourgeois dictatorship in all the civilised capitalist countries — consists in the fact that the dictatorship of the landowners and bourgeoisie was the forcible suppression of the resistance offered by the vast majority of the population, namely, the working people. In contrast, proletarian dictatorship is the forcible suppressio of the resistance of the exploiters, ie. an insignificant minority of the population, the landowners and capitalists.

It follows that proletarian dictatorship must inevitably entail no only a change in democratic forms ar institutions, generally speaking, but precisely such a change as provides al unparalleled extension of the actual enjoyment of democracy by those oppressed by capitalism — the toiling classes.

The substance of Soviet governmen is that the permanent and only foundations of state power, the entire machinery of state, is the mass-scale organisation of the classes oppressed by capitalism, ie. the workers and semiproletarians (peasants who do no exploit the labour of others and regularly resort to the sale of at least part of their own labour power). It is the people, who even in the most democratic bourgeois republics, while possessing equal rights by law, have i fact been debarred by thousands of devices and subterfuges from participation in political life and enjoyment of democratic rights and liberties, that are now drawn into constant and unfailing, moreover, decisive, participation in the democratic adminstration of the state The old, ie. bourgeois democracy and the parliamentary system were so organised that it was the mass of working people who were kept furthe away from the machinery of government. Soviet power, ie. the dictatorship of the proletariat, on the other hand, is so organised as to brin the working people close to the machinery of government. That, too, is the purpose of combining the legislative and executive authority under the soviet organisation of the state and of replacing territorial constitutencies by production units — the factory.

The army was a machine of oppression under not only the monarchy. It remains as such in all bourgeois republics, even the most democratic ones. Unly the soviets, the permanent organisations of government authority of the classes that were oppressed by capitalism, in a position to destroy the army's subordination to bourgeois commanders and really merge the proletariat with the army; only the soviets can effectively arm the proletariat and disarm the bourgeoisie. Unless this is done, the victory of socialism is impossible.

Only the soviet organisation of the state can really effect the immediate breakup and total destruction of the old, ie. bourgeois, bureaucratic and judicial machinery, which has been, and has inevitably had to be, retained under capitalism even in the most democratic republics, and which is, in actual fact, the greatest obstacle to the practical implementation of democracy for the workers and the working people generally. The Paris Commune took the first epoch-making step along this path. The soviet system has taken the second.

Destruction of state power is the aim set by all socialists, including Marx above all. Genuine democracy, ie. liberty and equality, is unrealisable unless this aim is achieved. But its practical achievement is possible only through soviet, or proletarian democracy, for by enlisting the mass organisations of the working people in constant and unfailing participation in the administration of the state, it immediately begins to prepare the complete withering away of any state.

That proposal indicates the complete ideological bankruptcy of the theorists who defended democracy and failed to see its bourgeois character. This ludicrous attempt to combine the soviet system, ie. proletarian dictatorship, with the National Assembly, ie. bourgeois dictatorship, utterly exposes the paucity of thought of the Yellow Socialists and Sociall Democrats, their reactionary petty-bourgeois political outlook, and their cowardly concessions to the irresistibl growing strength of the new. proletarian democracy.

Scan page 12

Bulgarian troops and dead after an assault on a Turkish fort in the war of 1912 Socialist Organiser No. 494 page 12 TIT HE NEW

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 494

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →