Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Has Benn abandoned hope?

Socialist Organiser no. 494, 8 August 1991 · scan p. 9 · Danny Nicol · about 935 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 9 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 9

notebonk MICHAEL DAVIE

PLATFORM

t is sad that Tony Benn should have spent five years preparing something that is gift to Labour's enemies.

He claims (Campaign Group News, June 1991) that his Commonwealth of Britain Bill will "establish popular sovereignty". But his Bill, which provides for a written constitution, is just what the Liberals always lobbied for, later the SDP, and now as Liberal Democrats.

It's a sad example of Tony's inveterate populism that he has jumped on the bandwagon of Charter 88 with seemingly no conception of the horrendous implications these changes would have for the struggle for democratic socialism.

Tony's proposed constitution will enshrine a High Court with responsibilities which include the safeguarding of the Commonwealth Constitution". This is absolute folly. It means - indeed, any written constitution means — that the courts are able to declare legislation invalid if they believe it falls outside the confines of the constitution. Given the record of the judiciary and how they are likely to interpret constitutional provisions, there is no case at all for giving them the opportunity, carte blanche, to nullify progressive legislation.

Our present constitution is based on the doctrine of Parliamentary Sovereignty. (A doctrine admired by many other countries with different systems.) Parliament is the supreme law-making body and its Acts cannot be challenged in any court of law. In other words, the courts must enforce statutes, they cannot question their validity.

This keeps judges out of the political arena which is essential for Labour governments. No-one familiar with, for example, the case-law on industrial conflict, for example during the miners' strike, can doubt that legislation which set the unions free from the Tory anti-union laws would fall foul of a High Court.

This is so even though Tony suggests, with the eclecticism which pervades his Bill, that the judges be nominated by a President and confirmed by a Commons committee. Just look at the United States, where the Supreme Court only this month ruled, against the wishes of elected representatives, that legislation to give information about abortion is unlawful.

In Britain, subordinate legislation and administrative actions are not subject to Parliamentary Sovereignty, and are therefore amendable to judicial review. Remember how Ken Livingstone's "Fares Fair" policy was held to be illegal when attacked in the courts by Bromley Council. It's ludicrous to go out of our way to ensure Tony Benn that Labour Acts of Parliament should suffer a similar fate.

Tony claims that "the House of Commons is a shell concealing its political impotence against the Executive". But there is another side to this argument: the right of the British people to elect a government with the power to govern, and which they can hold accoun table. Britain needs a strong socialist government, resolute in carrying out its policies. A decadi of Thatcherism seems to have lef some socialists running scared of strong government.

Of course the balance between the executive and legislature isn't right. Backbench Labour MPs should have more power. At the same time they should be more accountable to the Party membership for the way they use it.

The Campaign for Labour Party Democracy (CLPD) has long campaigned for changes in the Parliamentary Labour Party that would bring this about. What Tony is proposing, however, is a USA-style Separation of Powers, a system of checks and balances, fitted to administer capitalist society and obstruct the efforts of future governments to shift wealth and power in favour of working people.

The Queen's constitutional posi tion is to be abolished, replaced by a President elected by Parliament. This policy would be highly unpopular with the British public; but — as important — it's also a case of failing to see the wood for the trees.

The last time the Royal Assent was refused was 1707. The prerogative powers which Tony complains of have long ceased to be exercised by the monarch. They are now a Prime Ministerial prerogative in all but name. Removing these powers, or at least making them subject to a Commons vote, has nothing to do with the Queen, and is a matter of changing the balance of power between government and Commons. To bring the Queen into it merely obscures this fundamental issue.

Tony suggests a second chamber, "elected in such a way as to represent England, Scotland and Wales in proportion to their populations" with delaying power of one year. This is a retreat from the left's traditional policy of abolition of the House of Lords in favour of a sovereign House of Commons. Having it elected in a different way from the Commons invites a clash between the two.

A second chamber endowed with the legitimacy of popular election would have considerable moral and political authority in standing up to a House of Commons prepared to pass radical laws. No wonder it's embodied in the Policy Review as official Labour policy!

Although some of the measures in Tony's Bill are desirable, they are outweighed by the dangers involved in a written constitution, placing future Labour governments at the mercy of the judiciary.

I fear that - consciously or unconsciously — Tony has abandoned any hope of a socialist government coming to power through existing constitutional channels. He has fallen victim to the present climate of despair which seeks refuge in building constitutional castles in the air.

Rather than attempt a thorougl going analysis of why the left lost the battle for the Labour Party and how it can learn from its mistakes, Tony's proposals sidetrack the depleted forces of the left into channels which can only give succour to the capitalists.

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 494

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →