Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

What prospect foi a Palestinian state?

Socialist Organiser no. 494, 8 August 1991 · scan p. 7 · about 1,570 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 7 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 7

Adam reports Aviv sraeli prime minister Yitzhak Shamir has drawn a series of defensive lines. When he has to retreat, he withdraws to the next line.

For a long time, Shamir demanded that there would not be a United Nations representative at any peace conference and that any conference would be a one-off event.

Now Shamir has given up on these demands. But he is arguing about Palestinian participation. He insists that there should be no Palestinian representation from East Jerusalem.

His argument is: Israel will talk only to Arabs of Judea, Samaria and the Gaza Strip; we will not talk to anyone from East Jerusalem because this is part of Israel.

The arrangements for this peace conference are in fact very unfair to the Palestinians and the PLO. They have no right to a delegation of their own. They have been forced to accept a second-class status.

The Palestinians seem to be having to accept the idea of a joint Jordanian-Palestinian delegation. There are many Palestinians in Jordan. In fact the Prime Minister of Jordan is a Palestinian.

Palestinians as part of a Jordanian delegation could be interpreted as being representatives of the Palestinian diaspora.

But the Palestinians are also insistent about the East Jerusalem question. If Palestinians from East Jerusalem are ruled out this means Faisal Husseini, a spokesperson for the Intifada, will be unable to attend. In fact, many of the people who have been at the recent discussions with James Baker will be unable to attend.

The Israeli government will object to any diplomacy which implies that the Palestinians are an independent entity.

The Israeli press has reported Shamir as demanding that only Jordanians on the Jordanian delegation will have speaking rights: the Palestinians will not have speaking rights. Also, Shamir wants to see the Jordanian speech in advance. He wants to make sure that "PLO" is not mentioned.

The next stumbling points are: who, exactly, will receive the invitations?

Will the Palestinians? If so, which Palestinians? How will the Jordanian-Palestinian delegation be formed?

It is more or less decided that the joint convenors of the conference will be the USA and the USSR.

The negotiations will be conducted the following way - there will be one or two days of plenary sessions.

Then the conference will divide into five working groups. Israel will have separate talks with Syria, Lebanon, Saudi and the Gulf States and Palestine-Jordan. The fifth group will discuss general regional problems.

The traditional Likud position has been that it is better to have separate direct negotiations between Israel and each one of the Arab states than to have a conference where all the Arabs are together. The official reason is to isolate the most extreme positions.

The unofficial reason is to divide the Arabs.

There are two issues: the Is Shamir backtracking?

Israeli occupation of the Golan Heights and southern Lebanon.

The price Assad got from the US in return for his support during the Gulf War, was a free hand 1n Lebanon. Assad wants Lebanon as Syrian satellite. Historically, syrian nationalism has cepted Lebanon's independence. They regard Lebanon as artificially constructed by French colonialism. In fact, Syria's attitude to Lebanon parallels Iraq's attitude to Kuwait.

But Assad is a cautious man. He is not trying to formally annex Lebanon. He wants to give the appearance of co-operation between two sovereign states. He is setting himself up as the arbiter of internal Lebanese politics.

To achieve his ends, Assad favours a Lebanese army which has real power over Lebanese territory. But the extension of Lebanese army power southwards first brought them into conflict with the PLO, then with the Israeli-run South Lebanon Army (SLA)

After the Lebanon war, the Israeli declared security zone in South Lebanon controlled by the SLA. Assad hopes for US pressure to get Israel out of South Lebanon.

Israel has already declared that it will not negotiate with Syria about Lebanon.

The second issue for Israel and Syria is the Golan Heights. A few days ago, Syrian Foreign Minister, said the US had promised pressure to get an Israeli The Americans have denied this. But the US has also said that they never recognised the occupation of Golan.

Of course, big questions behind all this are: What, exactly, What, exactly. does America want? and how much pressure are they prepared to exert?

It seems clear that they are determined to see this peace conference convened.

Firstly, it is the personal concern of Bush and especially Baker. It will be humiliating if they fail.

The immediate problem is the question of East Jerusalem. It is possible that the first stage of the negotiations will agree some sort of autonomy for the Occupied Territories from which East Jerusalem will be excluded and their representatives will not take part in these initial negotiations.

It is possible that there are some conflicts between the Palestinians - between the Arafat leadership looking for diplomatic openings, and the Palestinian leadership in East Jerusalem. People like Faisal Husseini have been under a lot of pressure from the Palestinian public who regard all the manoeuvring with great suspicion.

I understand that Faisal Husseini's life has also been threatened by the Islamic fundamentalists.

An opinion poll published recently in an East Jerusalem Arab paper suggested 60% Arab opposition to talks with Baker. There is the strong feeling that it is always the Palestinians who are asked to compromise Israeli settlements. It is clear that the US will not demand an end to the building programme as a precondition for talks. Saudi-Arabia has offered to begin trading with Israel if the building programme is ended.

Inside Israel there is of speculation about elections. The positio Labour Party is that if the extreme right try to break up the government to stop the negotiations, Labour will back Likud in order to maintain the talks. Labour's position has, so far, held the government together.

However, Labour's position is ambiguous. It is very right wing on the question of the Golan Heights. Most of the settlers there are Labour kibbutzniks. On the other hand, the Labour Party is very pro-American.

Mapam and Ratz have fallen in behind the Americans.

If Shamir is leaning towards withdrawal from the Occupied Territories, he could do it with the current internal political line-up. Will Shamir do it? This depends on the Americans and no-one knows their attitude for sure.

Leaders of • Socialist organiser will be pleased to learn that the Israeli authorities have dropped proceedings against Adam Keller which were started when Adam spoke alongside a PLO member at the November 3 Campaign Against War in the Gulf conference in London.

Adam had deliberately broken the Israeli law which prohibits con tact with the PLO.

Adam Keller is E Other Israel* -digest.

sure informatio 0 Bus 156, Tel Ari, 60N Takeo Shin from the Socialist Workers' Party of Japan repor on the tasks and prospects for the stages since World War I!

As everyone knows, Japan, along with Germany, leads the world economy. The ruling class, and the Liberal-Democratic Party (LDP) as its political spokesperson, are using this "chance", trying to "complete" Japan's development as a newborn imperialist state.

Last April they sent a minesweeper and troops to the Gulf on the pretext of defending Japanese oil tankers. Japan's constitutional ban on sending any military force abroad was broken for the first time since the War.

The LDP also want to seize the chance for political reformation, including the introduction of a new electoral district system. We also see a drive for patriotism in education and reactionary laws against foreign workers. We must struggle against every single policy of the LDP.

However, the Japanese which was relatively radical in the past, is now "reflecting" of its "socialist" past and trying to "renew" itself as a "sensible" op position just like the Kinnockites. The JSP was totally defeated in the local elections last April, and that is accelerating its rightward shift.

The Japanese Communist Party (JCP), which has 400,000 members is also rotten to its core. After the Gulf War they issued this statement: "The US military action on Iraq had a certain significance to liberate Kuwait". According to the JCP the Gulf War was a "just war"!

But the JCP, like all Stalinist parties, is in a great crisis since the revolutions in Eastern Europe and the USSR. The JCP had kept up fraternal relations with the Romanian Communist Party, calling Ceaucescu "com rade" until just before the revolution in 1989.

The majority of the JCP members began to criticise their leadership, and the whole party has been thrown into chaos.

This party, which still demands "Japan's real independence from the US" and "reform within the capitalis system" with "respect for the present constitution" is doomed to collapse sooner or later.

Infortunately, most of New Left groups, desperate at this difficult situation, have escaped into various minority movements, abandoning the strug gle in trade unions.

The most typical of these movements is the one against the expansion of the New Tokyo International Airport. They are struggling to ise near there it ted peas nig working class. Moreover, : atical sects have ki than undred activist Б7Is. le sects aire - rockets perial Palace and so Is of workers hat is the on an as well as

----- pull-quotes -----

he question now is Twhat will Syria do?

Japanese left apanese politics is now

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 494

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →