Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Getting away with murder

Socialist Organiser no. 494, 8 August 1991 · scan pp. 6–7 · about 797 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 6 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 6

Science in the Origins, Causes, and Consequences of Stalinism in the g the cause of scientific socialism - TIADHSOCCSUSSROC Iso while the G7 Summit was in progress the US Budget Director, Richard Da man, announced that America's budget deficit for next year is expected to rise to a record $348 billion.

Taking a line from Norman Lamont, he reassured those millions of unemployed that the recession is almost over, recovery is just around the corner. It's a very big corner.

Symposium '90 USSR and Other Countries.

GUSTAVE DUON AI lecture The more sprightly ex"Communist" leaders are adapting to capitalism pretty well.

For the workers in East Germany, it's tougher going. A West German glossy magazine, entitled Schönes Leben (Beautiful Living) has found sales in the East so poor that it has launched a separate eastern edition - entitled simply Leben (Living).

INAUGURAL LECTURE TONI PROFESSOR YEFIM PIVOVAR (Pro-Rector, Russian State University of Humanities)

introduced by meIT COLLEGE LONDON WOMENTS-EMEI Millward The Court of Appeal has decided (based on sound legal precedent no doubt that if you say to your friends that you will kill someone, and you write slogans denouncing that person around your house, and you do kill the person, you cannot then argue that you committed the crime during a momentary loss of control.

Thus you are sent down for murder, rather than the lesser offence of manslaughter.

I am not a lawyer, but Court of Appeal seems have applied fairly sound reasoning, assuming, of course, that all the alleged events are true.

However, the woman now serving a life sentence for murder committed under these circumstances feels that the law has treated her very badly.

Her argument for having committed manslaughter rather than murder is that she was regularly beaten by the man she killed, who was her husband. She further suggests that if her husband had killed her as part of his violent behaviour he would probably have "got away" with manslaughter.

This assertion is strengthened by another case this week where a man killed his drunken and nagging wife and was allowed to plead guilty to manslaughter. The judge accepted his argument that he had temporarily lost control and had not intended to kill his wife — and he has not been sent to prison.

There is no doubt that the courts treat men and women differently. I have a nasty suspicion that a woman who killed her husband would get a longer sentence than a man who killed his wife even when all the other were the same.

But I am alarmed by the arguments surrounding the Court of Appeal case. The woman in the case admits she killed her husband but says she should be allowed to plead manslaughter because of his violence to her.

In the second case, a manslaughter verdict carried no prison sentence, so had the woman received the same treatment, she would have "got away" with it, and not be facing life imprisonment. The logic of the argument is that the woman should be "allowed" to kill her violent husband without having to go to prison.

Various campaigners around the case have generalised from this, substituting "women" and "violent men" for "this particular woman and her husband". In other words, under the banner of feminism there are groups of women campaigning for the legal rights of women to kill their violent husbands, justifying themselves by saying that men have got away with killing nagging wives for centuries. This is all upside down and back to front! !

Women should be entitled to the same rights under the law as men. And that applies to the victims of male violence as much as the perpetrators. So a man who kills his "nagging" wife should not "get away with it" by being able to plead that he was provoked into losing It is this change in judicial practice which would being us closer to equality, not a change in the law to allow a history of violence to justify a manslaughter-because-ofprovocation plea.

Society also makes it easier for a man to leave his "nagging" wife than the victim of a violent husband to leave him. It has taken decades of campaigning to get domestic violence taken at all seriously by the police and the law. Women's refuges are disgracefully underfunded, and the legal advice and service and emotional support they provide should be much more widely available. No woman should have to kill her husband to escape Men have got away with murder for centuries, but that is no reason to extend the injustice to women.

Scan page 7

EHIND THE NEV iser

----- pull-quotes -----

"PERESTROIKA HISTORICAL SCIENCE

PROFESSOR VITALY LELCHUK (Institute of History, Academy of Sciences USSR)

VANESSA REDGRAVE Tuesday May 14th 6.30 pm GUSTAVE TUCK THEATRE

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 494

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →