Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Outing: telling the truth or an invasion of privacy?

Socialist Organiser no. 494, 8 August 1991 · scan pp. 4–5 · about 1,591 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 4 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 4

and the "Groupleader" (GL) concept.

The motor industry seems to be particularly prone to industrial Newspeak, so it was refreshing to read (in Trade Union News) a carworker sum up what all these fancy concepts really mean: "Bullshit!"

*The real reasons for GLs are: (i) to reduce supervision; (ii) to weaken/eliminate shopfloor organisation an trade union influence; (iii) to be party to, and party of, cost-cutting....through combining parts of separate job Other names associated with this process are "team working", "flexibility" "versatility" ', "multi-skilling" and "quality circles". It all amounts to the same thing: concerted employers' offensive to introduce "Japanisation". The precise details vary from company to company, but in general "Japanese work methods" involve abolishing traditional skills demarcations, introducing "teams" and "quality circles" that by-pass existing union structures, and appointing "Groupleaders" from the shopfloor, to "lead" groups of three to 12 workers and monitor quality, job performance, etc.

The package is often accompanied by single union no. strike deals and accompanied by "sweeteners" like improved wages, consolidation of bonus payments and These methods were pioneered in Britain by Nissan at its greenfield site in Tyne and Wear. When Isuzu took over the Bedford van plant at Luton (now IBC) in 1987, a similar agreement was forced in, using the threat of closure to ensure acceptance (by the narrowest of Vauxhall has been easing Japanese methods into its Ellesmere Port plant since 1986, and Ford is bringing in the Groupleader concept at Halewood. The response, even from militant shopfloor trade unionists, has tended to be that "Japanisation" is now inevitable and the best that can be done is to attempt to limit the worst excesses of the new working methods and maintain basic union structures alongside (or within) them. This is essentially the approach that has been adopted by the unions at Ellesmere Port. The problem with this response is that it concedes victory to the employer in advance.

In fact, the battle against new working methods is far and gay movement needs more than good stunts. It needs from lost. A recent (unpublished) study by one Michael Cross, a "visting fellow at Manchester Business School", suggests that the new methods have yet to gain widespread acceptance in British manufacturing plants.

While there has been an increase in multi-skilled team working, it is only from 0.75 per cent in 1981 to 2.75 per cent in the first quarter of this year. And only 22 of a sample of 405 plants in which new working methods have been introduced have developed "world-class" flexible working patterns compared to those in Japan and the All of which is not to underestimate the difficulties faced by shopfloor activists, especially in the recession-hit motor industry. There may, indeed, come a point at which we have to accept that outright opposition is no longer viable and instead attempt to negotiate the best romWorkens' Nos. 1-14 - £15, post deal possible under the circumstances. But that point hasn't (in most cases) been reached yet. Despite all the Workers' Liberty Nos.1, Workers' Liberty Mr J Dromey - an apology 2, 7-13 - £5, post free Bpok! Service Other publications: A mail order service for in last week's Sleeper column it was suggested that Jack Dromey, Public Services Secretary of the Transport and General Workers' Union, was a Feminism (published by eurent shameless careerist, motivated by personal ambition and 8 pamphlets for just E5 Women's Fightback) E1 plus Special Introductory the desire for high office. It was further suggested that Mr Dromey's decision to withdraw his candidature for the position of Deputy General Secretary of the union (Organising for Socialism; made a revolution 60p plus Revolution? Conservative was a mere ploy designed to further his long-term plans A Stancl 32 post law and the trades unions We now accept that there is not a scintilla of truth in these statements. Mr Dromey's decision to re-submit his rotter anderle ouistsi Ei і рим кр From WLBS, PO Box 823, candidature is conclusive proof that he is a selfless, socialist answer; New FUSE London SE15 4NA. Cheques dedicated servant of the labour movement whose integri struggien ritentoneu Bou 8KE anen is beyond question. We wish to unreservedly withdraw ondoni S 06 4MAx Chennes Workers' Liberty. For full these allegations and apologise for any distress and em- ase for Sociale nu remmism; Foria full publications list hat old misery-guts a few things wrong in THE UNIONS 1984 but he was dead right about "Newspeak"

These days, insurance Kevin Sexton talked to salesmen are "financial Peter Tatchell about the advisers" , and PR men recent furore in the are "image consultants"

Press over the "outing"

In industrial relations all the talk is of "Human of closet gays Resource Management" (HRM), "Quality of By Sleeper One major tabloids. uting has been in all Working Life" (QWL)

The "Faggots Rooting Out Closeted Sexuality" (FROCS) used a hoax outing of prominent public figures to show up media hypocrisy when it comes to respecting people's private lives.

Peter Tatchell said that in allocations, and so on." general he opposed outing.

He would support outing when lesbian and gay public figures advocate policies damaging to the homosexual community. "If lesbians and gays in public life are not actively harming our community, then it's their decision whether or not to come out; that decision should be left up to them"

Tatchell believes that the FROCS campaign provided much-needed debate. The normally brutal tabloid press was very cleverly manoeuvred shorter hours.

into condemning outing and defending a person's right to privacy.

Tatchell believes that what the tabloids said will make it much more difficult for them margins). to continue with their own savage "outings"

Would Tatchell support the outing of Tory MPs as a tactic during the General Election Campaign? Yes, against those Tory MPs who have a record of voting for anti-lesbian and gay legislation.

He believes that there are strong moral arguments in favour of the outing tactic.

Why, he asks, is it wrong to tell the truth about a person's sexuality? No-one comolains if a public figure's heterosexuality is discussed.

One of the key issues behind this campaign is Freedom of Speech. People shouldn't run the risk of libel suits for simply stating the fact that certain well-known celebrities are lesbian and gay.

US. The recent Jason Donovan decision to sue the "Face" magazine for libel is collusion with homophobia.

By suing the "Face", Donovan is effectively saying that there is something terribly wrong with being described as a homosexual. bullshit. *I'm not Jewish, but if someone described me as being Jewish, I wouldn't bother denying it; there is nothing wrong with being Jewish"

Peter Tatchell thinks it is extraordinary that it is still considered defamatory under British law to say that a person is gay.

Tatchell insists that instead of attacking the outers, the for self-advancement. heterosexual hypocrites should be attacking society's homophobia, which forces lesbians and gays to hide their sexuality. Tatchell cites as examples the outing of Peter Mandelson, the Labour Party Publicity guru, Allan Roberts, the late MP for The lesbian to organise within the labour movement Bootle and Maureen Colquhoun, MP for Northampton North in the 70's.

Tatchell believes that the vulnerability of certain closet gay and lesbian Labour MPs could become politically very important.

"There are several quite - postaines Liberty; Eastern Europe:

towards capitalism or War in the Gulf; Lenin and enDictederı R senior MPs who are either lesbian, gay or bisexual. They could be exposed by the tabloid press whenever Murdoch and friends choose. It would be far better for them to come out voluntarily to avoid the risk of being involuntarily exposed by the Complete cunor The Case for Socialist 32 post Offer 1917: How the workers plemsras Struggles (a handbook for payable to SO. sleazy tabloids.

*These people have been Labour MPs for more than a decade and are well-established in their own constituencies and have rocksolid majorities; they can easily afford to come out."

Campaigns such as outing cannot be part of a vacuum. The tactic of outing should be used during mass campaigns.

Peter Tatchell raises important points about the tabloids, and their hypocritical lip-smacking response to mass outing.

Personally, I believe that Tory MPs who voted for and will continue to vote for legislation such as Paragraph 16 and Clause 25 should be outed by lesbian and gay activists.

However, l believe that Tatchell places unjustified faith in the FROCS campaign's ability to force the tabloids to be more cautious regarding discussion of homosexuality. The Murdoch and Maxwell press will continue to expose and use people's sexuality when it suits them.

For socialists, the most important issue to face in the coming months is the General Election. We must support and build a lesbian and gay movement which carries out more than press stunts. We must organise within the Labour Party to force the leadership to commit itself to the repeal of Section 28, Section 30 (Clause 25 previously) and all homophobic legislation passed under the last twelve years of the Tories But that can only be done by an organised mass Labour movement-based lesbian and gay movement.

Get out! Get active! Get even!

Peter Tatchell send a SAE to the address socialist and labour laborme row ne renon £1 off publisher's price -E8.95 post free!

details of the Book Service Send aisAt to Wids

Scan page 5

iocialist Organiser No. 494 pag

----- pull-quotes -----

parrassment caused to Mr Dromey and his family. OUT AND

INSIDE Or well may have got PROUD

espechadnoliens libenty free

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 494

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →